Weapon XP was an AWFUL idea, I'm sorry. What it really does is strongly punish you late game when you try to use guns you rarely used before. You don't even notice the level up effects on guns you do use, but when it's playthrough 2.5 and your pistol level is still 3 you can basically just never use a pistol again because it functions like shit. Badass rank is a far superior system.
Agreed completely.
Can't escape the 'Expansion pack' feeling about it.
I really don't know why this feeling is so predominant when the game is arguably longer than Borderlands...
Don't worry. I was a bit alarmed too ,but I read the actual Destructoid review, and my fears were alleviated. The dude is kind of harsh in his score, and based on Destructoid's score guide scale and the content of his reviews I feel he should probably have given a 7 instead of a 6, but regardless of score, what he says in the review is more important than the number, and it seems like this is something any Borderlands fan will enjoy.
In fact, Jim Sterling's review on Escapist doesn't seem to disagree much with the Destructoid review in terms of general praise and criticism, but he gave 4/5.
Looking really forward to it myself.
Edit: oh there's one thing I disagree with Darren Nakamura (Destructoid reviewer) over, though... Athena is my girl. I called
dibs first, dammit! XD