hosannainexcelsis
Member
Honestly I didn't really pay attention to staff when first watching this but probably next time. I really liked this episode though and it's probably one of my favorites in the show. Like you mention with the more surreal imagery and getting more insight into Yuki and Kodai was just great. I think it was NeoSoma(?) who mentioned that this episode was kind of SHAFT-like, not in a derogatory sense, but more in the abstractness maybe of some of the visuals or storyboarding. Maybe it was the head tilts,haha. I felt bad for the younger psychic sister though...
I don't think Shaft is a good point of comparison, honestly. There isn't much Shinbo-esque about the episode - even the head tilts are more akin to live-action Japanese horror (the girl even looks sort of like Sawako from the Ring) than Shaft's infamous practice. It's a bit of a pet peeve of mine that anime fans are so eager to leap to that studio whenever a bit of abstract imagery comes up. The kind of surreal and horror techniques used in Yamato 2199 14 are older than Shaft - just watch Serial Experiments Lain, for instance.
I also agree with your AOTY comment on the last episode. I really like Wolf Children and seeing this families struggles and triumphs in their situation but I came to really like Yamato 2199 pretty quickly as well and maybe even more so than Wolf Children.
I don't think I can put this above Wolf Children, but it sure is hitting a lot of the right buttons for me. It's just about an ideal model of how a remake should be handled - it keeps the classic feel while intelligently fleshing out the story in a way that makes it palatable for modern audiences.