not familiar with what's neutered about it to be honest. All I know is I played both 3 and 4 for a while and neither felt good to me. They felt like cod. It was tag. I fucking loved 1942 and 2 and this reminds me of the feeling I got the most. I'm not someone who puts 1000 hours into these, so I don't know the nuances as well as the hardcore fans but I certainly know how they felt and both of those drove me from playing fairly fast, whereas with bf1 it's the first time I've felt immersed in a game in years, and I don't say that lightly. Maybe it's the setting?
The neutering is the lack of ticket bleed. It feels casualised and boring, and it makes matches last forever. If I'm getting bodied, I want the match to be over so we start over, not have to play a losing effort.
Benemoths were a mistake. The game balance is still getting worked on. While the maps are far better than BF4's at launch, there are still some issues.
Saying that BF3 and 4 played like CoD, but this one doesn't is kinda weird, seeing that it plays just like 3 and 4. The lack of lock on and copters aside, the game doesn't change the formula too much.