So I ended up playing about 3 hours of DAII (PC) last night. Had to cut my session short due to sleepiness but so far my impressions are very positive.
Things I like so far
- Game looks great - I'm playing with the High res texture pack, game doesn't run as smoothly as DAO but thats to be expected as it looks a lot better.
- Combat is great fun. I know it has been copping shit for being simplified etc but fuck it, it is fun. I ended up deciding on a male, two handed weapon wielding warrior for my first play through, and so far it has been great fun slicing shit up. It is definitely not as difficult as DAO but there have already been a couple of boss type fights where I have had to stop and manage strategy to avoid being completely annihilated. For me, it strikes a nice balance between being able to easily fuck shit up clickety click and then every now and then stop and think about what I'm doing a bit more.
- The skill trees, menus and codex etc are so different to DAO that at first it freaked me out and put me off a little. But after spending some time with it I'm convinced they are better, especially with the way the skill trees are set out.
- Story so far is interesting, I much prefer having a voiced character. The dialogue stuff is much better IMO, I prefer knowing before I choose an option whether or not it is going to be taken as snarky, charming or nasty.
- Some nice little call backs to DAO which made me smile (and laugh).
- The map and travel stuff is handled really well. Easy to navigate and find what you are looking for.
Things I'm not so sure about
- the framed narrative is interesting, but it is kinda weird (as the game skips time forward in chunks) when your character runs into someone and is like "hey i remember you from that thing that we did together, you know that thing when we killed the thing with the thing". But I guess its not a big deal, maybe I'm being picky.
Overall, I'm glad I've avoided the OT and reading too many reviews as I have gone into the game with an open mind and made my own judgements of it. I can totally get why some people would compare the game to ME2 in it's change of direction, but to be honest I enjoyed ME2 a lot more than ME1. I honestly do not understand the hate the game has been getting. Maybe I am more easily pleased than some, and I'm only a few hours in so my opinion may change, but so far I am having a great time with it and can't wait to get home tonight to get stuck in again.
Enchantment!