Support NeoGAF

[Tashi]

Nevermind

 

[MikeE21286]

Leaving positve feedback for Full Metal Jacket

Quick and easy transaction!

 

[the chris]

Selling

edit: Both gone

 

[Dominican Power]

leaving positive feedback for MikeE21286

Bought a 1600 MS card, delivered as promised.

 

[Tawney Bomb]

Selling:

360 Tournament Edition Arcade Stick
Super Street Fighter IV 360
Resident Evil 4 Wii
Shin Megami Tensei: Nocture w/ Soundtrack
PSP 300 Black
DS Lite White

PM with offers and I'll try my best to work something out with you.

Thanks!

 

[Litflynt912]

FOR SALE: all prices are OBO so make an offer!!!!


Sony psp 2001 slim (black but with silver battery cover) condition 8/10 (screen is in great shape)
w/memory card
$80 Shipped

PSP Games
Gundam vs. Gundam (JP Complete)
$10 ShippedSOLD
Ridge Racer (JP first print SEALED)
$10 Shipped
Dark Stalkers (U.S. complete)
$8 Shipped
Final Fantasy VII Crisis Core PSP (U.S. Complete)
$7 shippedSOLD

PS3Gundam Musou JP (Gundam Dynasty Warriors)complete
$15 Shipped obo

 

[Makoto]

Edit: Not selling.

 

[Mexx]

My friend from polish forum Polygamia selling his PS3 with all released PSS games. All of the informations are in auction.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=140562649852#ht_12414wt_1061
May some good person coud post topic? I don't have permissions to do this and my friend really want to many peapole see this auction.

 

[Jomjom]

Selling:

Games

Game & Watch Collection Vol. 1 (Sealed) - $18 shipped

God of War: Chains of Olympus Black Label (Complete, Like new, no scratches) - $10 shipped and I'll throw in the special demo Sony sent along with the "Omega" necklace thing

Tatsunoko v. Capcom: Cross Generation of Heroes (JP Ver) (Like new, complete, No scratches whatsoever) - $20 shipped


Blu-Rays

Watchmen Motion Comic & Curse of the Black Freighter (2 separate Blu-rays) (Like New) - $12 shipped for both, cannot separate

Superbad 2-Disc (Like New) - $8 shipped




Accepted Payment Methods:
Paypal
Amazon credit
PSN $$
Steam/GoG codes in trade

 

[LQX]

.

 

[SephCast]

A couple things to sell:


Pokemon White - $25 Shipped
Pilotwings Resort 3DS - $25 Shipped
Futurama DVD Sets - Volumes 1, 2, 3, & 4 - $30 Dollars Combined shipped or $10 Shipped per box set
SOLD - Arrested Development DVD Sets - Seasons 1, 2, 3 - $15 Combined shipped or $8 Shipped per set - SOLD
Back to the Future Trilogy DVD Set - $10 Dollars shipped

Paypal only. I've got great ebay feedback: http://feedback.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewFeedback2&userid=sephc712&ftab=AllFeedback

I've got some more DVDs to get rid of, but I can't think of them off the top of my head yet.

 

[Crisis]

Hey guys. I'm glad to see that everyone's trades are going well and such! If I can have a little bit of your time, there are a couple of things we need to discuss as I would love to have your input on this stuff. Please understand that I am not trying to pick on anyone in particular when I bring this stuff up. They're either fully-fledged issues or potential issues and I don't want to see either one, and it is my understanding that none of you would, either.

1: I have noticed a rise in the amount of posts in this thread since its creation of people referencing positive feedback that they have received elsewhere online. This is starting to worry me because I don't know of a way that can be verified here. For instance, what if someone is claiming to be a member of Cheap Ass Gamer that has a lot of good feedback on that site, but they aren't that person? Or the eBay account stuff? I am not stating that anyone here has done this, as I have no reports of such a thing occurring, and I am also sure that the far and away vast majority of the posters here are more than legitimate. But we now have hundreds of people on that feedback list, and as it grows this potential also increases.

My only real proposal for this issue is for people to stop referencing feedback they've received elsewhere. I understand that some of you may not like this change as you've built up quite a reputation on other sites, and you're looking to get in on this site's action as well. What I'd like from you guys is to know whether or not you like this idea, if you have an alternative proposal, or something else.

2: The NeoGAF Plus and Gold programs. When I started those programs, things in this thread were moving a little slowly. I am amazed at how fast some of these sellers have made the list. They're all great sellers to be sure. But if you go and look at the list now, you can see blue in a lot of places and more than a few Gold members. I created this as a way to highlight really good sellers/traders/buyers, and I think it's been very successful in that respect. But the issue I'm seeing now is twofold. The first is that it's no longer as unique as it was when I started it. The second is that it's somewhat hard to spotlight these members, as was the original intention, when there's so many names on the list. Nobody really browses that list to see who the best sellers or buyers are. They just look at it to see if they have positive feedback or if there's been issues with that buyer.

So here are my proposed solutions for this particular issue. I plan to wait longer to add people to the NeoGAF Gold program from here on out. Members already in the Gold program stay in the Gold program. Members that would otherwise be really close to Gold status are "grandfathered" in for now. It seems cruel to have been so close and to have it taken away. For the rest of us, I'll add us on a less frequent basis.

My solution for the Plus/Gold program exposure has two parts. The first of which is that I plan to divide up the list as it is now. All feedback will remain intact for all users. There are basically three "tiers" right now, so I figure that is how many we could use for this program. We'll have one table for Gold members at the top, a second table for Plus members in the middle, and the big list of people that have yet to reach either status beneath those two on the User-Submitted Feedback List. The second part is to create two identical lists in the first post of this thread to more properly highlight Gold and Plus users. Just like the first one, I'm really open to suggestions, comments, or criticisms on these ideas.

3: This is more of a personal request from me to you guys. For the last handful of months, I've been trying to make the process of "inducting" people into Gold and Plus a little more personable so it'd be memorable and more fun. I have garnered eight positive feedback mentions within this thread, which means that (hopefully) before long I will be eligible to be in NeoGAF Plus. I kind of don't want to induct myself. So I'm hoping I can get some members to volunteer to do this one for me.

Anyway, thank you very much for your time and happy trading!

 

[snack]

Selling the following:

MOTHERBOARD: MSI 790FX-GD70
GPU: XFX 5770 1GB (never overclocked)
RAM: 2x2gb ddr3 g.skill ram F3-12800CL7
CPU: X4 955 (never overclocked)

Everything is in mint condition from a non-smoking home. Selling all for $400. Also willing to part it out individually. Feel free to message me if you have any questions. I have positive feedback, which can be viewed here:

https://docs.google.com/document/pub?id=1b3-jTcnQ8cKtyELo8ZStLQSt5Nu5lrpU1Q5hACjYzFU

Thanks!

 

[vocab]

Selling:

PS2:

Star Ocean 3 - Doesn't include the original slip case. The game has a few minor circle scratches on disc 1. Disc 2 has no scratches but has some minor dust stains on it that can easily be cleaned. $12.
FFXII Collectors edition - The game disc has a small hairline scratch that can only be seen in the light. The disc is flawless for the most part. The bonus disc was never used at all. $20.
.Hack//Infection - Includes the Anime OVA. Both discs are flawless. There's security sticker Residue at the top. $20.
Bully GH - Disc has a small 3cm scratch, and that's all that's wrong with it. $12.
Ratchet - Flawless copy $12


DS: Elite Beat Agents $10
DS: Hotel Dusk 215 $12
DS: Phoenix Wright $24


Want: Money
Hyperdimension Neptunia
Atelier Rorona

 

[Ryuukan]

...1: I have noticed a rise in the amount of posts in this thread since its creation of people referencing positive feedback that they have received elsewhere online. This is starting to worry me because I don't know of a way that can be verified here. For instance, what if someone is claiming to be a member of Cheap Ass Gamer that has a lot of good feedback on that site, but they aren't that person? Or the eBay account stuff? I am not stating that anyone here has done this, as I have no reports of such a thing occurring, and I am also sure that the far and away vast majority of the posters here are more than legitimate. But we now have hundreds of people on that feedback list, and as it grows this potential also increases.

My only real proposal for this issue is for people to stop referencing feedback they've received elsewhere. I understand that some of you may not like this change as you've built up quite a reputation on other sites, and you're looking to get in on this site's action as well. What I'd like from you guys is to know whether or not you like this idea, if you have an alternative proposal, or something else.

I agree with this completely. I also think links to external sales sites should not be allowed, ie, posting ebay auction links or amazon stores.

 

[Great Poster]

I've got some Canon lenses I'm looking to part with as I indulge my camera kit fetish. Lenses were purchased new in Nov 2010 and have no flaws/marks/defects of any kind.

Canon EF-S 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 IS SLR Lens

and

Canon EF-S 55-250mm f/4.0-5.6 IS Telephoto Zoom Lens

I'm looking to get $250 for the pair. Price is negotiable.

I have positive feedback (as a buyer). PM if interested.

 

[PhoenixSFT]

Selling:

A Pokemon Black DSi. Comes with 2 Stylii, Trace Memory (sans box unless I can find it...), and an AceKard 2i with a MicroSD adapter and a 8gb MicroSD card. Preloaded with a bunch of stuff and definitely works on this DSi with the current DSi software. Also comes with DS case which holds 8 DS games. PM for more details. I have multiple positives in the GAF feedback page.

