Basileus777
Member
That's not really that odd when dealing with adaptations.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Autumn Anime 2015 |OT| Like leaves on a tree were falling one by one.
- Thread starter BGBW
- Start date
- Status
That's not really that odd when dealing with adaptations.
Huh, what...
Maximilian Kolbe
Member
http://animeanime.jp/article/2015/12/02/25928.html
発表された新作も、岸誠二総監督、制作はラルケと前作の体制を引き継ぐ形で制作される。さらにシナリオ構成に『がっこうぐらし！』の原作を手がけたニトロプラスの海法紀光さんが入る。
Kishi Seiji will still be the chief director, but not only that.
This guy will be the series composition lol.
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/people.php?id=118667
Hellwarden
Member
But I thought everyone loved that Gunslinger Stratos anime adaptation?
Basileus777
Member
lol. Of course it's Kishi.
It is amazing. Absolutely hilarious.
Basileus777
Member
He's a director that is mostly infamous for making bad video game adaptations. His other work isn't exactly stellar either. Check out his history.
Admiral Woofington
Member
Somewhat unrelated but the Indivisible game campaign got funded, and one of the stretch goals is that the intro will be done by a 'mystery anime studio'
Signs point towards Trigger but you never know. Hopefully it reaches it.
Signs point towards Trigger but you never know. Hopefully it reaches it.
Says he directed Yuki Yuna, full HOPE engaged
You say that, but most of his not-vidya-game stuff is generally pretty well received.
I'm just excited for Thoraxes at this point.Euphonium movie will air on April 23rd.
So hopefully season 2 will start by October I hope?
I see. I will still hold out hope since it is not explicitly an adaptation as it is a continuation of sorts.
Basileus777
Member
I mean I guess that would apply to Angel Beats and the like depending on how one interprets "generally," but it's not really a sentiment I share. He has duds outside of the video game adaptation business.
Humanity Has Declined was good in spite of him.
ThatChairMan
Member
Aura
Carnival Phantasm
Humanity Has Declined
Persona 3 movies
Yuki Yuna
He's alright.
Euphonium movie will air on April 23rd.
So hopefully season 2 will start by October I hope?
Yes, definitely needs a season 2 for FGC the Anime, lol
Euphonium movie will air on April 23rd.
So hopefully season 2 will start by October I hope?
im prophetic
Crash Station
Member
My biggest problem with the DR anime was it was a super condensed low effort adaptation that could barely even be called the game in motion with how little animation there was. It was nothing more than a shittier alternative to playing the game.
An original story on the other hand is different. It doesn't even need to have good animation for me to be satisfied. Kodaka writing means I'm in.
An original story on the other hand is different. It doesn't even need to have good animation for me to be satisfied. Kodaka writing means I'm in.
TUSR the Oracle of Kyoani.
Admiral Woofington
Member
Will we ever have a hyouka season 2?
*shakes TUSR and waits for response to appear*
*shakes TUSR and waits for response to appear*
Hellwarden
Member
A Canadian 8-ball Egg is not reliable, yo.
Thanks, Enter The Dragon Punch!
DON'T COME HOME!!
I still plan on doing writeups for the last episodes I didn't do them for, too. Work has been pretty these past few months but I gave myself two weeks off at the end of the year. Though, I have enough time saved up to take all of December off if I wanted.
Considering that the is basically Danganronpa 3 and they skip the anime of 2 and AE, I am not sure if people who only saw the anime can even eally enjoy this.
Oh yeah, buy a Vita, it's fun. Great games and stuff. And more to come. Buy it. Go.
firehawk12
Subete no aware
When's K-On S3 please.
MikeHattsu
Member
Sölf;187528074 said:
Perm
firehawk12
Subete no aware
That would be K-On 0!Sölf;187527519 said:
But a prequel makes so much sense. Why isn't this a thing. lol
Well, they could always make a comeback! But yeah, a show around Death Devil would be nice. Just give me my metal anime fix, pls! ;___;
As opposed to all good videogame adaptations not directed by him.
He was always playing the dangerous game. I still remember his posts about Neptunia and illya anime.
hosannainexcelsis
Member
Astro Fighter Sunred is generally liked. Also, My Bride is a Mermaid is enjoyable.
Thankfully Naoko Yamada and company decided they didn't want to milk that series to oblivion, unlike other anime franchises.
Caught up on Concrete Revolutio finally. It's getting pretty damn entertaining imo. The inherent problems with the narrative suffering from insufficient runtime continues to be there, but I like how the stories are pretty varied and actually have some substance to them. Not as great as Space Dandy in terms of execution, but there's some good intent there. The latest episode actually felt pretty self contained and complete, and it's the first one not written by Aikawa. Lol.
rrvv
Member
Honestly is better to blame the fact that it is very hard to adapt Video Game anime instead blaming on the director.
When a director shows a consistent work history of being more than willing to take on tons of low quality work just to get stuff released, with little or no passion to it, it is fine to blame the director regardless of the "challenge". Directing shows isn't a slavery, it's a conscious career choice.
hosannainexcelsis
Member
Apparently the episode was written by the guy who wrote the very first episode of Sazae-san, which the episode's story referenced. So that's kind of neat.
Adapting video games has inherent challenges, but Kishi's work outside game adaptations shows that he's not exactly a skilled director no matter the source material.
Wasn't this weeks episode written by the scriptwriter for the very first episode of Sazae-San? That's pretty high-tier staffing given the specific content of the episode!
(Kinda feel like the Earth-chan episode has been my favourite so far, but I'm finding Concrete to be one of my most consistently entertaining shows of the season most weeks)
rrvv
Member
Not saying Kishi is great director. But I dislike how people simply blame the director or studio without understanding the challenge of creating anime in first place.
Say is there anyone in industry who can do Video game adaption good consistently
Yeah, well, I already saw that (and the live action, which was pretty funny).
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked