SCULLIBUNDO
Banned
And Munich had quite a presence.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Dunkirk - Review thread
- Thread starter zsynqx
- Start date
Still awesome to get to see it early. Post some impressions afterwards!
Yeah, he's up there.
I sincerely forgot until just now that Lincoln was a thing.
DecoReturns
Member
I remember thinking Joaquin Phoenix was more deserving then Daniel Day lewis for the Oscar that year.
As for the film itself. I remember thinking I didn't like it, but it's been a while
Obliterator
Member
Is there any way for me to find out what kind of Imax the one nearest to me is without calling them? Like any websites that list the type of screens / film shown?
I have no idea if the Imax near me offers 70mm or not
I have no idea if the Imax near me offers 70mm or not
El-Pistolero
Member
I won't argue with that, although I would put Villeneuve up there as well...Nolan's filmography is insane!
xValentine
Member
So.. GF doesn't watch films like this. I want to watch it.
How to make her come with me to watch this?
How to make her come with me to watch this?
On fandango or movietickets it should say 70mm IMAX...if not, it should just say IMAX.
Go alone to an empty morning screening, it's better
Or tell her it's PG13 and there's no gore if that's the issue
DecoReturns
Member
Tell her it starts Harry Styles. She'll never expect a war film
BennyBlanco
aka IMurRIVAL69
Patiently waiting for Armond White's 2 cents
Obliterator
Member
read the novelization of the movie. don't betray the trust
I_D
Member
How have I never heard of this before??? It looks amazing.
Google isn't being very helpful though (I blame the generic title). Is there a place I can watch Arena Combat MMA?
If you're gf won't sit for less than 2 hours at a free movie after you told her you want her to go then get a new one
Absolutely
Yeah it's def worth it still, even if just for the better sound.
Obliterator
Member
PeskyToaster
Member
Harry Styles' acting debut.
CosmicGroinPull
Member
'Best film so far'? Wow impressive reviews. Interstellar and Inception were great, but I won't be seeing this movie. Happy for Nolan though.
What's another tier below 'crap'? Because that's what the usual suspects will be calling his Batman trilogy, once the adulation for Dunkirk starts building up.
What's another tier below 'crap'? Because that's what the usual suspects will be calling his Batman trilogy, once the adulation for Dunkirk starts building up.
jack_package_200
Banned
I am glad Nolan picked a project with a smaller scale.
Lets fucking go.
Lets see if he can top The Prestige
Lets fucking go.
Lets see if he can top The Prestige
Buba Big Guns
Banned
Lets see if this can top Interstellar. I love WW2 but I love space even more.
What?
isaacnukem
Member
So is this good to watch on IMAX 2D? 70MM or Laser isn't available for me.
AuthenticM
Member
Damn
I guess I'll see. The trailers didn't grab me. Interstellar is my favorite film of his.
I guess I'll see. The trailers didn't grab me. Interstellar is my favorite film of his.
Lan Dong Mik
And why would I want them?
Just got out of a screening of this. I hate to say it because I love Nolan films but I honestly didn't like it very much.
I'm American so maybe this only effects me but I seriously had a very hard time understanding much of the dialogue. There were key moments where I was confused on what hell was going on because I couldn't understand anyone.
Some spoilerish impressions:
I'm American so maybe this only effects me but I seriously had a very hard time understanding much of the dialogue. There were key moments where I was confused on what hell was going on because I couldn't understand anyone.
Some spoilerish impressions:
The different timelines were cool but man they got really confusing after a while. Things started feeling VERY redundant.
I liked Hans Zimmers score for the most part but it felt like so much of it was building towards some sort of climax and it rarely felt like anything significant came from the build up because the timelines would switch so often it was difficult to understand which part of the story I watching.
Was Tom Hardy supposed to be playing the part of the worst pilot in history lol? He definitely had some cool moments, but Christ I was getting frustrated watching him spend the entire movie shooting and missing? I really liked the other pilot though, dude reminded me of WWE's The Miz.