Shipped for $180.

 

[Meowtor]

new stuff up, can take pictures if you want:

Dreamcast
Street Fighter 3rd Strike JP
Virtual On US
Shenmue US

Sega Saturn
Super Puzzle Fighter 2 JP

Playstation
Xmen vs Streetfighter US
Darkstalkers 3 US
Castlevania: Symphony of The Night JP
Ghost in The Shell US
Castlevania Symphony of the Night US

Gift card for Trader Joes 50$ (will sell for 40$)

 

[NoRéN]

2: The NeoGAF Plus and Gold programs. When I started those programs, things in this thread were moving a little slowly. I am amazed at how fast some of these sellers have made the list. They're all great sellers to be sure. But if you go and look at the list now, you can see blue in a lot of places and more than a few Gold members. I created this as a way to highlight really good sellers/traders/buyers, and I think it's been very successful in that respect. But the issue I'm seeing now is twofold. The first is that it's no longer as unique as it was when I started it. The second is that it's somewhat hard to spotlight these members, as was the original intention, when there's so many names on the list. Nobody really browses that list to see who the best sellers or buyers are. They just look at it to see if they have positive feedback or if there's been issues with that buyer.

So here are my proposed solutions for this particular issue. I plan to wait longer to add people to the NeoGAF Gold program from here on out. Members already in the Gold program stay in the Gold program. Members that would otherwise be really close to Gold status are "grandfathered" in for now. It seems cruel to have been so close and to have it taken away. For the rest of us, I'll add us on a less frequent basis.

My solution for the Plus/Gold program exposure has two parts. The first of which is that I plan to divide up the list as it is now. All feedback will remain intact for all users. There are basically three "tiers" right now, so I figure that is how many we could use for this program. We'll have one table for Gold members at the top, a second table for Plus members in the middle, and the big list of people that have yet to reach either status beneath those two on the User-Submitted Feedback List. The second part is to create two identical lists in the first post of this thread to more properly highlight Gold and Plus users. Just like the first one, I'm really open to suggestions, comments, or criticisms on these ideas.

I always felt that my GOLD status was undeserved. No way should I be in the ranks of the likes of GamerGeorge and xaosslug. I think something like a blue + for every 10 positive trades could be good. From there, gold at 5 blue +s, or 50 total positive trades.

 

[BeEatNU]

I agree with this completely. I also think links to external sales sites should not be allowed, ie, posting ebay auction links or amazon stores.

I agree with this, we come here to do business with each other.
Alot of people come here due to not wanting to deal with eBay or anything else.

 

[Jazzy Network]

Prices negotiable

WTS:

iPod Touch 8GB newest generation. Near perfect condition. - $140
Call of Duty: Black Ops (360) - $30
Nook Color barely used - $170 (add 16gb micro sd for $13)
Ton of Blu-rays just pm me and I'll give you a list.

 

[Futureman]

An easy way to confirm an eBay account is send a message thru the eBay system with your GAF name and the items you are trading.

But I agree that posting eBay links in here should be a no no.

 

[MikeE21286]

My solution for the Plus/Gold program exposure has two parts. The first of which is that I plan to divide up the list as it is now. All feedback will remain intact for all users. There are basically three "tiers" right now, so I figure that is how many we could use for this program. We'll have one table for Gold members at the top, a second table for Plus members in the middle, and the big list of people that have yet to reach either status beneath those two on the User-Submitted Feedback List. The second part is to create two identical lists in the first post of this thread to more properly highlight Gold and Plus users. Just like the first one, I'm really open to suggestions, comments, or criticisms on these ideas.

I can back this solution.

As far as any input or feedback goes...personally I use the NeoGAF Gold/Plus lists (and the feedback in general) as a way to identify the bad users

Thanks for all the hard work Crisis!

 

[BeEatNU]

I can back this solution.

As far as any input or feedback goes...personally I use the NeoGAF Gold/Plus lists (and the feedback in general) as a way to identify the bad users

Thanks for all the hard work Crisis!

The thanks could not be big enough.

I too, thank Crisis for his hard work, I was going to take on this role and he swept me off my feet

I appreciate you going through the hard work to organize this.

 

[mattiewheels]

I'm putting my Radeon 4670 up for sale here. It's in great shape and only been used for about 6 months. It's a pretty versatile card for someone looking for moderate power for cheap or an HTPC setup. Unfortunately don't have the box or manuals/cd, but installing drivers is probably a snap from the maker's website. Here's all the tech specs: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002LEVQ24/?tag=neogaf0e-20

I'm asking for $34 shipped, PM me.

