• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty | Review Thread

RavageX

RavageX

Member
It does seem like ppl have short attention spans or something. All this talk like this is a goty.

Its dlc. For a game that was shit. Just poorly put together from story to city to perks, etc. Not well designed and definitely not what was promised.

Now, if they took their time with it ( I dont trust reviews) and it is actually good...then great. Its ONE step in the right direction.

And they cant even stick with it to further expand on the game after this when that was the plan. These guys dont get a pass from me.
 
M

Macaron

Banned
RavageX said:
It does seem like ppl have short attention spans or something. All this talk like this is a goty.

Its dlc. For a game that was shit. Just poorly put together from story to city to perks, etc. Not well designed and definitely not what was promised.

Now, if they took their time with it ( I dont trust reviews) and it is actually good...then great. Its ONE step in the right direction.

And they cant even stick with it to further expand on the game after this when that was the plan. These guys dont get a pass from me.
Click to expand...
To each their own. Cyberpunk has been divisive. You say "shit", I loved this game. Plenty feel the same as both of us.
 
gaming_again

gaming_again

Member
balls of snow said:
From ign review:
At the intersection of (character) performance and technology, CDPR has found something in Cyberpunk 2077 that can genuinely move you.

And really thats where I am with cdpr, they craft these characters, dialogue, atmosphere and world building to create something deeply emotional for me to engage in. I remember tearing up when Geralt look to the camera in Blood and Wine after my 500 hour playthrough. They just get it man.
Click to expand...
Nobody else makes worlds as believable as they do.

Even the world of BG3, which I am loving at the moment, doesn’t seem as real as CDPR’s do.
 
killatopak

killatopak

Gold Member
RavageX said:
It does seem like ppl have short attention spans or something. All this talk like this is a goty.

Its dlc. For a game that was shit. Just poorly put together from story to city to perks, etc. Not well designed and definitely not what was promised.

Now, if they took their time with it ( I dont trust reviews) and it is actually good...then great. Its ONE step in the right direction.

And they cant even stick with it to further expand on the game after this when that was the plan. These guys dont get a pass from me.
Click to expand...
I had fun with it. I recognize people don’t like the release version however their revamp during the Edgerunners was actually great. Lots of rework from skills to equipment, glamour etc. The list of changes was endless.

This is actually version 3 if you can call it. It changed so much, they dropped last gen support. CP2077 was probably the biggest callout to reviewers in recent time. I doubt they can pull of another smokescreen like back then. The fact that it managed to score this well despite its previous reputation actually inspires confidence.

It’s not just a dlc though. Like I said its a V3. Lots of stuff actually changed and most of the requested features were added in. This is irrespective if you bought the dlc. It’s a huge update to the base game as well.
 
Last edited:
Gaiff

Gaiff

SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
TrebleShot said:
Interested in how the PS5 version compares to the balls to the wall 4090 version.
Click to expand...
Why would you be interested in that? I'd understand being interested to how it compares to a similarly specced PC but against a 4090 with DLSS, frame generation, path tracing, and ray reconstruction? Don't see the point.
 
Topher

Topher

Identifies as young
Negotiator101 said:
Rockstar wipe the floor with them and everyone else for that matter.
Click to expand...
No GIF
 
Mortisfacio

Mortisfacio

Member
Gaiff said:
Why would you be interested in that? I'd understand being interested to how it compares to a similarly specced PC but against a 4090 with DLSS, frame generation, path tracing, and ray reconstruction? Don't see the point.
Click to expand...

Especially considering the 4080/4090 cards are the only ones that can even fully utilize the features in this game. Overdrive mode is an unplayable mess on anything below that.
 
artsi

artsi

Member
RavageX said:
It does seem like ppl have short attention spans or something. All this talk like this is a goty.

Its dlc. For a game that was shit. Just poorly put together from story to city to perks, etc. Not well designed and definitely not what was promised.

Now, if they took their time with it ( I dont trust reviews) and it is actually good...then great. Its ONE step in the right direction.

And they cant even stick with it to further expand on the game after this when that was the plan. These guys dont get a pass from me.
Click to expand...

Nope.

It was a great game and Starfield opened my eyes again how great game it was even with it's problems on release.
All those problems are solved now anyway.
 
Hugare

Hugare

Gold Member
Xdrive05 said:
They're pulling me back in. When the new patch drops for this, I'll start a new game and work my way back up to the DLC.
Click to expand...
I'm thinking of doing the same

I'm excited for the DLC, but I'll replay the game anyway, might as well do it before the DLC

Will wait until the patch tho to see if I'll buy it on PC or PS5.

I really miss RT when playing on console. But I'm shackled to 30 FPS on PC in order to experience Overdrive.
 
SkeletonQuays

SkeletonQuays

Member
Salty Popsicle said:
Damn, I nearly completed a second playthrough some months ago but stopped near the end of the main story and decided I would wait until the expansion released to enjoy the full breadth of content. Not they are saying it's best to create a brand new playthrough just to experience all the new systems and skill trees in one go. I don't have the time to start over for a 3rd time.
Click to expand...
Just use your second playthrough and respec
 
Agent_4Seven

Agent_4Seven

Tears of Nintendo
Topher said:
Oprah Winfrey Concert GIF by CBS
Click to expand...
It's far from the best FPS games out there. I will argue that Far Cry 6 is way better purely when it comes to FPS mechanics, how enemies react to your shots in various ways depending on what they're doing, which part of the body is shot, the way impact from you shots feels etc. It's just night and day difference.
 
Last edited:
Hugare

Hugare

Gold Member
Agent_4Seven said:
It's far from the best FPS games out there. I will argue that Far Cry 6 is way better purely when it comes to FPS mechanics, how enemies react to your shots in various ways depending on what they're doing, which part of the body is shot, the way impact from you shots feels etc. It's just night and day difference.
Click to expand...

Excuse Me Reaction GIF by One Chicago





You kidding, right?

Hit reaction isnt great in Cyberpunk, but gameplay has tons of variety in terms of mechanics. Much more than any Far Cry game.
 
Last edited:
Topher

Topher

Identifies as young
Agent_4Seven said:
It's far from the best FPS games out there. I will argue that Far Cry 6 is way better purely when it comes to FPS mechanics, how enemies react to your shots in various ways depending on what they're doing, which part of the body is shot, the way impact from you shots feels etc. It's just night and day difference.
Click to expand...

I agree. Far Cry 6 had great shooting mechanics, but such a drag of a game. Rage 2 was also a really fun FPS game. Hopefully the FPS mechanics is something CDPR has improved on. I'll need to read some reviews tonight.

MScarpa said:
Is this a review on the DLC or the 2.0 update?
Click to expand...

Hopefully both
 
Last edited:
Agent_4Seven

Agent_4Seven

Tears of Nintendo
Hugare said:
You kidding, right?
Click to expand...
Do I look like I'm kidding?
Hugare said:
Hit reaction isnt great in Cyberpunk, but gameplay has tons of variety in terms of mechanics. Much more than any Far Cry game.
Click to expand...
I'm talking about FPS mechanics and guns, but sword stuff is shit, everything else is shit too or simply above average/mediocre (in 1.63, I haven't played 2.0). Even The Chronicless of Riddick had way better feeling gunplay.
Topher said:
I agree. Far Cry 6 had great shooting mechanics, but such a drag of a game. Rage 2 was also a really fun FPS game. Hopefully the FPS mechanics is something CDPR has improved on. I'll need to read some reviews tonight.
Click to expand...
Yeah, Rage 2's gunplay is great as well, but sadly the game itself is not. I don't think they can do much with gunplay in CP2077, we'll see about the sequel on UE5.
 
Last edited:
Negotiator101

Negotiator101

Member
Hugare said:
Excuse Me Reaction GIF by One Chicago




You kidding, right?

Hit reaction isnt great in Cyberpunk, but gameplay has tons of variety in terms of mechanics. Much more than any Far Cry game.
Click to expand...

I think that poster is talking about the feel and fluidity of the moment to moment FPS gameplay. I'd say they're correct, although not as good as Destiny, Halo or COD. Then again Cyberpunk is a lot more than just a FPS.
 
Mortisfacio

Mortisfacio

Member
PakiChilli said:
I've only put 5-10 hours into C2077, would I be better off starting fresh? Or does it not matter
Click to expand...

