I've found that I just really don't like the Forbidden Woods. I started a third save file because I wanted to play, but didn't feel like doing the DLC on my NG file, and don't really like NG+.
Four and a half hours in, I'm having fun. Tearing through the early-game, Cleric, Gascoigne, Amelia, BSB, Witch; all of 'em down in like three hours (okay so I'm sure you guys are faster, but I wasted an hour on Vicar trying to do a low-level win). I also mercy ran through Old Yharnam, just because I'd never done it before.
But then I got to the Forbidden Woods. I turned the game off and... I don't know if I want to play now. :L
Don't like the area, don't like the enemies, don't like the bosses. It's really a momentum stopper for me.