 

[Fatal Futanari]

I have some stuff that needs a new home and I need to start saving up money for fall semester of college!

-accepts Paypal, Postal MOs, and Cash (at your own risk)
-Shipping will be determined on how much stuff you buy.
-Please send me your offers, but please be nice, I am a college student not a rich banker

BulletStorm (online pass unused)
Mavel VS Capcom 3 LE (codes unused)
Split/Second
Transformers: War for Cybertron

Silent Hill 3 (Sealed)
Silent Hill 3 (missing booklet but comes with soundtrack)

Resident Evil: The Umbrella Chronicles
Mobile Suit Gundam: Senshitachi no Kiseki (aka Ace Pilot) JAP

Anime DVDs:

*Note, please only ask for pix if you are generally interested in buying them as all these sets are spread out between 2 shelves and 3 separate boxes that are under alot of boxed anime figurines that are a real pain to go through.

Ah! My Goddess: Flights of Fancy (individual DVDs + artbox)
Ai Yori Aoshi + Ai Yori Aoshi Enishi - Complete Set (individual DVDs)
Air TV Complete Collection (individual DVDs, SEALED, artbox)
Black Blood Brothers Complete Series (SEALED individual DVDs)
Black Cat (individual DVDs + artbox)
Blue Gender Complete Collection (individual DVDs)
Bludgeoning Angel Dokuro-Chan Complete Collection
Chrono Crusade Complete Series (artbox + DVDs)
Claymore (individual SEALED DVDs + artbox)
Elfen Lied Complete Collection (individual DVDs)
Desert Punk Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox)
Devil May Cry Complete Series (all 3 individual DVDs with artbox. DVD 3 is sealed)
Full Metal Panic! (individual DVDs, SEALED)
Full Metal Panic!: Fumoffu (individual DVDs + artbox)
Full Metal Panic! The Second Raid (individual DVDs SEALED)
Gankutsuou: Count of Monte Cristo Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox SEALED)
Gao-Gai-Gar Premium DVD Box Set 1 (individual DVDs + artbox)
Gao-Gai-Gar Premium DVD Box Set 2 (individual DVDs + artbox)
Ghost in the Shell SAC Complete 1st Season Collection Box Set
Ghost in the Shell SAC 2nd Gig Complete Collection Box Set
Gravion Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox)
Gravion Zwei Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox)
Gungrave - The Complete Boxed Set (sealed with mousepad)
Gunparade March Premium Box (3 DVDs + LE collectors tin)
Haibane Renmei Complete Series (individual DVDs)
Infinite Ryvius Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox. Artbox has a tear)
Kanon Complete Collection(individual DVDs, SEALED, artbox)
Kaleido Star: New Wings Complete Collection(individual DVDs)
Le Chevalier D'Eon Complete Collection + artbox (ALL have their slipcovers)
Mezzo Complete Series (individual DVDs + artbox)
Mobile Suit Gundam 00: Season 1 Limited Edition (LE Parts 1, 2, 3 SEALED)
Mobile Suit Gundam 00: Season 2 Part 1 Limited Edition (sealed)
Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Destiny Complete Collection (individual DVDs)
Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Complete Collection (individual DVDs) *on hold, cant find Vol 1*
Moonlight Mile Complete Series (individual DVDs + artbox)
Mushishi Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox, SEALED)
Pani Poni Dash Complete Collection(individual DVDs, SEALED, artbox)
Peach Girl Complete Collection (individual DVDs, artbox)
Orphen: The Perfect Collection (brick pack)
Outlaw Star Complete Collection (3 individual 2-disc DVDs)
Ragnarok: Complete Series (SEALED, individual DVDs)
Red Garden Complete Collection(individual DVDs, SEALED, artbox)
Samurai Deeper Kyo Complete Series (individual DVDs)
School Rumble Season 1 (individual DVDs, LE locker tin)
S-cry-ed Complete Box Set
Shin Chan: Season One, Part One (SEALED)
Shin Chan: Season One, Part Two (SEALED)
Shingu: Secret of the Stellar Wars Thinpack (sealed)
Shuffle! Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox)
Stratos 4 Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox)
Solty Rei - The Complete Series (individual volume DVDs + artbox)
Sorcerer Hunters Complete Collection (brick pack)
Soul Taker Complete Collection (individual DVDs)
Texhnolyze Complete Series (individual DVDs, sealed)
This Ugly Yet Beautiful World (individual DVDs + artbox)
Trigun Remix Complete Collection (individual DVDs SEALED)
UFO Ultramaiden Valkyrie Season 1 (individual DVDs, SEALED)
UFO Ultramaiden Valkyrie Season 2 (individual DVDs, SEALED)
Utawarerumono Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox)
Vandread Complete Collection (individual DVDs + artbox)
xxxHOLiC Complete Series (individual DVDs, SEALED)
Xenosaga (individual DVDs)


Want:
$$$$
inFAMOUS 2 Hero Edition (really only want the game, DLC, and bag)
FEAR 3 (ps3)
Shadows of the Damned (ps3)

 

[samus4ever]

Looking for a copy of NFS Shift 2 for the Xbox 360. PM me if you are interesting in selling.

