-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Banshee - Season 3 - Fridays on Cinemax
- Thread starter Vert boil
- Start date
- Status
Reading through the last couple pages, yeah, it seems like that's the general sentiment here. I had just read the AV club review where the writer was gushing over it and the commenters love it too. Felt like I watched a completely different episode.
I mean Proctor literally wanders off-screen and you hear a few gun shots. How does that translate to any tension? Even if they didn't show him later on, everyone and their mother knew he survived.
Dangit, we knew it was coming after last week's episode, but having it happen was bitterly disappointing for me. Nola dying was a shock, but this one was seen a mile away after Hood got outed. It's not like Siobhan was my favorite character or anything, but the death was so damn predictable it made me angry at the writers. A reason I did like Siobhan's character is it kept Hood from being with Carrie. Rekindling that pairing will just make me all kinds of angry. DON'T DO IT, BANSHEE!
LucilleBluthsdrunkeye
Neo Member
Well, these reactions from people would suggest that the answer is yes. Just looking at twitter I've never seen so many people pissed off about a television character in so many languages. (I'm not on twitter a lot) Plus, the actress' name trended worldwide after the how aired.
What surprised me most was how many people were pissed it was Siobhan that died and not Ana/Carrie.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
That's what I mean - she was really that popular?
*boggle*
She was hot, sure, but I mean, she didn't really do anything to warrant such a rabid fanbase imo. She wasn't involved in (m)any of the best action sequences, her dialog wasn't anything special - she was just one of the regular characters. She was cool, but then again, so is everyone on this show.
I could understand such a reaction if it related to Carrie or Rebecca, or even Nola, but Siobhan? Really?
Carrie is the female lead, so...
Miles Quaritch
Member
Maybe some saw Siobhan as a way into the show? She was grounded, didn't have a crazy back story and was generally someone who felt relatable?
LucilleBluthsdrunkeye
Neo Member
She was my favorite of the female characters as I found her to be more relatable. Siobhan wasn't your cup of tea. That's fine, but I doubt if anyone gave you their reasoning it would change your opinion. So *boggle* away I guess. *Kanye shrug*
jonnyp
Member
Yeah, terrible episode all round really.
Miles Quaritch
Member
The worst crime of the episode was that they removed a lot of the beastly/unstoppable force aura/presence that's been surrounding Chayton.
He came across as really powerless this episode. Lacked any kind of presence until the very end and even that wasn't shot very well.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Er, I guess? I mean, it just never occurred to me that some people might be watching Banshee on Cinemax because one the characters is relatable. lol
finowns
Member
They handled killing Siobhan badly. It was surprising and sad when Emmett was killed but Siobhan you saw it coming so it weakened the impact it could've had.
This episode was full of tropes and cliches. Like I said annoying.
I enjoyed Siobhan but I'm glad she's gone. The writers would have had a hard time pulling off their relationship.
As long as Deva and Job stay alive I'm fine.
This episode was full of tropes and cliches. Like I said annoying.
I enjoyed Siobhan but I'm glad she's gone. The writers would have had a hard time pulling off their relationship.
As long as Deva and Job stay alive I'm fine.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
This is Banshee brah. Shit like this happens on a weekly basis!
Pilgrimzero
Member
Just caught up. Dang is this show great.
I figured the girl was going to die the second she found out Hood was false. Though I kind of help out hope she would live. I thought maybe Proctor would appear and save them both at the end but nope.
I'm expecting full on war next episode.
Such a fantastic show.
I figured the girl was going to die the second she found out Hood was false. Though I kind of help out hope she would live. I thought maybe Proctor would appear and save them both at the end but nope.
I'm expecting full on war next episode.
Such a fantastic show.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Ratings:
Episode 1 - 547K
Episode 2 - 439K
Episode 3 - 588K
Episode 4 - 662K
Episode 5 - 583K
Episode 1 - 547K
Episode 2 - 439K
Episode 3 - 588K
Episode 4 - 662K
Episode 5 - 583K
Hours Left
Member
Well, they couldn't call the local police obviously, but they did call the state police, hence the sirens just as Chayton killed Siobhan. Hood even mentioned early in the episode that they had to wait it out until the state police arrived.
WarrenMax007
Member
Proctor called the state police.
Hours Left
Member
Possibly. I'm sure multiple people did.
I know you're referring to the "make that call" line, but it was brought up before that too. They wouldn't of gotten there as fast as they did if the first call was from Proctor.
Offering the reasoning that Hood wasn't going to be exposed because Siobhan forgave him thus killing her off wasn't a lazy act of keeping the show where it's at is adding insult to an injury.
Yeah, so this long-time proud cop did a 180 turn in the length of a single episode, forgave Hood and no longer insists for him to step off as Sheriff -- That's much better!
Siobhan goes from demanding Hood to retire and leave the town (because she doesn't want too taint all the good police work the real cops did) to being written as a woman that as long as she was loved 'for real' by Hood is willing to let everything else slide and then take off with him somewhere else! AND then they top it off by killing her, because of course we can't let the person that knows the truth roam around unchecked.
Siobhan's story didn't come to an end. The writers flip-flopped her up the wazoo and brought the end to her.
Siobhan already offered half of the solution. Hood quits the police. Brock is the new Sheriff. Hood stays in Banshee as a law-(un)abiding citizen. If Siobhan still wants him completely out of the state and still threatens to expose him then just have Hood answer fire with fire: If you come forward about me then i come forward about us three murdering that Nazi guy at the start of the season.
But clearly this is a non-issue if under one episode Siobhan can go from not wanting anything to do with Hood to reconciling with him and agreeing to leave Banshee together(!!). She would have been fine if Hood were to stay in town after he retires, even half-knowing he keeps doing his shit.
Yes, we really need more reason to hate Cheyton, the soldier-murdering guy. Because Hood had 'no reason' to get really involved against the guys that almost killed all his group or as them planning 'to take back the land from the white guy' will sooner or later have Carrie or Deva on their sights.
Are they really making Hood's real name a thing? Just spill it.
Yeah, so this long-time proud cop did a 180 turn in the length of a single episode, forgave Hood and no longer insists for him to step off as Sheriff -- That's much better!
Siobhan goes from demanding Hood to retire and leave the town (because she doesn't want too taint all the good police work the real cops did) to being written as a woman that as long as she was loved 'for real' by Hood is willing to let everything else slide and then take off with him somewhere else! AND then they top it off by killing her, because of course we can't let the person that knows the truth roam around unchecked.
Siobhan's story didn't come to an end. The writers flip-flopped her up the wazoo and brought the end to her.
Siobhan already offered half of the solution. Hood quits the police. Brock is the new Sheriff. Hood stays in Banshee as a law-(un)abiding citizen. If Siobhan still wants him completely out of the state and still threatens to expose him then just have Hood answer fire with fire: If you come forward about me then i come forward about us three murdering that Nazi guy at the start of the season.
But clearly this is a non-issue if under one episode Siobhan can go from not wanting anything to do with Hood to reconciling with him and agreeing to leave Banshee together(!!). She would have been fine if Hood were to stay in town after he retires, even half-knowing he keeps doing his shit.
Yes, we really need more reason to hate Cheyton, the soldier-murdering guy. Because Hood had 'no reason' to get really involved against the guys that almost killed all his group or as them planning 'to take back the land from the white guy' will sooner or later have Carrie or Deva on their sights.
Are they really making Hood's real name a thing? Just spill it.
WarrenMax007
Member
Gooood, too bad it's not 10 but hey, less filler I guess.
Hours Left
Member
faceless007
Member
How was Hood's real name not in the FBI dossier that included his stint in prison?
Hours Left
Member
They didn't get his name when he went to prison. Did you watch the Origin shorts for season 2?
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Banshee is their biggest show - only 8 episodes? I could understand cutting it down to 8 if they had a packed slate (like HBO or Starz) and wanted to make room for other shows, but that isn't the case here. I can't imagine it's a cost cutting measure either...it must have something to do with scheduling conflicts or something.
I'm pretty disappointed.
>
There are huge tax incentives for shooting there.
The FBI doesn't know his real name. He's a ghost.
Miles Quaritch
Member
8 episodes and no comments on returning characters?
That's not exactly good news....
Time to be concerned or perhaps a huge shake up is incoming? Perhaps a move away from Banshee?
That's not exactly good news....
Time to be concerned or perhaps a huge shake up is incoming? Perhaps a move away from Banshee?
Hours Left
Member
I think they're just waiting until after the season is over. There's probably some more big deaths coming, and the lack of certain actor's being confirmed might spoil that. (Both Chayton and the army dude's actors are series regulars, and I don't think they'll both make it out alive.)
The 8 episodes thing is disappointing, but if they have the arc already mapped out, maybe it just works out this way.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Strike Back has withheld cast information a couple different times when it was renewed while the season was still going. There were maybe a couple minor deaths but nothing major. I assume that's the case here but you never know. :3
It'll be interesting to see how they try to make Pittsburgh look like North Carolina.
WarrenMax007
Member
Maybe Quarry related? What if Greg Yaitanes wants to do both?
Maybe they pull of a heist and go on the run? That's why they're shooting in Pittsburgh?
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
I think Jonathan Tropper is the new showrunner for Banshee, although it's not unheard of for one person to serve as showrunner on two shows at the same time. It would certainly assuage my fears if that were the case.
Hours Left
Member
According to one article a few weeks back, Tropper is the sole showrunner now.
WarrenMax007
Member
Maybe he wants to direct.
Finally started watching this show a month or so ago and have been catching up at a pace that is rare for me when my wife isn't interested. In the middle of season 2 right now.. poor Zeljko, dude is always dying in shows. Too fitting that the house got burned down as that signified the dream of them having a life together again after all this.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
New episode tonight! Get hype!
JadedWriter
Member
Lol I brought up the tragic fate of the Zeljko character a couple of weeks ago.
spindoctor
Member
Edit - totally late to the renewal party
My bad
My bad
JadedWriter
Member
I'm going to assume Mrs. Lotus wasn't there that night when they had to fish a dead Kinaho out of Proctor's pool.
the_firewithin
Member
Brock gon be pissed when he finds kai slayed his old lady
JadedWriter
Member
I honestly don't see her surviving this season to be honest. Why is that woman defending Chayton? I know even great white sharks have activists, but fuck Chayton.
JadedWriter
Member
the_firewithin
Member
Wtf is Indian girl the flash?
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked