KyanMehwulfe
Member
Did you play Deus Ex Human Revolution?I mean, I get the importance of augs in the world, and yes I was definitely loose with the details and perhaps a bit inexact in how augs relate to the various things I listed. But nevertheless, all of those things DO directly concern augmentation one way or another, and I can't help but feel that the entire aug angle is plumbed just a little too heavily. I mean certainly, there are other things going on in the world not related to augs?
I guess part of my exhaustion with hearing "aug aug aug" over and over stems from the fact that I kind of just don't buy the whole foundation - that people would flock en masse to permanently modify their bodies with mechanical parts. Certainly there would be a fringe group at least that would happily do it, but on the whole people don't like things in their body. I've worked in a hospital and seen how deeply upsetting it is for people to have anything interfering with their body. Like I said, there can be exceptions, but I don't think most people would readily swap their limbs for mechanical ones no matter how great the benefits seemed to be.
So in short, I don't mind suspending my disbelief for certain things (was very cool, for instance) but on the whole I think the entire aug thing is just too much. There are other stories they can tell with the aug angle as a constant, a backdrop, that don't have to directly concern augmentations and the people who use them. The first Deus Ex, for instance, talked about augs here and there - it was a part of the world but not all of it. It feels like every single story has to concern augs to an almost ridiculous degree.Golem City
Again though, I'm enjoying the game immensely, and I'm not trying to get anyone to agree with me necessarily about the aug thing, I just think the idea and its various implications have been thoroughly exhausted, and by this point in the game's timeline it feels like it should be more something that simmers in the background rather than dominates literally every single that happens.
I'm not sure the exact source but for me by the end of that game, it seemed pretty natural for why so many people were getting augmented. It was like electricity, a car, a phone... it was aptly named 'Human Revolution' because suddenly people had accessed to tools that dramatically improved their lives.
But there was also a rather huge (and under stressed in DXMD) element of 'forced' augmentation. It was a pretty big theme in Hengsha in DXHR though.
A lot of augs were war vets, of which there were a lot after not only the US wars but also the Russian States war and the Australian Civil War (these things are also not really stressed outside of emails or eBooks).
Another large number of augs were indirectly forced to remain competitive. In the same way you basically need internet, need a smartphone, in DXHR a lot of people needed basic vision or sensory augs. 'Soft' augs... not limbs or such, but a lot of augs just got minor things like Malik or that stock trader in Hengsha. A lot of labourers also needed limb augs, however, simply to remain employed.
DXMD however doesn't do the best job of either making the player feel that, or giving 'emotion' to the Aug Incident. There's one short story cutscene late in the game where a character retells an anecdote from that date, but in general the game assumes you sort of already know why augs are so common and also 'feel' (not just know) the Aug Incident was so horrible.
Both of which I think were only really conveyed by playing (and I supposed being immersed in, emotionally moved) by the Hengsha and Panchaea sections of DXHR.
And even then, maybe it didn't connect for everyone or it's been too long and DXMD should have had a better [emotional] (not just text) that makes you feel and understand that again. At times I did feel the game did not actually make you FEEL about the Aug Incident or 'segregation' enough -- it constantly pushes in in your face and TELLS you it's happening, but it doesn't do enough to make you believe it. It just assumes it's already accepted commonplace from DXHR I guess.