• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Catherine |OT| Sheep, Matrimony, Terror - Love Is Gone

Beat the game last night. Got the
true love
ending.

I'm still not really sure what to think about the game, but I surely didn't enjoy it as much as I hoped I would. Too bad.
 

Mergesort

Member
slaughterking said:
Beat the game last night. Got the
true love
ending.

I'm still not really sure what to think about the game, but I surely didn't enjoy it as much as I hoped it would. Too bad.

Get the other endings!
 

ULTROS!

People seem to like me because I am polite and I am rarely late. I like to eat ice cream and I really enjoy a nice pair of slacks.
kyo_daikun said:
People on PS3 trophies are saying Axis mundi is around the 170 step mark.

I can't even get past 60 due to the "holey" blocks. :/
 

ULTROS!

People seem to like me because I am polite and I am rarely late. I like to eat ice cream and I really enjoy a nice pair of slacks.
cj_iwakura said:
What did you Obelisk survivors do for the part when the tower separates? Bounce back and forth, or stick to one?

Stick to one then if I couldn't "progress", I tried to merge the tower and by trying not to make the blocks fall (by pulling/pushing the edge holding blocks).
 
cj_iwakura said:
What did you Obelisk survivors do for the part when the tower separates? Bounce back and forth, or stick to one?

In solo, I usually stuck to one side until it looked like I'd have trouble continuing, then I'd build a path over to the other side. I never actually beat it, but I got the end with the bell toll four or five times doing that.

I can't remember what I did in pairs, probably the same thing.


also, Rapunzel sucks.
 
I only have one problem with the game. During the final stage of the night you just don't get enough time to think about the moves you can make. So I've been kind of abusing the home menu to pause the game and think about what to do next.
 

Zerokku

WHAT HAVE YOU DONE?
Kambing said:
Like a boss.

Get the Catherine ending ASAP, much superior imo.

I like the True Lover ending more since I'm a sucker for that kind of stuff, and it feels like the most fitting end for the game, but True Cheater still needs to be seen by everyone who has played this game. So good.
 
Wait what's with the "I think I am stuck" in Rapunzel. It triggered that phrase when I just finished making the path to the end of the stage, weird.

Edit: And now it did it a 2nd time, weird.
 
Lostconfused said:
I only have one problem with the game. During the final stage of the night you just don't get enough time to think about the moves you can make. So I've been kind of abusing the home menu to pause the game and think about what to do next.

You can just use Undo if you're scared of messing up.

Lostconfused said:
Wait what's with the "I think I am stuck" in Rapunzel. It triggered that phrase when I just finished making the path to the end of the stage, weird.

Edit: And now it did it a 2nd time, weird.

Vincent says things like that when the prince is low on power.
 

Kambing

Member
Zerokku said:
I like the True Lover ending more since I'm a sucker for that kind of stuff, and it feels like the most fitting end for the game, but True Cheater still needs to be seen by everyone who has played this game. So good.

Yeah the first ending i got was the True Lover ending and thought it was really awesome, but then i got the True Cheater ending and i was like... WOW! Go Vincent!
 
Fimbulvetr said:
You can just use Undo if you're scared of messing up.
It's not about messing up. It's just that I can't think of a solution on the fly and the trial and error approach wasn't helping me either because I wasted like 5 or 6 retries on that one specific section.

Anyways it's not a big deal. But it's one of the things that kind of makes this game harder than it needs to be.

Edit: Not to be a hater or anything. Because for now this is like my favorite puzzle game ever. Even better than Portal 1/2 or Toki Tori or whatever other games that get mentioned in the steam thread.

But damn ice blocks are evil, pure evil.
 

Neiteio

Member
This game is beatable with persistence, but perhaps the following would've helped:

- A Super Guide, inspired by Nintendo's recent efforts. Fail a level 10 times, and the game offers you a hint. The hint could be a video clip of how to negotiate the part of the stage where you appear to be stuck. For example, if you keep reaching the midpoint and can't get higher, the game could give you the option to see what needs to be done.

- The ability to rewatch the techniques Vincent and the other lambs teach each other on the landings. That way you could review such techniques as the pyramid, spider, etc.

- Present four difficulty levels: Make Very Easy the Easy option; Easy, the Normal option; Normal, the Hard option; and Hard, a new "Legend" option.
 
A giant big fuck you to the ice blocks, and the boss randomly removing blocks and that stupid special attack. And why the hell is it still giving me bronze? I am pretty sure I am getting gold on the previous levels.
 