 

[DownLikeBCPowder]

Got it! Thanks!

 

[Movement]

Bayonetta - $15 shipped
GTA IV PS3 - $12 shipped
Skate 3 PS3 - $12 shipped

 

[Meowtor]

Anyone selling a 360 Wireless Adapter for a good price? My Ethernet port suddenly died abruptly (rage).

I have the original white 360 wireless adapter thats given me no problems ever that I could sell. What were you shooting for price range?

 

[NoRéN]

I agree with this, we come here to do business with each other.
Alot of people come here due to not wanting to deal with eBay or anything else.

Agreed. I've always found it weird when people would much rather sell through eBay and take a loss after eBay + paypal fees rather than cutting out the middle man and selling here directly.

 

[vocab]

Agreed. I've always found it weird when people would much rather sell through eBay and take a loss after eBay + paypal fees rather than cutting out the middle man and selling here directly.

Selling shit on ebay is so much hassle. It's like filling out doctor forms before you want to sell something.

 

[Davedough]

Crisis - I dont sell or buy much on here, but I've had a few transactions and I look at the thread daily.

I agree that outside feedback shouldn't be mentioned. Its not relevant to GAF trading and it shouldn't be up to the Gaffer to have to track down feedback from some outside source just to verify the seller. The seller takes chances and builds feedback just like they did everywhere else.

I also would think it'd be nice to amend that no links to ebay are listed. If you're selling something, I'll be damned if I want to go to ebay to buy it from you. I have had horrible times on ebay and I refuse to give that website page impressions for any reason. If you're going to sell something on Gaf, sell it on Gaf. If it doesnt go, put it on ebay and cut your losses here.

As far as inducting you, I think it would be appropriate for one of the Golds to do that for you. Hopefully someone will step up to the plate.

 

[BeEatNU]

As a Gold member, I recommend Crisis to be inducted to Gold status.
I'm pretty sure I've down business with him and others can vouch for him also.

 

[Crisis]

As a Gold member, I recommend Crisis to be inducted to Gold status.
I'm pretty sure I've down business with him and others can vouch for him also.

Thanks for the kind words. But that's not how Gold status works. I would not like to receive preferential treatment. If and when the time comes, I'd just like to not have to induct myself into Plus.

 

[BeEatNU]

Thanks for the kind words. But that's not how Gold status works. I would not like to receive preferential treatment. If and when the time comes, I'd just like to not have to induct myself into Plus.

Sir I AM THE SHINING DEFINITION OF GOLD!

 

[The_Inquisitor]

Hey guys. I am looking to buy a copy of Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood (360) Anyone got a copy for sale? I think I am waiting for the July 4th sales, but if I get an awesome offer I probably couldn't refuse.

 

[zugzug]

if only we were lucky enough to remove the professional vendors from posting. If we are really here to sell and trade amongst our on GafKind. People listing more than 10+ items, whether that list changes or not its just so many items listed that you eventually learn to scroll past them without really searching if they have something new each time on each page.

 

[KoreanBarbecue]

if only we were lucky enough to remove the professional vendors from posting. If we are really here to sell and trade amongst our on GafKind. People listing more than 10+ items, whether that list changes or not its just so many items listed that you eventually learn to scroll past them without really searching if they have something new each time on each page.

No offense, but I've put up big lists of stuff, and I'm hardly what you would call a "professional vendor." Some folks just have more stuff to get rid of than others. Like me. I'm clearing out room for a baby, so the more stuff I can get rid of, the better.

 

[GrotesqueBeauty]

A few thoughts regarding the feedback program. Let me preface this by saying thanks to everyone who has contributed to maintaining the list, it's a great resource and your contributions are invaluable to the community.

That said, what about just doing platinum members at 50+ transactions? We would still have the benefit of knowing when someone reaches plus or gold, but only truly prolific sellers will likely gain platinum status.

Another suggestion would be resetting the list each year, but making a side note of the status thread regulars had for the previous year. Perhaps a perk to further differentiate platinum members could be that your status doesn't reset each year with everyone else.

if only we were lucky enough to remove the professional vendors from posting. If we are really here to sell and trade amongst our on GafKind. People listing more than 10+ items, whether that list changes or not its just so many items listed that you eventually learn to scroll past them without really searching if they have something new each time on each page.

