Watched the Ultimate Cut last night, man what an improvement. I really enjoyed it this time around. My main issue with the theatrical version was that it didn't flow but all of that seems taken care of and I was able to have much more fun watching because of it. Now that some time has passed and I've watched the proper cut, I thought I'd type out some thoughts.
What I loved:
Clark as a character, I can't believe how much of him was cut. I was able to feel more for him as a character. Really feels like a naive small town boy playing on the world stage and not understanding why it's not as simple as doing what you think is right. Really liked when he calls his mom looking for answers why things are so complicated. Makes me feel more sorry for him when he goes into isolation and remembers his dad. The investigation into Batman is great too, makes the big fight better now that I can see from Clark's point of view why he thinks Batman needs a bit of a pummeling. I felt the contrast between the two characters much better overall.
Batman, although some really seem to hate his character with a passion, I thought was awesome. Love the concept of a brutal, burnt out, womanizing, drinking Wayne. Affleck plays the part so well too. More Alfred was great too as I loved Irons in the role. He really shows that Bruce has gone off the deep end and it's over for him. Bruce's speech at the end how he failed is touching too. It's the only real victory in an otherwise bleak movie where none of the main characters really win.
Lex, I can see how it's a love or hate thing, but I loved him. Eisenberg's little face twitches and mannerisms just make me smile every time. Like the mad scientist angle they went with over the business man we've seen before. Love how the added scenes really show that he was playing both Bruce and Clark from the beginning. In many way's he's just like Bruce, no faith in the world as it is, and hates superman for being a contradiction to everything life taught him. The rooftop scene with Superman in particular is just really awesome.
Lois, who's plotline I thought bogged down the pacing of the theatrical cut is also much improved. The extra scenes with her uncovering Lex's plot I thought really helps both their characters.
The visuals were still fantastic too. Love the look and feel of the cities, some really beautiful shots. The montage of people discussing Superman while he is flying around the world trying to do good is beautiful. Love the shot of Supe's corpse in space too. Costumes still look awesome as hell, the action was great although not enough of it until the end. I'm a sucker for violence too so I appreciated the added blood splatters. Wonder Woman was another totally awesome part. The music was great too, and I also thought the dialogue was well written between all the characters.
What I hated:
The knightmare, including the flash thing at the end still bugged me. The movie is already really long and stuffed with moving parts and it really wasn't necessary and it took me out of following an interesting plot. I wouldn't mind a version where this whole thing is edited out.
The other hero cameos, though not that great, didn't bug me as much since it was pretty quick. I still wouldn't have included them though.
The Martha thing...while it totally works for the story they are telling up to that point, was just executed poorly, I dunno the delivery just feels off.
The Lois hurling the spear thing was still dumb. The whole Doomsday fight was less epic than I thought it would be. Batman doesn't really do anything while Lois just has to be rescued by superman again. Thought it could've worked a lot better but I did like the death of Superman thing, thought it really completed Superman's arc dying for a world that seemingly turned against him.
So in all while not perfect, I'm pretty happy with the Ultimate Cut, it really fixed the movie for me. Upgraded from 'that was a mess' to 'great'. I'm pretty excited to see where they go with these characters in Justice League.