• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Crimson Desert | Review Thread

What scores do you think Crimson Desert is getting?


  • Total voters
    400
  • Poll closed .
Honestly, I don't care about the game. But if this ends up having a decent performance on consoles it will be cool cause this is a proprietary engine, right? Finally something new.
 
My review after 50 h, the game is up there with Big rigs, earthworm jim 3D and Zelda botw.

Empty Big world without story, no good side missions, boss rush game with no more to do.

3/10

Nintendo version 8/10 because nostalgia.
 
A lot of these early reviews sound like a skill issue to me.

Morden leagcy reviewers are old men in their 30's who are too old get good at games.
 
I remember playing the TGS demo with a Playstation controller... The control combinations required for simple actions were atrocious. Like you had to hold several buttons to grab something. I don't know how it will play with keyboard + mouse.
 
Yeah, reading idiotic take like this about glitcher's world design telling you everything you need to know about reviewer

I'm probably the biggest Witcher 3 hater around these parts (a lot of its' shortcomings are overlooked because of the fantastic writing/performances), but I really can't stand modern open world map designs that put map markets down for every point of interest. It kills any sense of exploration or discovery and, in my fucked up mind, the purpose of open worlds in the first place. /rant
 
My review after 50 h, the game is up there with Big rigs, earthworm jim 3D and Zelda botw.

Empty Big world without story, no good side missions, boss rush game with no more to do.

3/10

Nintendo version 8/10 because nostalgia.
98EZGM0QrRMC4Dnj.gif
 
A lot of these early reviews sound like a skill issue to me.

Morden leagcy reviewers are old men in their 30's who are too old get good at games.

Ah yes, the geriatric 30 year old demographic. Fossils. Gasping for air that their weak lungs can barely make use of. They truly are "Morden Leagcy" as you so aptly put it.
 
I hope there is an ACG review ready. I will watch that and then I will go to sleep and either feel good or bad about my already downloaded ps5 pro preorder.

And most importantly I will make up my own mind when I eventually play it.

Can't deny I'm hyped though.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom