weemadarthur
Member
(Psst....Faddy, who I've given evidence against, is actually in the cage)
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Arkham Asylum Mafia |OT| It's time to kill the Bat
- Thread starter franconp
- Start date
(Psst....Faddy, who I've given evidence against, is actually in the cage)
Zippedpinhead
Member
Except we literally can't choose from those all of those three. We have the following people to chose from:
Faddy, fireblend, flame_AC and verelios.
Those are our options today. Like I said, if I could vote for you I would weemadarthur, since I'm sure you are scum.
Zippedpinhead
Member
I believe Faddy WAY more than you right now...
yeah, we can see your attempts to get a lynch train against Faddy going
its been going for a while now
weemadarthur
Member
Do you have a response to the actual argument I made?
I am doing work in rereading the thread, and reviewing the posts of known flips to reevaluate their gameplay.
I will have data on the other lynch possibilities tomorrow if I can manage it. Faddy was just the first to come up chronologically.
Discussing the four possibilities would be an excellent use of the day.
You haven't made any actual claims against Faddy.
You just keep bringing up how you think they should be lynched.
and then this, which honestly makes no sense to me whatsoever considering it was day one:
your assumption of Faddy being scum comes down to acohrs listing them town on day one.
anything else?
You just keep bringing up how you think they should be lynched.
and then this, which honestly makes no sense to me whatsoever considering it was day one:
your assumption of Faddy being scum comes down to acohrs listing them town on day one.
anything else?
weemadarthur
Member
No, that's it.
Just looking back at what known scum has done.
Haven't yet evaluated much else regarding Faddy. Actual post content from him, etc.
I do realize it is a small argument, but it is an argument. After work tomorrow I will attempt to find more arguments for our thunderdome. Then I will watch the contributions from players and place a vote on my personal opinion of the scummiest, and you'll be able to see why I did it.
And then Faddy told me acohrs was someone worth lynching yesterday.
If the scum team was going to do a sacrifice of some kind, why would they lean town towards Robin and not Batman? If they sacrificed Batman, they would of had a chance to night kill two towns last night thanks to Robins ability.
I may be simplifying your point on Faddy here a bit, weemad, but it's a thin claim to say the least (especially with no other reads to back it up).
If the scum team was going to do a sacrifice of some kind, why would they lean town towards Robin and not Batman? If they sacrificed Batman, they would of had a chance to night kill two towns last night thanks to Robins ability.
I may be simplifying your point on Faddy here a bit, weemad, but it's a thin claim to say the least (especially with no other reads to back it up).
weemadarthur
Member
Duder, I'm a sub-in with a pre-built thunderdome against zippedpinhead hanging over my head. I been here five hours...I'd like to think I'm contributing as I can.
Achoo WAS worth lynching yesterday. Busing is normal. I find that post....inconclusive. I have no clue what Batman has/hasnot got in a role. But I'd really like to kill him as a followup to my last Batman game.
I offer much better SICK READS on people I've played with before.
Achoo WAS worth lynching yesterday. Busing is normal. I find that post....inconclusive. I have no clue what Batman has/hasnot got in a role. But I'd really like to kill him as a followup to my last Batman game.
I offer much better SICK READS on people I've played with before.
And yet it only took me 20 minutes to get my sick read on you.
I'm weighing up whether I want to clarify or not.
It is quite fun watching them squirm. This might be a rare situation where less information is better for town.
AbsolutBro
Member
His "accusations" are literally 100% supposition. I mean, he not only made up a role for me that is counter to both what I have claimed and what I have shown, but also made up my results and my actions taken on those made up results. What exactly do you expect me to do to prove that wrong? It's all made up with 0 evidence. So I respond with as much substance as the accusation holds in the first place.
Yes, and instead of attempting to counter his points you elect to hand weemad more defense.
Ok let me make it simple. There are two main accusations against you
1. Why did you role claim with zero information on day 2? As a watcher it would have been more useful to stay hidden
2. Today you claim you forgot to watch when scum have clearly targeted the two obvious players, that very suspicious
AbsolutBro
Member
Counter what points? The points that he made up based on things that didn't happen?
And "hand weemad more defense"? I tried to explain in simple terms what took almost half a page of discussion to stumble around on. Apologies for trying to offer clarity, I guess?
it's 0130, i'm going to sleep now.
AbsolutBro
Member
was going to sleep but I'll answer this first, then crash.
1. I didn't role claim. I offered one sentence in case I died, so I could pass on my results like any town PR should do.
2. Yeah, I fucked up. I have a lot of shit going on and thought day phase started tomorrow. I even PMed a command to Fran from the grocery store about 30 minutes before day started, knowing it was probably way too late. I obviously can't prove it, since I know he can't come in and confirm, but at least I came out and admitted it. If I were scum I would have had two days to work with my scum team to make up some sort of working bullshit. "Zomg I targeted so-and-so and this other person was the only person to target them" Be a perfect segue into "zomg there must be a ninja on the scum team!"
