It's not so much that they're try-hard as it is that they... simply don't care. Which is how Hine and Lapham get this kinda shit published.
Supergod was legit good, fwiw. Uber is a pretty fun read too.
But you see, it was ok because she felt an irresistible urge to fuck and be violently abused by the protagonist while they fucked (which is how she got a dislocated shoulder). And that's ok because the wives of the other half-werewolf guys also actively enjoy being abused and they all kinda got this whole "if he really loves me, he'll beat the shit outta me" thing going on.
#lapham