No offense, but I've put up big lists of stuff, and I'm hardly what you would call a "professional vendor." Some folks just have more stuff to get rid of than others. Like me. I'm clearing out room for a baby, so the more stuff I can get rid of, the better.

I can see both sides of the argument. While I wouldn't want to chase away people who sell large amounts of stuff (I quite like being able to strike deals buying multiple titles, and that's only going to happen when someone has a selection), there are definitely a handful of culprits who abuse the thread by rehashing the same post every page for months on end. You can include me among the people becoming irritated with sellers like xaosslug, not because he has large posts with lots of items, but because he makes a point of hogging the top spot on every page with the same stuff he's already listed dozens of times. That's just bad form. Ideally this is the sort of thing people can self regulate, but every once in a while there's someone (who may even be a valuable regular) that pushes things a bit too far. It's not that hard to simply link to an older post, only post every few pages, or only re-list when there's an update. Basically, use common sense.

I thought about adding another tier of B/S/T'er, platinum or whatever, but at some point, it's going to start getting confusing with different requirements and keeping track of all of that. I'd rather cap it at where it is now and simply raise the requirements just a bit. For right now, at least. And I really don't intend to reset the list each year. The idea behind the document is to have a record of each seller's history and feedback throughout the community and threads, as we have to do a new one each year now. It'd be nice to have a continuous feedback system as well, that way we can always have a reference. But outside of that, I really like the idea of the perks and I'm going to try to think of ways to incorporate that kind of idea into the list.

Word. Maybe plus could remain for every 10 transactions but stack (so people could +, ++, +++, etc.) until they're +5, which would be gold? This way you retain the old milestones, still show a clear progression, and only award gold status to prolific members. I don't know, I'm sure people will reach a consensus that makes sense.

Okay, guys. I understand that I didn't post this all that long ago, but it seems like there's near-unanimous support for prohibiting referencing feedback from other forums or sites, as well as prohibiting listing eBay auctions or Amazon storefronts, etc. I'll gladly add something to the documents and the OP of this thread about that, but as you all know, I am not a mod. That makes enforcing this kind of thing fairly tricky outside of using the list somehow to penalize people that do this. Any suggestions on what I could do for people who do not adhere to that?

You know, that sounds good on the surface, but I have had at least one very positive transaction with FrostuTheNinja who linked to his very reasonably priced ebay store and gave shipping discounts for multiple items. I can definitely understand why people are leery of new posters who cite feedback from elsewhere, but there are times when we'd be missing out by flat out prohibiting linking to stuff like half.com stores.

 

[Crisis]

A few thoughts regarding the feedback program. Let me preface this by saying thanks to everyone who has contributed to maintaining the list, it's a great resource and your contributions are invaluable to the community.

That said, what about just doing platinum members at 50+ transactions? We would still have the benefit of knowing when someone reaches plus or gold, but only truly prolific sellers will likely gain platinum status.

Another suggestion would be resetting the list each year, but making a side note of the status thread regulars had for the previous year. Perhaps a perk to further differentiate platinum members could be that your status doesn't reset each year with everyone else.

I thought about adding another tier of B/S/T'er, platinum or whatever, but at some point, it's going to start getting confusing with different requirements and keeping track of all of that. I'd rather cap it at where it is now and simply raise the requirements just a bit. For right now, at least. And I really don't intend to reset the list each year. The idea behind the document is to have a record of each seller's history and feedback throughout the community and threads, as we have to do a new one each year now. It'd be nice to have a continuous feedback system as well, that way we can always have a reference. But outside of that, I really like the idea of the perks and I'm going to try to think of ways to incorporate that kind of idea into the list.

Okay, guys. I understand that I didn't post this all that long ago, but it seems like there's near-unanimous support for prohibiting referencing feedback from other forums or sites, as well as prohibiting listing eBay auctions or Amazon storefronts, etc. I'll gladly add something to the documents and the OP of this thread about that, but as you all know, I am not a mod. That makes enforcing this kind of thing fairly tricky outside of using the list somehow to penalize people that do this. Any suggestions on what I could do for people who do not adhere to that?

 

[KoreanBarbecue]

A few thoughts regarding the feedback program. Let me preface this by saying thanks to everyone who has contributed to maintaining the list, it's a great resource and your contributions are invaluable to the community.

That said, what about just doing platinum members at 50+ transactions? We would still have the benefit of knowing when someone reaches plus or gold, but only truly prolific sellers will likely gain platinum status.

Another suggestion would be resetting the list each year, but making a side note of the status thread regulars had for the previous year. Perhaps a perk to further differentiate platinum members could be that your status doesn't reset each year with everyone else.
I can see both sides of the argument. While I wouldn't want to chase away people who sell large amounts of stuff (I quite like being able to strike deals buying multiple titles, and that's only going to happen when someone has a selection), there are definitely a handful of culprits who abuse the thread by rehashing the same post every page for months on end. You can include me among the people becoming irritated with sellers like xaosslug, not because he has large posts with lots of items, but because he makes a point of hogging the top spot on every page with the same stuff he's already listed dozens of times. That's just bad form. Ideally this is the sort of thing people can self regulate, but every once in a while there's someone (who may even be a valuable regular) that pushes things a bit too far. It's not that hard to simply link to an older post, only post every few pages, or only re-list when there's an update. Basically, use common sense.

Good point and I agree with you. Hopefully I didn't come across as pissy. I just wanted to make sure there's some clarity in not lumping everyone into the same group. I don't consider myself an abuser (I think I've posted my big list of crap maybe three times in the past two months), but I agree that there are folks in the thread that abuse the system, whether intentionally or not.

 

[NathanMcMahon]

I like to see a resource like Amazon or eBay for people's feedback. If you don;'t like to visit those sites then don't, but that shouldn't keep people who do like it from getting more info on a potential buyer and seller.

 

[DownLikeBCPowder]

Another suggestion would be resetting the list each year, but making a side note of the status thread regulars had for the previous year. Perhaps a perk to further differentiate platinum members could be that your status doesn't reset each year with everyone else.
I can see both sides of the argument. While I wouldn't want to chase away people who sell large amounts of stuff (I quite like being able to strike deals buying multiple titles, and that's only going to happen when someone has a selection), there are definitely a handful of culprits who abuse the thread by rehashing the same post every page for months on end. You can include me among the people becoming irritated with sellers like xaosslug, not because he has large posts with lots of items, but because he makes a point of hogging the top spot on every page with the same stuff he's already listed dozens of times. That's just bad form. Ideally this is the sort of thing people can self regulate, but every once in a while there's someone (who may even be a valuable regular) that pushes things a bit too far. It's not that hard to simply link to an older post, only post every few pages, or only re-list when there's an update. Basically, use common sense.

I have an awful and huge list, I really try to only post it every few pages at BEST since it is so awfully large. I know people check several pages, I do!

However I don't really see the logic in denying feedback from other websites. If a specific user doesn't care for it, so be it. I don't list it anymore (no point), but if someone wanted it I'd be glad to provide it. These links are small, are they not? People deal here at their own risk, don't they? Just seems odd.

I come to this thread to get away from standards, rules, regulations that plague eBay, Amazon, and all other types of trade areas. I don't come here for new rules and regulations for posting...

1: I have noticed a rise in the amount of posts in this thread since its creation of people referencing positive feedback that they have received elsewhere online. This is starting to worry me because I don't know of a way that can be verified here. For instance, what if someone is claiming to be a member of Cheap Ass Gamer that has a lot of good feedback on that site, but they aren't that person? Or the eBay account stuff? I am not stating that anyone here has done this, as I have no reports of such a thing occurring, and I am also sure that the far and away vast majority of the posters here are more than legitimate. But we now have hundreds of people on that feedback list, and as it grows this potential also increases.


My only real proposal for this issue is for people to stop referencing feedback they've received elsewhere. I understand that some of you may not like this change as you've built up quite a reputation on other sites, and you're looking to get in on this site's action as well. What I'd like from you guys is to know whether or not you like this idea, if you have an alternative proposal, or something else.

Can't say that this is worrying. People have been referencing off site feedback for quite a deal of time (ever since I have been a participant in this thread). I can't really speak for anyone else, but if someone claims to have X amount of feedback from a secondary location, I'm going to seek some kind of confirmation through my own means (whether that be through alternate communication to confirm the same identity, or whatever it involves for me). I think it is reasonable to allow people to tout feedback they have accumulated at other websites, just as I think it would be reasonable to refer someone to this feedback from another location. It is up to the person whether or not they would accept that data - personally, I am not all that interested in feedback outside of GAF, but I can't say that link or reference in a post has ever bothered me enough to take up the torch and pitchfork. Seems kind of absurd to simply block out outside references because they *aren't* internal and for no other reason. Just my opinion, but I'd let people decide if outside feedback is worthwhile on a transaction by transaction (or person by person) basis. Seems kind of absurd to police such a matter as the risks are kind of inherent and I'm not much for restricting behavior to save the ones who won't think at all to begin with.

