Finally got all but one DLC weapon to +10. Tested them in the chalice dungeons with BIS blood gems:
- MLGS is the new king, much more versatile than LHB
- Rakuyo is nice against groups of enemies but shit against bosses and big mobs, Chikage outperforms it by so much it isn't even funny
- The Whirligig L2 "one-shots" Rom (beast pellets, yo)
- Bowblade is utter crap (even against Amy's head), sad they nerfed it from ARC to BLT
- Boom Hammer has ridiculous AR (almost 1200!!!) but doesn't do any damage without L1 ignite, clunky because only charge R2 makes good use of the single hit ignite
- Saif is the better Saw Blade even without the hidden beast bonus, that moveset is sublime
- Amy Arm, Beast Cutter, Bloodletter and Church Pick are neither here nor there, they have way too limited move sets and don't excell in damage
Maybe I am missing some weird, unintended gem setup for some of the weapons (arcane Gun Spear says hi).
Now the only things left are the Beast Claws (with rune) and the Parasite (with rune)...then some PVP.
Good post. Thanks for your work.