Instead I threw out about the most suspicious thing I could possibly have thrown out. Either the most ludicrously stupid gambit ever from a team that just lost a second scum member, or a simply fuck up. You decide.
I can understand you putting Faddy out of the zone, but why not Fireblend? I can roleclaim but it's unprovable and unlikely to yield y'all much information.
That was me.
Fireblend is a gut town read for me, but all it really is is gut. That's why I said at the moment, it's conceivable that I could end up voting for him.
I haven't really focused on him much, would like to go back and have a read through his posts today.
Yeah sorry, I'm a bit lazy right now
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 5 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
Verelios (2)
Faddy 2653
Bronx-Man 2755
Fireblend (1)
Penguin 2806
Flame_AC (1)
Verelios 2673
No active vote for Day 5: AbsolutBro, CCS, Fat4all, Fireblend, Flame_AC, Lone_Prodigy, weemadarthur, Sorian, Timeaisis, Zippedpinhead
Day 5 Postcount: AbsolutBro 8, Bronx-Man 2, CCS 3, Faddy 33, Fat4all 35, Fireblend 1, Flame_AC 12, Lone_Prodigy 7, weemadarthur 17, Penguin 7, Sorian 11, Timeaisis 8, Verelios 20, Zippedpinhead 9
Day 5 ends:
Automated vote tally here
8 votes for majority
Verelios (2)
Faddy 2653
Bronx-Man 2755
Fireblend (1)
Penguin 2806
Flame_AC (1)
Verelios 2673
No active vote for Day 5: AbsolutBro, CCS, Fat4all, Fireblend, Flame_AC, Lone_Prodigy, weemadarthur, Sorian, Timeaisis, Zippedpinhead
Day 5 Postcount: AbsolutBro 8, Bronx-Man 2, CCS 3, Faddy 33, Fat4all 35, Fireblend 1, Flame_AC 12, Lone_Prodigy 7, weemadarthur 17, Penguin 7, Sorian 11, Timeaisis 8, Verelios 20, Zippedpinhead 9
Day 5 ends:
Automated vote tally here
8 votes for majority
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Penguin, why Fireblend?
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Here's the quote from AB I was thinking of.
Hey L_P, I know you want everyone to know you aren't scum and I am just jumping to conclusions. It was only a small defense of AB's name claim after all. Perhaps I'm wrong about you.
However what do you think of my deduction AB and nudull/wma have both lied to try and confirm themselves as town.
What's good every-
No, I'd shoot you in the head in the middle of the night and be proud of it. Working for my lynches is so 2016.
No, I'd shoot you in the head in the middle of the night and be proud of it. Working for my lynches is so 2016.
Did my obligatory light skim. You dusters trying to solve are the best. I remember when I was into things like that. All I care to comment on is lol at AB not telling me if I was roleblocked or not and lol at weemad trying to spook people with worries of a lynched when there is no trace of a lynched anywhere in this game.
My eyes glazed over but I'll give it a 6/10. I think my guess at scum team looks better, maybe we can talk about it tomorrow.
That is only the first sprinkling of stuff. I'm saving the good bits for later.
weemadarthur
Member
..
Last edited:
weemadarthur
Member
But aren't ya glad I didn't say "godfather" again? That was another season.
Zippedpinhead
Member
Is weemadarthur still ok, or does that fall under the any variation of arthur? I've got no problem addressing the one who opposes me how they choose.
weemadarthur
Member
My full name, which I bestowed upon myself, is always acceptable.
Thank you for asking.
I should check that you don't dislike being called Zippy? I actually have permission to call acohrs Achoo.
Zippedpinhead
Member
My full name, which I bestowed upon myself, is always acceptable.
Thank you for asking.
I should check that you don't dislike being called Zippy? I actually have permission to call acohrs Achoo.
I prefer zipped or the full name. Zippy is this weirdo...Zippy the Pinhead
weemadarthur
Member
That was an interesting read! I really like the programming bits.
Is it where you get your username? Mine is a literary reference.
Also, no faddy vote love?
Faddy, I've gone back and forth on you. Initially I was suspect, but then you played pretty soundly as town, but then yesterday you were on me pretty good and suggested some weird Sorian protection shenanigans. With none other than Nudull (now weemad).
What was your reasoning there, if I may ask?
Vote: Faddy
Faddy, I've gone back and forth on you. Initially I was suspect, but then you played pretty soundly as town, but then yesterday you were on me pretty good and suggested some weird Sorian protection shenanigans. With none other than Nudull (now weemad).
What was your reasoning there, if I may ask?
Vote: Faddy
Haha, this is quite the 180 then.
Hey man, I respect you as a player. You have the experience, you're just scummy and don't post enough for my tastes.
You know he got one of them right? Did you hold back a night 3 check from us or are you just mixing it up?