Best WWE Star Daniel Bryan is this year's MVP. He can spin shit into gold and usually puts on the match of the night. CM Punk is a strong second going over the year, and Antonio Cesaro would have won if his entire year was like the last three months
Best Non-WWE International Star El Generico is my pick for top indy wrestler in the world, though I don't know Mexico or Japan as well as I should
Best Female Wrestler I'll just give this one to Eve Torres as a most improved/best in the current WWE award but otherwise Sara Del Rey would have it for her work in Chikara. I'm sure if I watched ACW I'd have a better answer.
Best Tag Team Hell No for WWE, FIST's Gargano/Taylor for the indies
Best on the Mic CM Punk with acknowledgements to Paul Heyman
Best Comeback Heath Slater was on his way out the door until he developed his Legend-Killed-By gimmick
Best Gimmick Marchie Archie/Mixed Martial Archie/Mysterious and Handsome Stranger/Archibald Peck
Most Improved This would have gone to Tim Donst but his UTH match was pretty underwhelming, so instead I'll say Kane for being enjoyable to me for the first time ever
Fall From Grace Chris Jericho showed a lot of promise with his return gimmick, but then it got really really bad immediately after Elimination Chamber
Angle of the Year I think I have to go with Daniel Bryan and Kane becoming bestest friends through violence
WWE Match of the Year This one is really tough, but I may have to go with TLC Shield/Hellbackno
Non-WWE International Match of the Year Hmm, hard to measure this but I'll go with my sentimental favourite of El Generico vs Kevin Steen Showdown in the Sun
Best Feud Gekido vs Chikara has lasted all year and still has my interest so we'll go with that
Best PPV WWE Extreme Rules nothing else really comes close
Worst Angle of the Year Natalya Neidhart farts was this year, so we'll go with that
Worst On-Screen Performer of the Year I want to say Vince McMahon for being generally awful, but he put on one of the best matches he's had in years so we'll instead go with Jerry Lawler
Most Underutilized Performer Ricardo Rodriguez is the most likeable person on the roster as far as I'm concerned, I liked what they did with him at TLC
Worst Moment That Made You Feel Wahjah Jerry Lawler's comeback video package with the sirens and shit Ugh.