I'm really enjoying it, beat both Amazon and Moon before calling it. I had been saving Moon and didn't want that remix spoiled before I experienced it myself.
The animation is lovely and to my ears everything sounds authentic. Scrooge makes a few too many quips as you play, but the cutscenes don't bother me - as discussed, they can be skipped and so far capture the tone of the show quite well.
It really is the original though, it plays like I recall with a few quality of life upgrades, even if I wish they'd let you continue pogo'ing if you land near an edge.
I'm playing on medium and while I've died a few times (and had a real close call on the Amazon boss), no game overs as of yet and I'm not exactly the kind of gamer who beats Dark Souls.
It just...plays like the original and to me that's still absolutely fine. The basic gameplay ideas hold up - cane pogo is still just a ton of fun, and an entirely new game could be based around it.
Though I do think the idea is a bit muddled, it not just a remake, it's also is a tribute to the cartoon - and for someone just looking for a bit of nostalgia and an authentic Ducktales experience, the fact it is almost NES hard on 'normal' seems a bit misguided.
Though I never thought the original was difficult as NES games go, (I beat it and I couldn't get past stage two of Ninja Gaiden II or beat a classic Mega Man game) this isn't that era any more and expectations are different.
If you wanted to use this to introduce a kid to Ducktales as a concept, this game also just doesn't work - and while it may not have been the goal to do so, considering they got everyone they could back, it feels like a shame that something so gorgeous and authentic is hidden behind something most modern gamers won't have the patience to see - nor could really show off to anyone being remotely distracted by a child.
The world Carl Barks created deserves to have the widest audience with as many entry points as possible.
That said it's amazing if you like a platformer - and I really think your enjoyment of good platform game design trumps a love of Ducktales if you're interested.
If you just want Ducktales nostalgia, you may be a bit too frustrated by the journey, but this is a classic platform game and remains so remastered.