ROH The Future is Now (12th June 2005)
We begin with a clip from WB News promoting ROH being in New York for this show, as WWEs produced ECW One Night Stand was also happening in New York later that same night. We get these WB News highlights throughout the DVD and they are pretty bad but any press is good press.
Match 1) Jimmy Rave [w/ The Embassy] vs. Colt Cabana
Thoughts: Decent back and forth and was totally fine for what it was but its focus, as with most indy matches was super unclear. Neither guy held any momentum before being cut off from the other and the wrestling itself was a mixture of spots for spots sake, and some sound ground work. Though there was no payoff for what they set up and for what happened after the match the booking made little to no sense. The match itself was inoffensive and showcased both well enough for those unfamiliar with either. The finish was neat with Colt escaping the styles clash and rolling up Rave.
Grade: C, Passable.
Match 2) Carnage Crew vs. Dunn & Marcos (Street Fight)
Thoughts: Dunn and Marcos get busted open early as the Carnage Crew dominate them both with slams, whips into the guard railing and general fisticuffs. Eventually a ladder appears allowing Dunn and Marcos to gain the upperhand but only for a moment without getting in any offence as Dunn suddenly gets thrown off the top turnbuckle through the set up ladder and Marcos is destroyed with a top rope spiked piledriver. Totally one sided and basically an extended unspectacular squash.
Grade: D, Underwhelming
Match 3) BJ Whitmer vs. Izzy vs. Jack Evans vs. Azrieal vs. Deranged vs. Fast Eddie (6 Man Mayhem)
Thoughts: Fast action with lots and lots of flips, inditastic moves and total chaos. There is no structure or reasoning for anything as its just a move showcase ran at 100mph with no-one selling a thing. Basically we got lots of no selling and a continuous string of high impact moves. Its a match you could watch once and be entertained by live, which the crowd were but you would never need to see it again.
Grade: D, Underwhelming.
Shane Douglas comes out to beat up two nobodies, and then begins berating WWEs ECW show, promoting his forever hardcore DVD and general whining. All this was supposedly done to set up a match down the road for Shane in ROH, which I dont think ever happened as Shane was pissed about his time here and how poorly it went over.
Match 4) Homicide vs. James Gibson
Thoughts: A far more methodical match with both concentrating on each others necks which makes sense considering each others preferred way of finishing matches involves the neck/head. And due to the pace and focus we get a more well rounded and satisfying match, with their moves having far more meaning and thusly impact. Homicide finding ways to slow a more versatile Gibson down was fun to see and for a wrestler who was incredible in 2003, Homicide had some of that old spark here too. The match lacked a little in the intensity department, which didnt get displayed until the match was over (we got very aggressive comebacks with big move attempts) but I enjoyed what they did and would gladly watch a rematch.
Grade: B, Enjoyable.
After the match an injured Jay Lethal runs in and attacks Homicide only to be chased off by Homicide's tag team partner, Low Ki. Jay Lethal was on the receiving end of a cop-killa/double stomp combo at the last New York show so he is back for revenge.
Match 5) CM Punk vs. Roderick Strong
Thoughts: The story with Punk at the time was whether or not he would be leaving ROH and go to WWE and we all know what happened there but it did lead to a super hot period for ROH as they/he created the Summer of Punk idea. Where Punk as champion would threaten to leave the company with the belt and with each show it was unclear if that was indeed going to be his last match adding drama and heat to each title match. In the end Punk left ROH having made ROH more money in the process and created a buzz we wouldnt see again until 2011 with Punk repeating the angle on a much larger scale. Punk didnt capture the ROH World title belt until the next show, which was advertised as being his last ROH appearance so lets move on to the match at hand.
Punk focuses on Strongs arm and does his very best to avoid as much of Strongs striking offense as possible. There is plenty of energy showcased by both while still doing their very best to tell a story of Punk using his experience to outwit the gutsy underdog. The pacing is wonderful as it was never too much for the sheer sake of it, Punk had an agenda and stuck with it and it helped the match ten-fold. Roderick Strong at this point was considered still a newcomer for ROH but he has always been able to hold his own and know how to stand out and entertain especially with his chops.
Quick rant. During the opening match Cabana did a spot where he went to chop Rave and Rave moved out of the way so Cabana actually chopped the ring post, which the crowd popped for yet it was a non factor in the match. This match is using the chop as a main story telling point and they do the same spot, which is great and all but its impact was neutered by it already being done and crowd having seen it coming. This is why indy wrestling can be frustrating. 1) They shouldnt have done the spot in the opening match and 2) since it was done in the opener, Punk/Strong should have come up with a different way to incorporate it. I dont think the opening match had any right doing the spot as it wasnt a match where the spot mattered, fuck Cabana didnt even sell it. Anyway rant over, back to the match.
