I assume you use a shield since you aren't taking advantage of the Guardian's Path Dodge boost? Or did you simply have to dump it for All as One in Inferno? Assuming you find sufficient all resistance equipment, what would you switch off for in terms of passives?
You don't need the armor boost from deadly reach? I guess dodge is better that armor, so that makes sense.
Yep, I use a shield. Guardian's path isn't good enough until you have the Resists and HP to allow you to take a few hits without the shield. When you can, using it for the extra Dodge is very nice.
If you have the all resistance to get up to 550 or higher, then dropping One with Everything for Guardian's Path is feasible but that requires a very high level of gear IMO. I don't have that kind of set yet so I go with OwE.
Deadly Reach/Keen Eye is not bad but it's a losing battle, at least in Act I/II. By going with damage mitigation, you have to have a high resist/armor/HP level to survive the extra hits you'll be taking. While it is true you get less defensive power by going with dodge, you'll be dodging more than half the hits and the rest just needs to be reduced enough that you can survive and heal it up. Fists of Thunder is faster than Deadly reach which allows you to pummel an enemy and keep your HP up.
As for passives, Transcendence is an absolute must, IMO. Seize the Initiative is almost to the same level as Transcendence but if you can get high armor equipment to make up for it, you could possible leave it off. The other ones are situational depending on gear but One With Everything should be the default unless you're getting like 60-70 All Resist on each of your pieces of gear.