ULTROS!

People seem to like me because I am polite and I am rarely late. I like to eat ice cream and I really enjoy a nice pair of slacks.
Ice blocks are tolerable. It's the random blocks, exploding blocks, and the cracked blocks that are annoying as fuck.
 
I am close to finishing on Normal (All Gold so far except for one Silver that I plan on redoing), but I'm wondering about something. What is the nature of the nightmare skip feature?

When you are presented with the option to skip a nightmare stage, do you just skip each segment and then go to the landing? Or does it skip the entire nightmare time block and you go instantly to the bar?

I'm curious because I think I screwed up some of the conversation trees with the bar patrons and
their sheep iterations in the dream world
and thus won't be able to see those plot threads to their proper conclusion. When/if I replay to get other endings/do this, will I miss the landing conversations if I skip or will I be forced to redo some of the stages I wasn't a big fan of to complete these parts?
 

Andrefpvs

Member
ColonelSkills said:
I am close to finishing on Normal (All Gold so far except for one Silver that I plan on redoing), but I'm wondering about something. What is the nature of the nightmare skip feature?

When you are presented with the option to skip a nightmare stage, do you just skip each segment and then go to the landing? Or does it skip the entire nightmare time block and you go instantly to the bar?

I'm curious because I think I screwed up some of the conversation trees with the bar patrons and
their sheep iterations in the dream world
and thus won't be able to see those plot threads to their proper conclusion. When/if I replay to get other endings/do this, will I miss the landing conversations if I skip or will I be forced to redo some of the stages I wasn't a big fan of to complete these parts?

All you skip is the stage itself and the final cutscene in case it's a boss stage. You still play the landings.

Also, you have to choose the option to skip in the menu.
 
Lostconfused said:
And why the hell is it still giving me bronze? I am pretty sure I am getting gold on the previous levels.

It depends on your climb chain mostly.

I usually get perfect climb chains so I always get Gold.

Also if you continue from a checkpoint you are pretty much forfeiting your ability to get gold.
 
Fimbulvetr said:
Also if you continue from a checkpoint you are pretty much forfeiting your ability to get golds.
Hahaha, ok. Well not doing that will all the stupid cheap boss deaths. Maybe when I play this game on again on hard or something.
 

SCHUEY F1

Unconfirmed Member
Finished the game with the True Freedom ending. Really enjoyed it and I can't wait for a Persona game using this engine. I also much preferred the in-engine cut scenes compared to the Studio 4G ones.

Time to get some of the other endings.
 

Neiteio

Member
Does resetting from a checkpoint hinder your chances of a high score because it resets the step combo multiplier?

Also, cool thing I noticed about the design of the final boss creature:
If you angle the camera sideways and down, you can see a stream of sheep-men being sucked up from the abyss below and fusing into Dumuzid's beard/growth
. As Strong Bad would say, "Oh man. So cool."

Also random: I love love love the cutscene where
Vincent and Orlando are on the shitter and Vincent's freaking out over Catherine's info being gone on his phone
. So many subtle nuances, pitch-perfect pacing, spot-on writing and a great blend of horror and humor in that scene. :)

Btw, does anyone know where I can obtain a copy of the song that plays in the Altar stage of Babel? It's not on the OST or the Love Attract disks. :-\
 

cj_iwakura

Member
It's supposedly called Hen to Hen, but it's not on any of the discs. The instrumental's on the disc, though; it's called Battle On Stage.
 

Neiteio

Member
cj_iwakura said:
It's supposedly called Hen to Hen, but it's not on any of the discs. The instrumental's on the disc, though; it's called Battle On Stage.
Thank you -- I searched it and found it on YouTube HERE. And if you use this site, you can convert the YouTube link to a high-quality MP3. Now it's added to my OST playlist. :)
 

JEKKI

Member
maaaaaaaaaaaaan this game is frikken ADDICTING!!

I started 2nd playthru yesterday morning but only played til I could make my 1st save.

today I've played all the way up til 7-5!!!