VERY frustrated with how the story of the civilian Moonstone rescue played out. Rylance's character pissed me off sooo bad. Literally didn't show any emotion over his own son being killed by one of the soldiers he rescued, Cilian Murphys character.
I gotta see it again. Those are just some quick thoughts on it. Definitely worth seeing.
I liked Hans Zimmers score for the most part but it felt like so much of it was building towards some sort of climax and it rarely felt like anything significant came from the build up because the timelines would switch so often it was difficult to understand which part of the story I watching.
Was Tom Hardy supposed to be playing the part of the worst pilot in history lol? He definitely had some cool moments, but Christ I was getting frustrated watching him spend the entire movie shooting and missing? I really liked the other pilot though, dude reminded me of WWE's The Miz.
VERY frustrated with how the story of the civilian Moonstone rescue played out. Rylance's character pissed me off sooo bad. Literally didn't show any emotion over his own son being killed by one of the soldiers he rescued, Cilian Murphys character.
I gotta see it again. Those are just some quick thoughts on it. Definitely worth seeing.
MeatGrinder
Member
I have seen Interstellar at least 5 times since the beginning of the year, and I listen to the soundtrack regularly. One of the most epic movies I have ever seen, both visually, story-originality and soundtrack. When he is getting 5/5 for Dunkirk, then it is a must!
Thanks for your input, man! I'm avoiding the spoilers but appreciate your feedback.
TheSkullPrince
Member
Sad, but true. Was looking forward to the GAF reactions though.
Inceptional
Member
I think it's going to be more like a Gravity situation where it ends up having serious legs due to strong word of mouth. Fury Road made all its money up front and everyone who saw it was already sold on the movie before it came out. I dont think Dunkirk is going to be very devisive with general audiences. I think most people are going to love it.
PsihoPerihelion
Member
I'm gonna be super happy if Spielberg wins Directing again.
rokkerkory
Member
Yesss! Cannot wait!!
Alter_Fridge
Member
Please get back to making awesome Sci Films Chris
Regarding Tom, the RAF was widely criticized after the fact for not doing enough to support the men on the ground. And for the most part, the Luftwaffe had air superiority to begin with, which made it that much more difficult.
Just got out, and I really enjoyed. I still need to chew on it a bit more, but I can safely say that it's one of my favorite movies this year. It went by at a really brisk pace, which is odd for a Nolan movie, but it worked for this one considering how intense it was. That quote from EW is a bit over blown, though.
I'll agree with the poster above on how
Much like every other Nolan movie, I fully expect someone to make an infograph of the Dunkirk timeline.
Anyway,These are just some quick thoughts, I'll add more later. I really dug it all in all. And yeah, Nolan has totally got the best director Oscar on lock.
I'll agree with the poster above on how
confusing it got with the different timelines. I really liked it at first, but then the final act got a bit too hectic and jarring, which took me out of it.
Anyway,These are just some quick thoughts, I'll add more later. I really dug it all in all. And yeah, Nolan has totally got the best director Oscar on lock.
MrPink93485
Member
Fury Road had good legs relatively. It tripled its opening weekend gross and then some which isn't easy for a lot of films in this era.
It's just that Gravity was in a different stratosphere.
I'd expect Dunkirk will be somewhere between the two, but closer to Fury Road.
DarkLordMalik
Member
Looks like opinion are already divisive in this thread on this movie so despite stellar reviews, I don't expect it to have Gravity legs. It should still pass 150 million and might do more worldwide.
M.W.
Gold Member
People will go into this expecting certain war movie tropes and they are not present here. It's gonna split the audience, that's for sure. I don't see a BO darling.
RBelong2Us
Member
Also saw a screening . I thought it was pretty brilliant and with war movie fatigue was as refreshing as it could get . The jumps could be jarring since it's a frantic film as a whole but I think it adds to the suspense.
One thing is it wasn't an IMAX screening and boy it really does call to be seen in an immersive screen like that . At the same time if you see it IMAX first then regular screen you'll definitely not appreciate the same. I'm sure I'll have a different experience once I see it in IMAX
One thing is it wasn't an IMAX screening and boy it really does call to be seen in an immersive screen like that . At the same time if you see it IMAX first then regular screen you'll definitely not appreciate the same. I'm sure I'll have a different experience once I see it in IMAX
bananafactory
Banned
Man the voices thing is a bummer.
