codswallop said:
Need more achievements? Buy an Ubisoft game.
NEED MORE HANNAH MONTANAH!! MORE AVATAR!!! MOOOOOORE CHEEEEEEVOOOS!!!
Mar said:
Silent Hill 4 Long Trailer.
Wow... I watched it and, having done so, can definitely say... that I watched it. I... really don't know. It's effective. It conveys mood and atmosphere. It's stylish. creepy as hell. but I don't know if I'd necessarily buy the game if I'd seen it (and I have played the game). It didn't really tell me anything about the game beyond "creepy japanese mind fuck horror." I didn't get the sense of the game.
With Dead Island (regardless of how is actually turns out) I got a feeling that it was about survival. That it was about loss. About losing those close to me. Making hard decision. Those close to me changing and becoming the enemy. Insurmountable odds. Survival.
Once again, I'm not sure what the final game will end up being and, realistically, it doesn't matter. It may be none of that. It may be shite but that's not the point of a trailer (or back cover synopsis of a book); it's all about describing the elements that may pique the interest of a buyer.
Silent Hill have me... a music video. The only bit of info I was fed was that there were 5 bodies found, a woman alive who later died from her wounds. Then more creepy shit. All very, very, very well done creepy shit.
For me personally, Dead Island did a better job of selling the game to me. That may be only because I'm more of a storyline sucker than I am a creepy japanoweirdoshit junkie.
codswallop said:
And it's being published by Activision. Meaning if Bungie is up to their usual standards, millions will want to play it for a long time, and if Activision are up to their usual games, millions will be gouged for a long time.
Everyone wins! Except consumers.
Yearly expansion packs!! Huzzah!!!
reptilescorpio said:
The biggest problem for me with Dead Island is that the trailer was hyped to high heaven and when I saw it my response was, "Meh."
Thankfully this wasn't my situation. I found out about the game when... I think someone on this board used the trailer music against a different video. I liked the music, searched for the game and found the trailer.
reptilescorpio said:
This trailer shows nothing of what the game will be about, if you base the story off the trailer you would say it would be a story driven game like Uncharted 2 or Shenmue or something. I think the uncanny valley visuals made it hard to emphasis with the characters (and this is someone who has a 5 month old son). I just didn't feel the emotional connection that they obviously want to portray is in the game, maybe some better flashbacks that showed more loving moments. Like maybe they could have flashed back to the childs birth, first steps, first word. That kind of stuff shows the connection between father and daughter.
Some valid points there. I didn't feel like they were going for the emotional heartstring tug but more the "...?" approach. Why is that girl lying there. Where is there a burning man in the background. Why is she suddenly launching into the sky, etc, etc. Then the backstory to that is slowly revealed. So yeah, maybe that perspective helped me enjoy it.
reptilescorpio said:
In fact it wasn't even techland who made the trailer, they outsourced it to a firm who specialises in these things.
I'm not trying to be snarky/trolly but what difference does that make? The idea is to get interest so you it makes sense to get some people with experience in. The clip was slick. that's their job. The job (for me) was done well.
codswallop said:
The trailer was fantastic but it didn't sway my impression one way or the other. I would've thought most gamers (or at least those on GAF) wouldn't have been so easily hyped from a trailer showing no gameplay at all.
I'm in no way "gonnagonnagonnabuythisgamedayonepreorderedohmygodohmygodsoooooohyped" like some people act, but the game is on my radar. At this point if I see a news story or a thread or even a pre/review about the game I will read it. Not hyped. Piqued. I think the trailer - as a separate entity - was excellent. Especially for what I've seen game trailers, which is mainly aggressively edited pieces of game play footage.
I guess we just want different things from our trailers. Or perhaps I didn't go into with the attitude of "sell me the game."