Strong gets his opportunity and begins to hit his backbreakers allowing Strong to keep his momentum and work Punk down with stretches and slams. Strong goes to the well once too often and it allows Punk to counter and give himself some respite. Massive chop exchange, which neither man gets the better of so Punk changes it up with kicks. It seems Punk has the match won but Strong counters a pinning attempt with backbreakers leading to a well earned elevated boston crab. Punk escapes and begins his comeback and wins the match by reversing a last ditch backbreaker attempt by Strong into the anaconda vice.
I loved this match. It told a story exceptionally well and was more than just about two guys getting their moves in, it was about building towards something and letting you get enthralled by what they did. Indy wrestling today is still about watching guys get their shit in rather than telling you a story or giving you a chance to be invested in the outcome. As with almost all Roderick Strong matches at this time it was all about look how I tried, look how close I came and not just look guys I can do the flips
Punk gets a standing ovation and a thank you Punk chant as everyone was convinced Punk only had one show left...
Grade: A, Exciting.
Match 6) Samoa Joe (c) vs. Nigel McGuinness (ROH Pure Title Match)
Thoughts: Pure Title rules (limited use of ropebreaks, warnings on closed fists and 20 count on the floor) are somewhat peculiar resulting in odd matches as they focus heavily on these stipulations and weird outcomes but hey, sometimes different can be good if done well.
We get random holds and stretches early on but they bust out the strikes with a cool spot that saw Nigel being sent through the ropes out into the crowd even taking out a ringside staffer on his way out, all from just a Samoa Joe running kick. Joe exhausts all his rope breaks by escaping really basic holds, which doesnt make too much sense. Why not save them for when you really need them? They slug it out and Nigel ties Joe up in the ropes but Joe has no rope breaks but the hold is so bad that no-one believes its gonna end the match anyway. With that spot out of the way they devolve into a standard match, which Joe wins with ease.
Grade: C, Passable.
Shane Douglas is back out and the crowd boo him relentlessly. Including You still suck chants, ruthless jeering and general disdain sent in his direction. They even cut the promo short on the DVD knowing it was doing nothing and wasnt going the way they wanted.
Match 7) Austin Aries vs. Low Ki (Non-Title Unsanctioned Match)
Thoughts: Low Ki is notorious for never wanting to be booked in a position that makes him look weak (i.e. losing) but he was a name that drew so maybe he had a point therefore a straight up title match would mean defeat, as the plan was Punk vs. Aries for the belt so they had to get creative here. How did they get to this unsanctioned main event match? Low Ki interrupted Aries during the WB news segment. Thats it. Though their last encounter about 8 months prior ended up as a draw (as again Low Ki doesnt do losing) so hopefully they play off that here.
Strike exchange starts us off and then Low Kis entourage gets instantly ejected, ok then. Low Kis intensity is something to behold though and it does create an interesting dynamic as its up to Aries to keep powering through Kis ever increasing harder strikes. Aries attempts a frog splash but Ki gets his knees up allowing Ki to control the match and wear Aries down with holds. Aries escapes and then returns the favour of being in control and just as he gains momentum an Aries dive is countered by a kick to his head. Back to rest holds we go, then to the strikes and lots of them. Aries hulks up and starts a beat down of his own on Ki and guess what, Ki still manages to get the upperhand. They fuck up a bunch of moves and this match is a little weird as we have the intensity and aggression and energy but it doesnt fully click on all levels. Aries hits Low Ki with his own double stomp, which isnt enough to keep him down so Aries just punts him in the head. Cool. Aries goes up to the top rope so Ki kicks the ref into the ropes to dislodge and stop Aries attack. Low Ki hits a super Ki Krusher from the top to a monsterous pop and Aries is defeated.
What a way to promote the big upcoming Punk vs. Aries title match but hey now Punk can go in to it with a game plan. It was an intense fight and very hard hitting though personally I feel its something Ive seen before but regardless I still was entertained by it all. Jay Lethal runs down after the match and lays Low Ki out with a Dragon Suplex to help continue Lethal's quest for retribution.
Grade: B, Enjoyable.
Overall: I can see someone getting something more out of the main event if they havent seen a Low Ki match before because it displayed everything you need to know about him (including all the stiff strikes imaginable). I enjoyed 3 matches on the card and feel the rest fell a little flat especially Joe vs. Nigel. Strong vs. Punk was great and a wonderful thing to watch and I would totally recommend that match but as a show as a whole, yeah it is a good way to introduce someone to ROH but it isnt the best show theyve done. Though what makes ROH fun is the effort they put in and its a nice alternative, regardless if it pays off or not.