It hurts me to write a review with a rating so low, but as a COLOSSAL Savage fan, I've waited a long time for a biography on his life and career. With that being said, it feels like there is so much missing from this release.
For example:
1. There is no mention of Savage's 1985 run against Hogan that really established him as a major player. In a period where Hogan was usually defending the belt every night against guys like King Kong Bundy, Kamala, Big John Studd, Don Muraco or Paul Orndorff, Savage was able to put Hogan in believable jeopardy as an undersized heel, and the fans bought it.
2. His career as Intercontinental Champion is glossed over even though his reign was more than a year long and is one of the greatest reigns ever. Savage headlined the WWF's B house shows for more than a year during this run which included sellouts in 1986 in places like Philadelphia and Chicago without Hogan even being on the card. So, as a main event heel Intercontinental Champion, Savage was a tremendous success at the box office, and this made him one of the logical choices to hold the WWF Championship when Hogan ultimately took time off. This was probably worth mentioning.
3. There is no reference to Savage's initial face turn and its significance. When Steamboat took time off and the Honkytonk Man was given the IC belt, Savage became a babyface in part because half of the crowds were cheering for him even when he was a heel, and partially because his heel run as IC champ drew so many fans to house shows that they trusted him in the headlining spot opposite the Honkytonk Man to continue drawing money. Again, there is no reference to this. Further, they made the statement in this bio that the Intercontinental Belt was always the belt for promising young talent, and this statement couldn't be more wrong. Initially, it was a belt for veteran, main-event caliber wrestlers who had the ability to headline house shows when the WWF/E champion was headlining elsewhere. Pedro Morales held the IC belt for more than 600 days in two reigns AFTER he held the WWF championship for more than 1,000 days, and he headlined shows against Don Muraco for YEARS. By the time Savage won it, at age 34, the average age of a IC belt holder the first time he wore it was something like 37 years old. So they allowed the present state of the diminished IC belt as a mid-card stepping stone to bleed into the content of the DVD. Savage was stamped as a main eventer after his run with Hogan, and at that time the IC belt cemented his status as a headliner.
4. They don't even mention his run as "Macho King" or his association with Sensational Sherri. Back then, the King's crown was won in the ring like a normal championship and not won in a tournament (e.g., Harley Race to Haku to Duggan to Savage). For all intents and purposes, it was the WWF's version of the Word Television Championship. In essence, Savage was a mid-card champion as the "King of the WWF" for 19 months and none of this is mentioned. During this run, Savage, Sherri, Dusty and Sapphire had the first mixed tag team match in WWF history, and they did it at Wrestlemania 6. And, Savage defended the crown against all the top babyfaces other than Hogan and the Warrior, including Roddy Piper, Dusty Rhodes, Jim Duggan and Jake Roberts. Again, that was probably worth mentioning.
5. Savage's rivalries with George Steele, Jim Duggan, The Honkytonk Man, Dusty Rhodes, The Ultimate Warrior, Jake Roberts and Ric Flair aren't even mentioned. How they can completely overlook his career vs. career match with the Warrior is mind boggling.
6. The Mega Powers vs. Mega Bucks feud isn't mentioned. Nor do they mention the attempt to create another version of the Mega Powers with Savage and the Warrior paired as the "Ultimate Maniacs" prior to the Warrior's suspension just before a major Pay Per View against Ric Flair and Razor Ramon, and how this resulted in Mr. Perfect's face turn as Warrior's replacement, and the dissolution of another potential super team.
7. Again, the feud with Flair that resulted in Savage's Wrestlemania 8 title win isn't even mentioned. Everything about the booking of this match was controversial, not least of which was the fact that it replaced the Flair vs. Hogan dream match that was previously announced as the main event for Wrestlemania 8. The WWF teased a Savage-Elizabeth-Flair love triangle to raise interest in the match, Savage won the match one year after losing a career-ending match to the Warrior at the previous Wrestlmania, Flair kissed Elizabeth after the match, and it touched off an extended brawl and beatdown sequence that was HIGHLY irregular for WWF pay per views at the time. Of course, they don't show or mention any of this. In watching this DVD, you would almost think Savage's in-ring career in the WWF/E ended at Wrestlemania 5.
8. In WCW, Savage's run with Ric Flair revitalized his career, and it isn't even mentioned. Nor do they mention the awkwardness of working with Elizabeth in his corner on multiple occasions in WCW despite the fact they were already divorced. While they do mention how Savage was offended by WWE's comical references to his divorce during the Huckster/Nacho Man skits, they don't mention that Elizabeth turned against him to side with Flair in WCW while ostensibly spending Savage's alimony money from the divorce to treat Flair and the Horsemen. No mention of how the divorce was turned into a WCW angle is ever mentioned, nor how that affected Savage.
9. Vince McMahon, Stephanie McMahon, Triple H and Shawn Michaels do NOT contribute any interviews to this DVD. Given how much Savage's relationship with Vince is mentioned, given that they mention Savage left the WWF/E because Vince rejected his proposal to work a two-year program with Shawn Michaels, and given how he insulted Triple H and Stephanie on his website and this is mentioned as being problematic toward facilitating Savage's return to the WWE, you would think that at least ONE of these individuals would have contributed an interview to the DVD.
10. While the Hogan-Savage rivalry is played up throughout the biography, no mention of the fact that Savage NEVER got a pinball win against Hogan in any setting is ever mentioned. The Hogan-Savage rivalry, on paper, is the most one-sided rivalry in professional wrestling history. When Austin finally allowed the Rock to score a clean pinfall on him at Wrestlemania 19, it was his way of paying back the Rock on his way out the door for making him. Similarly, Dusty and Flair both had their share of victories over one another. Savage NEVER beat Hogan cleanly despite about 15 years of working with him on and off and dragging some of his best matches out of him. Some mention of the unfair, one-sided nature of this feud should have been mentioned aside from simply saying "Hogan was number one and Savage was number 1A."
Sadly, I think this is a case where the WWE Network actually interfered with the product. It feels like material on Savage's career may have been withheld from this product so that they can produce more specials for the Network, like for the "Rivalries" series. I get it, but it results in DVD releases like this coming off as incomplete.
The reason this gets three stars from me is because of the in-depth attention to his upbringing, his baseball career and his family life. However, so many of the 90 minutes are dedicated to Savage's obsession over Elizabeth and their respective unhappiness that the overall feel of the DVD actually comes across as being a little somber. An additional 20 to 30 minutes that fleshed out details of his in-ring career would have been vastly appreciated. Seriously, when you consider how WWE has done significantly lengthier DVDs on Triple H, CM Punk, Edge, Chris Jericho, Mick Foley, The Rock, Steve Austin, Ric Flair, John Cena and PAUL HEYMAN (two hours), let alone how their last Austin release was two-and-a-half hours long, I don't think I'm asking for too much by requesting more than 90 minutes out of their Savage bio. It's truly, truly disappointing.