• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Doctor Who Series Seven |OT| The Question You've Been Running From All Your Life

Status
Not open for further replies.

Belfast

Member
Have you considered that this is a thing that's probably true of half the audience of Doctor Who as it stands?

At any rate, livid may have been glib, but I stand firmly by irrational. You have reasons, but they're rooted in emotional reactions and not rational ones. One of you doesn't want the Doctor to be female because, in spite of the show saying clearly that Time Lords can change gender in regeneration and accepting that, you believe that The Doctor's gender is essential to his nature. The other doesn't want him to be female because you don't want to lose some kind of exclusive hold on relating to the Doctor you currently feel you have. Neither of those are rational reasons for wanting him to not change.

And male protagonists will never ever go away. They are not a disappearing species in need of protection.

Agreed. The Doctor's ingenuity and personality is what is integral to the character, not necessarily the gender. It would seem pretty obvious to me that, as fair as the series has generally been (compared to many, many others), it has still maintained a purely male lead for specific, gendered reasons.

At the same time, I don't want a female doctor just because it's an antithesis to the mold, and I feel like it would be interpreted that way due to the subtle (and not so subtle) ways in which Doctor Who/Torchwood has pushed a variety of gender/sexual relationships to the forefront in recent years.

I want to see it happen because I honestly think it would be an interesting twist on the story of the Doctor that hasn't really been tackled yet. But once again, it is the Doctor's "nature" that makes the character so easy to idolize. I hate this argument because I feel that it, oddly enough, only really matters to the adult male fans of the show. Kids who love Doctor Who, and (I realize I'm making a bit of an unfounded leap here) a large portion of the female audience would undoubtedly still watch and enjoy it if the Doctor was a she.
 

Snake

Member
At least we know one character who will be returning soon.

ibxKAbZKRwv4q0.jpg


"'The Pope' was an invention. So perfect a disguise that I forgot who I am."
"Then who are you?"

iJwSM9nJ9W7oP.gif
 
Daleks on Westminster Bridge again is, like, one of the most exciting set reports ever.

One of the great iconic Who moments. Just get us some Cybermen walking away from St. Paul's and we'll be content.
 
Today at the Glasgow Film Festival, director Nick Hurran announced he will be back behind the camera for the Doctor Who 50th Anniversary Special. The episode, which will also be broadcast in 3D, will be written by Steven Moffat and starts shooting in April. Hurran has some excellent previous experience on Doctor Who having helmed The Girl Who Waited, The God Complex, Asylum of the Daleks and The Angels Take Manhattan.

http://blogtorwho.blogspot.com/2013/02/50th-anniversary-director-announced.html
 
Excellent choice. Up there with Adam Smith, Graeme Harper and Joe Aherne (why hasn't he ever come back?) in the absolute top rank of New Who directors.
 
Excellent choice. Up there with Adam Smith, Graeme Harper and Joe Aherne (why hasn't he ever come back?) in the absolute top rank of New Who directors.

I wish Moffat would have Harper back for an episode or two. He's great. He would've been a great pick for the 50th, as the only director to work on both the classic and revived versions of the show... this is an amazing choice, though. Those are four of the Moffat era's best episodes.
 
Wait, it's going to be broadcast in 3d? I thought it was only going to be in 3d at theaters! Noooooooo

I don't have 3d glasses.

And it makes a bit naseuous, it's the synesthesia I think.
 

Quick

Banned
Wait, it's going to be broadcast in 3d? I thought it was only going to be in 3d at theaters! Noooooooo

I don't have 3d glasses.

And it makes a bit naseuous, it's the synesthesia I think.

It'll be broadcast in 2D, as well.

You need to tune into a specific channel to view it in 3D, usually offered for free if it's a channel you already have.
 
Wait, it's going to be broadcast in 3d? I thought it was only going to be in 3d at theaters! Noooooooo

I don't have 3d glasses.

And it makes a bit naseuous, it's the synesthesia I think.

It'll be 3D for anyone who has a proper 3D TV/subscription.

Don't worry, it won't be a red/green glasses kind of affair.
 

Quick

Banned
If you tune into the special channel, all you'll see are the same video output side-by-side.

Double the Matt Smith.

Kind of like...

tumblr_lmoibfDrWm1qbodpe.jpg
 
You know, I really prefer silver Daleks to any of the recent colours, I can't stand the gold ones and while the red ones would have been ok, I'd love for them to go back to the old Silver and Blue ones or maybe even grey and black ones

I do really like the gold, but the Time War Daleks do look great in the classic series colours:

mainpic_subcusick2.jpg

New-Series-Dalek-008.jpg


I'm not a fan of the new paradigm bright primary colours at all, sadly. Plus the whole too big/hunchback thing. Glad they've backpedalled to the lion's share of them being the time war variants - I just hope they think about introducing more colours.
 

mclem

Member
If you tune into the special channel, all you'll see are the same video output side-by-side.

