Smision said:gamer
when i meet people, i'm like "hi, i'm smision and I'm a gamer."
"meet me at Grub's tavern and I'll show you where the treasure is hidden"
Smision said:gamer
when i meet people, i'm like "hi, i'm smision and I'm a gamer."
Fusebox said:Ignoring Nintendo games means you're ignoring some of, if not the, best games that last generation had to offer.
outunderthestars said:And how many successful new franchises did Nintendo launch this generation?
Also, I like that you list Bioshock Infinite. A game that appears to have changed more in a single generation than Zelda has in the last 15 years....
I'm intrigued.Snuggler said:"meet me at Grub's tavern and I'll show you where the treasure is hidden"
Randomizer said:Hmm the differences between Bioshock and Infinite are the same as the differences between each new Zelda. New setting, new story, new art/graphics, new mechanics (Zelda has flying, Bioshock has Sky-Line Rails), similar mechanics(Zelda has new items and puzzles Bioshock has new powers and shooting). If you think the difference between Bioshock and Infinite is bigger than Twilight Princess to Skyward Sword you are very wrong.
toasty_T said:What about if you don't like platforming games or Zelda?
WHAT THEN OP?
truly101 said:You just ruined everything. You don't deserve that Chun Li avatar.
Not really that big of a slice though is it?rpmurphy said:I guess that if a proper gamer can ignore Nintendo games, then they can equally ignore other big slices of gaming.
dani_dc said:How would you know you don't like them if you're ignoring them?
Randomizer said:Hmm the differences between Bioshock and Infinite are the same as the differences between each new Zelda. New setting, new story, new art/graphics, new mechanics (Zelda has flying, Bioshock has Sky-Line Rails), similar mechanics(Zelda has new items and puzzles Bioshock has new powers and shooting). If you think the difference between Bioshock and Infinite is bigger than Twilight Princess to Skyward Sword you are very wrong.
Drek said:Not really that big of a slice though is it?
A couple of triple A quality Mario platformers in a generation, two great Zelda games, then a library packed to the gills with fan service.
Same argument could be made for PC gaming or any system, not everone has the time or money for all of them.Buddha Beam said:Ignoring Nintendo games means you're ignoring some of, if not the, best games each generation has to offer. Therefore, anyone calling themselves a serious gamer can't ignore their output.
BigJiantRobut said:But I just beat Witcher 2 for a third time and I still own my Genesis and I play fighting games on a stick and and and I love the original X-com and I buy all my PC games on Steam!
Well with Nintendo zombies acting like the company is somehow shitting gold when to date this generation they've got two good Mario games and basically nothing else, what other response is there?Gravijah said:You really want this thread to turn into one of those giant list wars, don't you? ;/
Maybe not but Infinite is.outunderthestars said:So the new zelda isn't about link saving Zelda?
They are however just as "same" as a Nintendo sequelOldJadedGamer said:These games do not have tacked on motion comtrols.
Dynamite Shikoku said:the only games nintendo fans seem to mention are mario and zelda. have they made any new grade A games in the last five years?
Dark Schala said:Not necessarily true.
If you've played The Legend of Zelda, you can't say that the rest of the Zelda games are open world like that. If you've played Zelda II, the other games are not sidescrolling and do not depend so much on RPG elements. If you've played Ocarina of Time, you can't say that all the other games (especially games before) adopt the Z-Targetting or, if you've played the 3DS version, adopt the gyro aiming system. Majora's Mask seems like a love-it-or-hate-it title because it deviated so much from the formula. Skyward Sword seems to be going in a different direction by using the Motion+ controller to make Zelda combat more strategic rather than merely hacking and slashing.
If you've played Metroid Prime, the other Metroid games are not in first-person. At the same time, Super Metroid isn't the same as Metroid Prime at all. These are two different types of games based on perspective. But the perspective shift can offer a brand new experience to the player.
If you've played Super Mario Bros, well... you and I both know that each new Mario title introduces some new quirk or mechanic (Super Mario 64's camera, for example) to keep players coming back. The level designs are often superb and well-designed.
But there is some truth here at the same time: Nintendo games are always comforting in their familiarity. In some cases, certain Nintendo games seems to have assisted in writing the blueprint for other games in the genre, or are inspirations for other games in the same genre. But the polished, well-planned work from any of Nintendo's development teams is very comforting to come back to every now and then. In other words: I know Nintendo EAD will give me a polished, well-designed product, and that's what keeps me coming back.
But on the other hand, I see your perspective and there's absolutely nothing wrong with that because it's partially true.![]()
truly101 said:I'm a console peasant, that shit don't impress me.