I keep telling myself this stage will be my last, but I jus keep going for the golds one after another!!!

a few things:

one, game is freakin waaaay more easier on 2nd playthru!! I've had no problem turning all my old Bronze & Silvers into Golds, and I've even gotten way farther in Rapunzel!!! SKILLZ!!

two, Undo is the most broken move ever!! lol. It resets your freakin Combo Meter so can always keep it up!! I want to feel bad for using it, but it's so easy to do I cant help it =P
 

jk-mox

Neo Member
Started this late last week. I'm finding it ridiculously hard so far. I might have to switch to easy. So much for my gamer pride :(
 
SCHUEY F1 said:
I also much preferred the in-engine cut scenes compared to the Studio 4G ones.
When the trailers came out and I saw how great the in-engine graphics looked, I wondered why they even bothered doing Studio 4C for the cutscenes, but then I realized that they used them very specifically for when
  • some intense acting was needed
  • some intense action was needed
  • there was a new location that would have had to been modeled if it was done in-engine
  • there was a new character that would have had to been modeled if it was done in-engine
If you think that other than the nightmare stages, there is only ONE explorable area in the game, Atlus lives up to their reputation getting a lot out of very little without the game feeling bare bones.

Such an awesomely budget-conscious developer.
 

Neiteio

Member
^^^ There are also the landings, for that's worth, and the stalls at Vincent's workplace, the restaurant where he and Katherine go, the Kappa Cafe and Vincent's apartment are all fully modeled (though you can't explore the latter four). :)

I think the blend of anime and in-game just adds to this game's style. There's been a massive style deficiency this generation, and this game almost single-handedly makes up for it. An amazing addition to my PS3 library. :)
 
Nooooooooooooooo, it can't be, why, god damn it. I thought I was done.

Edit: Wow, can you say "the worst stage in the game". Ok maybe not the worst, but still rather shitty.
 
Lostconfused said:
Nooooooooooooooo, it can't be, why, god damn it. I thought I was done.

Edit: Wow, can you say "the worst stage in the game". Ok maybe not the worst, but still rather shitty.

Escort mission?
 

cj_iwakura

Member
Regarding Chapter 8(mega endgame spoilers)

I can't enjoy that scene the same knowing it was a dream.

The Japanese version never ruined that for me, since I had no clue what Katherine was saying afterward.
 
Oh god we are in some Madoka territory here.

Would you like to become a magical sheep and climb the long tower of despair to prove your fidelity? I will grant you one wish if you do.
 
D

Deleted member 30609

Unconfirmed Member
I kinda loved everything about the demo. I ordered this. Tell me what to expect on a sentence or two.
 
Just started a few days ago. I rarely buy games for more than $20 these days, so it's a big deal that I got this for $60. Gotta support the Persona team though.

So I'm playing on normal and I'm not very good at puzzles but about 7 hours in and I'm already on night 6. I was starting to get the feeling that while this is a really cool game, I'm not really going to get my money's worth. Then I hit 6-3 and spent 10 hours on it. Yes 10 hours. Hooray.
 

Neiteio

Member
cj_iwakura said:
Regarding Chapter 8(mega endgame spoilers)

I can't enjoy that scene the same knowing it was a dream.

The Japanese version never ruined that for me, since I had no clue what Katherine was saying afterward.
There may be room to think the dream WAS real, or at least, that Katherine was really in it, only she can't remember afterward, just like all the other dreamers (at first). Either way, it's a very meaningful scene in that it's the point at which Vincent realizes how deeply he loves Katherine
.

Of course, I got the True Katherine ending, so I wonder how all those earlier scenes chain together with some of the other endings. I suppose he could
realize how much he loves Katherine in Chapter 8
but still decide
he loves freedom more
.
 
slaughterking said:
Beat the game last night. Got the
true love
ending.

I'm still not really sure what to think about the game, but I surely didn't enjoy it as much as I hoped I would. Too bad.
Haven't finished but feel the same way.
 

JEKKI

Member
maaaan I spoke too soon on the game being hecka easy on playthru 2.

9-3
genuinely kicked my butt >_<

but
9-4
went back to being easy =P
 

DR2K

Banned
I'm glad I'm not the only one who had a hard time on Easy mode. Got the
True Love
ending, so satisfying. Thinking about a new game on normal mode.
 
6-4 is kicking my arse, boss is so god damn cheap, I got close then half the level broke away with me on it, I could hear the bell ringing damn it!

Also hard mode is such a random bag, took me 20 tries to gold 6-2 whereas 6-3 only took me one attempt.
 
Nora Kisaragi said:
Vincent's an a-hole.

In Persona or a standard JRPG, when faced with the devil or the god/mastermind, the MC would go: "Your evil ends here! It's time to be defeated!" yet in Catherine, Vincent is okay with other people being sentenced to death as long as he and his friends are let go, and goes on to be the friend of the bartender

This is my favorite part of the entire game. Catherine's True Ending is a close second. I thought the game was at its best when it was being completely absurd.
 
Top Bottom