2: The NeoGAF Plus and Gold programs. When I started those programs, things in this thread were moving a little slowly. I am amazed at how fast some of these sellers have made the list. They're all great sellers to be sure. But if you go and look at the list now, you can see blue in a lot of places and more than a few Gold members. I created this as a way to highlight really good sellers/traders/buyers, and I think it's been very successful in that respect. But the issue I'm seeing now is twofold. The first is that it's no longer as unique as it was when I started it. The second is that it's somewhat hard to spotlight these members, as was the original intention, when there's so many names on the list. Nobody really browses that list to see who the best sellers or buyers are. They just look at it to see if they have positive feedback or if there's been issues with that buyer.

I don't have an awful lot of input on this. I think you are absolutely correct on this matter, as long ago it was a much slower affair, this you are surely right about. I have also noticed (even though my participation has lowered slightly over the past period of time due to real life issues) the increase in gold members. I think this is something you are spot on about both of these issues and considering you have done a phenomenal job thus far with the feedback information I sincerely doubt leaving this issue to you (especially when I concur) will yield negative results. I didn't quote the rest of your text, but I handily agree.

 

[NoRéN]

.

 

[Crisis]

The NeoGAF User-Submitted Feedback List has been updated and it is accurate as of this post. I know I've posted a bunch today, but this time is a little different. We have a new addition to the NeoGAF Plus program!

• Let's all welcome Eltacoman to the NeoGAF Plus program! He has successfully completed ten transactions within this thread. Eltacoman joins the ranks of the most delicious-named members of the NeoGAF Plus or Gold programs. I kind of want to eat him, but in a totally not-gay way. In a cannibal way. Trade on, you delicious-tasting son of a bitch.

 

[Nose Master]

I don't have my one positive on that list . I can troll back and find it, but it was by smurfx.

 

[xaosslug]

Another suggestion would be resetting the list each year, but making a side note of the status thread regulars had for the previous year. Perhaps a perk to further differentiate platinum members could be that your status doesn't reset each year with everyone else.
I can see both sides of the argument. While I wouldn't want to chase away people who sell large amounts of stuff (I quite like being able to strike deals buying multiple titles, and that's only going to happen when someone has a selection), there are definitely a handful of culprits who abuse the thread by rehashing the same post every page for months on end. You can include me among the people becoming irritated with sellers like xaosslug, not because he has large posts with lots of items, but because he makes a point of hogging the top spot on every page with the same stuff he's already listed dozens of times. That's just bad form. Ideally this is the sort of thing people can self regulate, but every once in a while there's someone (who may even be a valuable regular) that pushes things a bit too far. It's not that hard to simply link to an older post, only post every few pages, or only re-list when there's an update. Basically, use common sense.

umm... well, that's good to know? LOL

i'd just like to say that this thread has always been first come first served, whether it be the best deals or the 'top post', and I'm really beginning to resent all the personal opinion, nonsense, bullshit 'standards' people keep trying to FORCE on the people in this thread...

like I’ve said before: this thread is what it is and has existed in the capacity it has FOR YEARS w/o people on the sidelines trying to ‘take it to the next level’ or ‘make it better’. The NeoGAF feedback doc is Crisis’ baby, and he can do whatever he wants with it. I will abide by whatever rules GAF mod(s) put in place, but I’ll be damned if I’m gonna sit by and have my name continuously maligned by other members who personally feel what I’m doing is wrong; in the name of 'bettering' the b/s/t thread. Please.

i'm sorry if I annoy you, GrotesqueBeauty *shrug* but please don't try to enact 'laws' upon this thread for the sake of assuaging your annoyance.

anyway, I’ve been contributing to this thread (buying/selling) for a long-ass time and will continue to do so, as long as the awesome opportunity allows. <3

 

[The_Inquisitor]

Looking to buy:

Kinect sensor + games


Please PM.

 

[SephCast]

A couple things to sell:


Futurama DVD Sets - Volumes 1, 2, 3, & 4 - $30 Dollars Combined shipped or $10 Shipped per box set

Individual DVDs - $5 shipped, 2 for $9 Shipped, 3 for $12 shipped, 4 for $15 Shipped, 5 for $18 Shipped

or a special deal of $40 shipped for all these movies:
Minority Report 2 Disc
iRobot - SEALED
Heat
Rounders - SEALED
Garden State
28 Days Later
Dodgeball
Doom - SEALED
The Negotiator
X-Men 1.5
X3 The Last Stand
Rush Hour
Rush Hour 2
The Rock
Armageddon - SEALED
Harold and Kumar
Shawshank Redemption
The Waterboy
Spawn
Speed
Jerry Maguire
Millions
Fight Club
Gladiator
Blade II
Moulin Rouge
Mystic River
Gone Baby Gone
Hero
Kung Fu Hustle
The Animatrix
Ong Bak


Paypal only. I've got great ebay feedback: http://feedback.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewFeedback2&userid=sephc712&ftab=AllFeedback

Updated