BigJiantRobut said:But I just beat Witcher 2 for a third time and I still own my Genesis and I play fighting games on a stick and and and I love the original X-com and I buy all my PC games on Steam!
He has to unless he has no job and multiple bodies. The sheer amount of gaming out there means you can't just limit yourself to good games anymore. You need to actively ignore segments and genres. Personally, I shut out most handheld gaming and Nintendo stuff. It's not that I don't believe Nintendo make great games, because they do, I just don't have time for them. I just started Alpha Protocol and the Witcher 2 AT THE SAME TIME!rpmurphy said:I guess that if a proper gamer can ignore Nintendo games, then they can equally ignore other big slices of gaming.
outunderthestars said:So the new zelda isn't about link saving Zelda?
SneakyStephan said:genesis is the bomb!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lk95swmkvBM
Cyborg justice, 4 player coop, fuck yeah.
Nintendork22 said:I mean, it may sound elitist
east of eastside said:Mario and Zelda are past the peak of their appeal
Nintendork22 said:I am someone who takes pride in playing video games.
Sure.Nintendork22 said:Can someone who doesn't play Nintendo games say the above?
Sure.Nintendork22 said:Can someone claim to be a bookworm but never read any Dickens? Can a movie critic refuse to watch The Godfather? Can a popular music fanatic avoid the Beatles their whole life?
Sure.Nintendork22 said:For example, is the opinion of a 12 year old kid who has only played games on his PS3 as valid as the opinion of an adult who has played games on multiple systems for the last 20 years?
Sure.Nintendork22 said:Does someone who plays games exclusively on their iPhone have as valid of an opinion about games as someone who has gamed on multiple systems for several generations?
Randomizer said:Hmm the differences between Bioshock and Infinite are the same as the differences between each new Zelda. New setting, new story, new art/graphics, new mechanics (Zelda has flying, Bioshock has Sky-Line Rails), similar mechanics(Zelda has new items and puzzles Bioshock has new powers and shooting). If you think the difference between Bioshock and Infinite is bigger than Twilight Princess to Skyward Sword you are very wrong.
BigJiantRobut said:Case of beer and Gunstar Heroes is how I rock it with bros on my Genesis. So goooood.
The validity of someone's opinion hinges entirely on the quality of their argument. Not the experience they've accumulated.Nintendork22 said:Okay, everyone is freaking out about "proper gamer", but I just needed some term to basically say - "I am someone who takes pride in playing video games. I am a video game enthusiast. I play a lot of games and I know a lot about games. I have played a wide variety of critically acclaimed games. I have played games from many different publishers, developers, and systems. My opinion about gaming is backed up by the wide variety of games I have played. I have been gaming for several years. I have done the "required reading" for video games."
Can someone who doesn't play Nintendo games say the above?
I seriously did not want this to turn into a troll fest. For example, is the opinion of a 12 year old kid who has only played games on his PS3 as valid as the opinion of an adult who has played games on multiple systems for the last 20 years?
Is someone who only plays Call of Duty as informed as someone who plays RPGS, FPSes, Platformers, Puzzlers, Action games, etc.? No.
Does someone who plays games exclusively on their iPhone have as valid of an opinion about games as someone who has gamed on multiple systems for several generations? No.
Can a Nintendo fan who only plays Nintendo games make judgments about the future of online in gaming? No.
I mean, it may sound elitist, but there are many gamers out there who have never played a single Nintendo game. If they want to sound educated about gaming, I think there are some Nintendo games they need to play.
SneakyStephan said:Can you rip off your friend's arms and legs? And use the weapons attached to the arms for yourself? And beat them to death with their robot arms?
Or hop around with no legs?
Rip off their robot torso and throw it in a pit?
Randomizer said:Hmm the differences between Bioshock and Infinite are the same as the differences between each new Zelda. New setting, new story, new art/graphics, new mechanics (Zelda has flying, Bioshock has Sky-Line Rails), similar mechanics(Zelda has new items and puzzles Bioshock has new powers and shooting). If you think the difference between Bioshock and Infinite is bigger than Twilight Princess to Skyward Sword you are very wrong.
Dynamite Shikoku said:the only games nintendo fans seem to mention are mario and zelda. have they made any new grade A games in the last five years?
The publishing output of Nintendo covers quite a swath of genres and IP's over console and handheld, not to mention the 3rd party titles that appear on them as well. Isn't that what is being discussed?Drek said:Not really that big of a slice though is it?
A couple of triple A quality Mario platformers in a generation, two great Zelda games, then a library packed to the gills with fan service.
Dynamite Shikoku said:the only games nintendo fans seem to mention are mario and zelda. have they made any new grade A games in the last five years?