When was the last Nolan film that didn't have this problem? The audio mix in all his films just seems to be flawed. I know Interstellar had issues with music overpowering speech and when Michael Caine's character whispers his last words I swear to God I had to skip back on the Blu Ray 10 times before I could make it out. And the entire opening sequence of TDKR was reworked from what I saw in the 7 min preview, Bane's voice got totally altered.
Lan Dong Mik
And why would I want them?
^^yeah man it was a pretty big problem for me and my buddy who I saw this with. A lot of it sounded very fast and mumbled and I felt like an old man leaning in and tilting my head to the side trying to hear some of the fucking dialogue lol. It was pretty rough at times. Had the exact same problem with that movie The Witch. I hate not being able to understand dialogue and even though this is a movie where speaking sort of takes a back seat, it still bothered the shit outta me.
Forgot to mention I did see this in an IMAX setting. Absolutely insane visuals/sound effects. This was by far the loudest movie I have ever experienced in a theatre. My ears were still ringing walking out of there. Seeing it in an IMAX is 100% worth the extra $$$ you'd be paying to see it.
Also, I gotta say, Harry Styles did a damn fine job. Dude has some acting chops for sure. He had one the better performances in the entire movie tbh. The two younger actors on the moonstone were also very good.
I really wish Hardy was cast in a different role though. Hes easily one of my favorite actors today but thinking about it, this is probably my least favorite roll of his, at least that I've seen. Felt like a waste, he deserved a better role imo
Soooo many amazing shots though, the cinematography and the overall look of the film was on a completely new level. It somehow felt at times like I was watching one of those older war movies from back in the 60's or so but they made it feel and look very fucking real.
Couple more quick/spoilerish positives:
And for fun, here be my Nolan rankings
Memento > The Dark Knight > The Prestige > Inception > Batman Begins > Interstellar > Dunkirk > Insomnia > Following > Dark Knight Rises
Forgot to mention I did see this in an IMAX setting. Absolutely insane visuals/sound effects. This was by far the loudest movie I have ever experienced in a theatre. My ears were still ringing walking out of there. Seeing it in an IMAX is 100% worth the extra $$$ you'd be paying to see it.
Also, I gotta say, Harry Styles did a damn fine job. Dude has some acting chops for sure. He had one the better performances in the entire movie tbh. The two younger actors on the moonstone were also very good.
I really wish Hardy was cast in a different role though. Hes easily one of my favorite actors today but thinking about it, this is probably my least favorite roll of his, at least that I've seen. Felt like a waste, he deserved a better role imo
Soooo many amazing shots though, the cinematography and the overall look of the film was on a completely new level. It somehow felt at times like I was watching one of those older war movies from back in the 60's or so but they made it feel and look very fucking real.
Couple more quick/spoilerish positives:
I really liked that you never see a single Nazi soldier. All you see/hear is gunfire or bombs being dropped. The Nazi planes are really the only time I recall even seeing a visible enemy and I really liked that
Another thing I liked was that this movie might have had the least amount of gore I've ever seen in war movie. I can think of maybe two scenes that have a little blood in it. I thought that was pretty cool and a unique approach to take.
Another thing I liked was that this movie might have had the least amount of gore I've ever seen in war movie. I can think of maybe two scenes that have a little blood in it. I thought that was pretty cool and a unique approach to take.
And for fun, here be my Nolan rankings
Memento > The Dark Knight > The Prestige > Inception > Batman Begins > Interstellar > Dunkirk > Insomnia > Following > Dark Knight Rises
Frozenprince
Banned
God king Nolan does it again.
A NINE average, that's nuts, way better than I thought it would sit at (figured it'd be low maybe mid 90's RT% with an 8-ish score).
A NINE average, that's nuts, way better than I thought it would sit at (figured it'd be low maybe mid 90's RT% with an 8-ish score).