The Violinist of Hamelin
It's hard to find the right words to really tell you about Hamelin, because no matter how I approach this subject, the way I begin it might influence the way you see the show altogether. I'm going to play it a bit riskily, though, and hope that you can see the good in the bad.
The Violinist of Hamelin has to be the cheapest show Yasuhiro Imagawa has ever made. The show's budget is probably less than the student loans I've withdrawn, even after adjusting for inflation. I can't stress this enough:
The show was made on sheer grit and nothing else. Numerous scenes aren't animated beyond still pictures accompanied by sound and voice. Animation comes in ten second bursts maybe thrice an episode and that'll be that. Sometimes you will wonder why one scene was animated and another was not. I don't know anything about how anime are made, so I'm gonna just leave that question hanging in the air.
The character designs are
excessively exaggerated; I would venture to call them typical of the genre and period. 90s fantasy anime was a time of massive eyes, razor sharp noses, outlandish hair styles, and torsos and limbs of equal, thin, width. I can't honestly say I liked any character designs in this show, but as that is a matter of taste, and as I felt that they were appropriate to the work, I cannot really complain very much.
And that concludes the complaints, really. They're substantial, but not numerous. Now let's dive into what I enjoyed.
The Violinist of Hamelin begins as a simple, almost stereotypical fantasy anime. The hero and the girl he likes are introduced, their village burns to the ground, and greater destinies are exposed. A war between the Holy Kingdom and the Demon Kingdom is explained, and a quest undertaken to escort a princess to a safe castle. It's all very straightforward at first.
However, it doesn't take long for the seeds of greater things to be sewn, and for the cracks in the seams to appear. No sooner do they reach the Holy City than the truth comes out: Hamelin is a devil, and the princess is hated by her kingdom. What springs from this is a surprising tale of tortured children, made to suffer for their parent's sake. Of bittersweet love, of broken friendships, and of maddening revenge.
The Violinist of Hamelin may rightly be described as a tragedy. Our hero is, in fact, a demon and his demonic nature does, in fact, lead him to do terrible things, and from all of those terrible things comes his ultimate undoing. It's hard to explain it all without going too far into detail, but the series' ending boils down to a series of examples about how vengeance ruins pretty much the entire world.
Hamelin is, by its nature, a very character driven show, and central to the cast is "Who are you, really?" When confronted with her being a Princess, Flute finds the prospect repugnant, rather than a dream come true, because it casts suspicion on all her relationships and forces her into responsibilities she never wanted. This foreshadows Hamel's later problem of accepting that he is the Demon King's son, and the failure of the villains to accept who they really are as well, or, in one case, having it denied them.
As a final note, I'm told the anime is much, much darker than both the manga and the OVAs. I can't attest to either of those, but I can tell you that the show is definitely a great deal darker than I had expected. People get crucified, manipulated into hurting people they love, and one or two lives are spent in utter ruin as part of the most capricious of plans.
I enjoyed Hamelin, but I don't know if I can recommend it. If you can put up with it being largely inanimate, though, then I think you may be able to enjoy the character drama that unfolds to the backdrop of a classical fantasy tale.