By all rights, I feel I should hate Max Payne 3. And to an extent, I do. It wasn't the sequel to Max Payne 1+2, and for that I won't ever really forget. But I just really can't deny how satisfying that game is to play. The slow motion gunplay is the best I've ever seen, and the physics engine rockstar uses is incredible. For what it's worth, I even appreciate that they went in a different direction, and the storyline they present is as enjoyable as any big dumb action movie plot could ever hope to be. Specifically, that big dumb action movie is Man On Fire, and thankfully, I quite enjoyed that movie.
It might be the only game that I both loath and love at the same time. And for that, and all its successes, it has earned its place on my top 10 games of the year list.