Yamato 2199- fin
I thought this was pretty fantastic. All the elements came together to create this really strong and cohesive work that is a fantastic modern retelling of a classic anime. While there are certainly elements of Battlestar Galactica,the modern version, it did feel like its own beast and the tone is much more consistent here. There are elements in Yamato 2199 that hint at the era from which the show hails from and while other works might have tried to downplay it, Yamato 2199 builds on those strengths and also uses more modern storytelling elements. It's a grand adventure anime that doesn't really take itself too seriously but really does nail a consistent tone that helps build this pervasive atmosphere. Even small things like repeating the number of days till Earth is dead, helped to reinforce the importance of the mission and also increasing the tension.
The most impressive element in the show for me was the 'villains'. The Garmillans, as Space Prussians I guess, are really fleshed out on not only a cultural level but an individual one as well. While there are certainly some characters on the Garmillan's side who are pretty much evil twirling mustache level villains, there are also some really in- depth ones as well. General Domel stands out as a highlight as he works as a rival throughout the series and the audience gets a really good understanding of his predicament. He's pretty charismatic but also dedicated to the cause and he certainly made the fights more dynamic. The show also fleshes out the anti-alien sentiment among the humans as well and there are some human antagonists thrown into the mix. Displaying both sides of the conflict not only helped to flesh out the universe as it displayed the contrasting alien architecture and society, it also served to make the fights more interesting especially when you know both sides of the battle.
The art direction was phenomenal. The user interfaces that both the human and Garmillans were used were intricate and cool looking. The architecture for the Garmillans felt organic and alien, reflecting differences them and the humans. I also thought some of the planets were really well designed as well and there are some gorgeous layouts during the show. It's a pity the ships were CGI but it didn't really bother me that much. I do think the anime had some great visual effects such as the afterburners on the ships or the Wave Motion Gun firing. I loved the character designs as they felt both old school and modern to an extent. I'm not necessarily wild about the Garmillans being blue humans though but that's sci-fi for you. The soundtrack had this larger than life feel to it in that it reflected this orchestral manly sound from the 70s. Yamato's theme is blaring and triumphant and the multiple Garmillan-related songs have this militaristic aspect to them. The space battles were alright, I liked that there were a lot of tactical aspects that went into them. I did find some of the outcomes somewhat unrealistic but it's not a serious complaint.
I have to say I really liked the characters as a whole. The only one that rubbed me the wrong way would be Dessler in that they tried to portray him in this sympathetic light but it wasn't enough. He just goes full on crazy near the end and any sort of character building with him is too little too late. I do give the staff credit for giving him emotions though and not making him one tone. The show really did a great job fleshing out the side cast and making sure that nobody felt neglected, which helped to make the Yamato crew feel like one big family to an extent. The show really did an exceptional job juggling its insanely large cast. I also thought the show did a notable job fleshing out Susumu Kodai and Yuki Mori's relationship. The audience gets a good sense of why they care for each other and the relationship builds gradually over the series. I do think the love triangle bit early on with Akira Yamamoto didn't do much though and was kind of a non-starter.
I don't watch much space opera anime but I enjoyed my time with this a lot. The fact that the setting wasn't in a high school, went a long ways.