Alan wake 2 has bad water visuals when in town even on max settings with all bells and whistles. Certain npcs look flat.
I think for me Spider-Man 2 this year really stood out visually. That big of an open world going that fast with RT and the voo doo tech to make it 60fps is nuts. In cut scenes characters look stellar especially Harry. Yes MJ looks straight out of GTA4 but she’s the exception to the rest of the cast looking stellar.
I’m also of the mind that Like a Dragon Man Who Erased His Name has some superb visual moments but unfortunately isn’t the overall package.
Lastly, final fantasy 16 deserves nods similar to Spider-Man 2 for looking as good as it does with the insanity on screen especially during Eikon fights.
TLDR: Spider-Man 2.