I'd personally suggest restarting and CDPR seems to suggest restarting, but you don't have to. With how much has changed, I just want to restart from the ground floor and build a new spec (planning netrunner this time around)
 
Hugare

Hugare

Gold Member
Agent_4Seven said:
Do I look like I'm kidding?

I'm talking about FPS mechanics and guns, but sword stuff is shit, everything else is shit too or simply above average/mediocre (in 1.63, I haven't played 2.0). Even The Chronicless of Riddick had way better feeling gunplay.

Yeah, Rage 2's gunplay is great as well, but sadly the game itself is not. I don't think they can do much with gunplay in CP2077, we'll see about the sequel on UE5.
Click to expand...
What you mean is "gun feel". "Mechanics" is a different thing entirely.

You mentioned FC 6 and I dont remember it having any really interesting mechanic in terms of gunplay. It's as mediocre as it gets.

And I agree, "gun feel" is bad in Cyberpunk, but specially now with the Relic abilities, you have tons of options in combat. Much more than your average 1st person open world game, imo.
 
DeaDPo0L84

DeaDPo0L84

Member
RavageX said:
It does seem like ppl have short attention spans or something. All this talk like this is a goty.

Its dlc. For a game that was shit. Just poorly put together from story to city to perks, etc. Not well designed and definitely not what was promised.

Now, if they took their time with it ( I dont trust reviews) and it is actually good...then great. Its ONE step in the right direction.

And they cant even stick with it to further expand on the game after this when that was the plan. These guys dont get a pass from me.
Click to expand...
Or rather life is short concerning videogames to miss out on something fun because it was less fun 3 years ago. Videogames aren't that serious, if it's fun to play today then I don't give a shit how it launched 1,2,or 3 years ago. There is enough actual shit to boycott or be upset about, videogames ain't it though.
 
Ozrimandias

Ozrimandias

Member
Wonderful, this second half of 2023 will be remembered as one of the best. Cyberpunk - after the corrections that were made - was transformed to my liking into one of the best modern RPGs. If it had been released in a proper state, it would have win game of the year easily. I will immerse myself in Night City again.
 
King Dazzar

King Dazzar

Member
Do we have news on PS5 performance post 2.0 patch? Also, I read they have reworked the controller config, any hands on impressions? Controls took an obtuse amount of config time to get "right" on console.
 
T

Thief1987

Member
RavageX said:
It does seem like ppl have short attention spans or something. All this talk like this is a goty.

Its dlc. For a game that was shit. Just poorly put together from story to city to perks, etc. Not well designed and definitely not what was promised.

Now, if they took their time with it ( I dont trust reviews) and it is actually good...then great. Its ONE step in the right direction.

And they cant even stick with it to further expand on the game after this when that was the plan. These guys dont get a pass from me.
Click to expand...
Seeing "journalists" with their tongues in cdpr's ass again is honestly disgusting. Did they get new set of chairs or something different this time?
 
Last edited:
SaiyanRaoh

SaiyanRaoh

Member
RavageX said:
It does seem like ppl have short attention spans or something. All this talk like this is a goty.

Its dlc. For a game that was shit. Just poorly put together from story to city to perks, etc. Not well designed and definitely not what was promised.

Now, if they took their time with it ( I dont trust reviews) and it is actually good...then great. Its ONE step in the right direction.

And they cant even stick with it to further expand on the game after this when that was the plan. These guys dont get a pass from me.
Click to expand...
LOL
 
Luipadre

Luipadre

Member
I'd play the game in RT mode on PS5, but the current motion blur looks awful. If they didnt tweak it in 2.0, im sticking with performance. It just a blurry mess when you move the camera
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Cyberpunk 2077 Coming to Mac Early Next Year
17
863
Same ol G replied
  • Locked
Is no one amazed by how we can play games handheld at higher settings than PS4/Xone? Bought RE2 for $6 today on CDKEYS
49
2K
EviLore replied
Inside the Game - Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty - 75-minute feature (EN) covers the 2020 launch, the aftermath and our work on the expansion
News
1
659
Killer8 replied
Cyberpunk 2077 Still Has Easter Eggs Players Haven't Found, says CDPR
Game Dev
32
3K
The_Observer replied
Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty Benchmark Test & Performance Analysis Review (Raster / Ray Tracing / Path Tracing)
Analysis Review 2 3
142
14K
DeaDPo0L84 replied
Top Bottom