tbh I've played a bunch of those games and I still think Mania is my GOTY right now
I'm 60 hours into P5 and it's very good but godddd the pacing is fucked which is why I've been so slow in playing it
BoTW is unquestionably excellent, I'm just not huge on open world games. I still really liked it, and it's probably in my top 3 for the year, but I don't think it's my favorite game ever like others feel
Nier is an amazing story saddled with shallow combat that loses its luster 8 hours in
PUBG is a great game that leads to some incredible moments but it still has a shitload of jank I'm waiting for them to iron out
Only played an hour of Prey and still haven't played Y0 or Hollow Knight yet. Too many fucking games this year
That isn't to say Sonic Mania is perfect but its the sequel to 3&K I've wanted for years and I'm willing to look past its flaws because it does so much right