As for Roman Reigns, this honestly isnt about his wrestling ability any more. And thats a problem in-and-of itself, because whats wrong with him is so much larger than his in-ring ability (which is fine). The question becomes who cares about his in-ring ability, because everything else is so dire when it comes to his character, his presentation, and his very presence. Even the more mark-based, casual Corpus Christi crowd cant muster up a reason to chant for him. They chant USA. Roman is literally the USA guy insert in this feud, like Titus ONeil just was, only without a build-up to Uncle Sam attire. And its not just a Corpus Christi thing, as he was getting the faint USA chants (again, not Roman chants) when he first insert himself into Rusev and the United States Championships orbit. If thats still not a sign that whatever WWE is trying to do with Roman isnt working, then nothing is.
Reigns wins a match (a great match that is also marred by terrible bookinggo figure) that shouldnt even exist, both because it effectively kills anticipation for a match six days away and because it paints him as the hero for refusing to apologize for disrespecting another mans (a colleagues) wife. Rusevs character (who is pretty much a what you see is what you get kind of guy) doesnt even want an apology for himself, just for his wife. Hes the villain? Give me a break. The one consistent in Roman Reigns character as a singles wrestler is that hes a selfish guy who doesnt respect or care about anything. One Versus All, you know? As its presented, his feud with Rusev isnt about defending the United States (unlike with John Cena, Mark Henry, Titus ONeil, or even Jack Swagger). It isnt even about winning the United States Championship. The story theyre telling is that he just wants to ruin this guys life because he has nothing better to do and because he thinks hes deserving of a shiny belt. Thats The Varsity Villain Alex Riley characterization, not the characterization you give your rosters supposed top babyface. Unless hes The Rock.
Roman Reigns is not The Rock. He will never be The Rock. No one else will ever be The Rock.