Double the Matt Smith.

Kind of like...

tumblr_lmoibfDrWm1qbodpe.jpg

And if you can stereoview side-by-side images, you can watch it in 3D without the need for glasses!

(NB: I'm *good* with 3D and *good* at stereoviewing, and I can't hold that for more than thirty seconds or so. Not advisable!)


An Adventure In Time And Space news: Troughton has been cast!

For those who can't follow the link:
Reece Shearsmith
 
Season 18 is a pile of hot garbage.

What? No, Season 18 is majestic. It rejuvenated the show after one of the weakest seasons in the show's history, and brought new blood and bold new ideas. Full Circle, Warriors' Gate, The Keeper of Traken and Logopolis are all classics, and State of Decay is great fun. Warriors' Gate remains one of the boldest stories in Doctor Who's rich history.

There's a reason Season 18 is frequently mentioned in 'best season' discussions.
 
One of the weakest seasons? City of Death and Nightmare on Eden shit on anything in season 18 from a great height.

Fuck Christopher Bidmead's vision for the show. Wanky pseudoscience that's only any different from regular Who because the words are longer, and all the humour surgically removed. I'd take a single Douglas Adams episode over anything Bidmead had any involvement with, no questions asked.
 
One of the weakest seasons? City of Death and Nightmare on Eden shit on anything in season 18 from a great height.

Fuck Christopher Bidmead's vision for the show. Wanky pseudoscience that's only any different from regular Who because the words are longer, and all the humour surgically removed. I'd take a single Douglas Adams episode over anything Bidmead had any involvement with, no questions asked.

I love Nightmare of Eden, and I have a soft spot for Creature from the Pit, but Season 17 as a whole is on the weak side. It's just far too silly for its own good. It's certainly better than some other seasons like 2, 15 and 24, but it's still one of the weaker seasons.

JNT and Bidmead brought a new vision to the show, and rejuvenated it. Season 17 feels old and stale; Season 18 goes in a bold new direction, with new writers, new theme music, and a whole new style. The E-Space trilogy is a triumph, especially Warriors' Gate.
 
The only thing that would be better then the Doctor regenerating into a female, would be regenerating into a Black female. The meltdowns would be the legendary.
 

mclem

Member
The only thing that would be better then the Doctor regenerating into a female, would be regenerating into a Black female. The meltdowns would be the legendary.

Why think so small?

The only thing that would be better than the doctor regenerating into a black female would be regenerating into a black female played by Freema Agyeman. Given the broad opinion of Martha, the shitstorm would be almighty.

Although... I kinda think she could do a good job, too. Not that fandom could cope with the fact
 
One of the weakest seasons? City of Death and Nightmare on Eden shit on anything in season 18 from a great height.

Fuck Christopher Bidmead's vision for the show. Wanky pseudoscience that's only any different from regular Who because the words are longer, and all the humour surgically removed. I'd take a single Douglas Adams episode over anything Bidmead had any involvement with, no questions asked.

Yes. Bidmead is one of the worst writers the show's ever had. He's also insufferably smug and thinks he's much better than anyone writing for the show now.
 
What? No, Season 18 is majestic. It rejuvenated the show after one of the weakest seasons in the show's history, and brought new blood and bold new ideas. Full Circle, Warriors' Gate, The Keeper of Traken and Logopolis are all classics, and State of Decay is great fun. Warriors' Gate remains one of the boldest stories in Doctor Who's rich history.

There's a reason Season 18 is frequently mentioned in 'best season' discussions.

State of Decay I like, Keeper of Traken is ok.
The first episode of Full Circle is probably one of the worst things I've ever seen.

The whole season is super serious pseudo-science. I realize the majority of Doctor Who is pseudo science, but this season takes itself so seriously. They wanted to get the 'silly' out but they've gone way too far in the other direction.

Tom Baker seems to have checked out, but I'm not sure that scripts could've stopped that from happening.

Adric, Tegan and Nyssa are the worst set of companions so far (still Mel and Peri to come.)

My Tom Baker season ranking:

13 (Terror of the Zygons...) - Best Who season ever
12 (Robot...)
14 (The Masque of Mandragora...)
16 (Key to Time)
15 (Horror of Fang Rock...) - Rot sets in when K9 turns up
17 (Destiny of the Daleks...) - Overall weaker than 18 but does have City of Death
18 (Leisure Hive...)
 
I'm pretty sure upon reflection that season 18 is my least favourite season in the show's history.

At least Season 24 had Paradise Towers. The only season 18 serial I find even remotely watchable is State of Decay, and that's largely because of the vampires camping it up like their lives depended on it.
 

Raoh

Member
This might be old topic but I just rewatched the Blink Episode with the Tenth Doctor (David Tennant) and Martha Jones.

Was Sally Sparrow and Larry Nightingale the inspiration for the Emily and Rory characters? They just seemed so alike.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom