dakkumauji
Member
Genshiken 09
This was like the episode of Haruhi where nothing happened and nothing happened.
This was like the episode of Haruhi where nothing happened and nothing happened.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Fall of Anime 2012 |OT2| O cursed spite, that ever I was born to UUURRRRYYY!!
- Thread starter kayos90
- Start date
- Status
Regulus Tera
Romanes Eunt Domus
Jex
Member
No, I think you're thinking about that episode of Hyouka.
Can't wait
This is how ADV treated Princess TuTu.
You can see her crying. Poor thing. Fucking criminal.
This is how Geneon treated a mediocre Kannazuki no Miko show.
Observe the artbox, beautiful artwork, double sides covers, insert artwork, pencil boards, and I hid the OTHER side of the inserts and pencil boards because 1. It is NSFW and 2. I dont want SDBurtons blood to explode through his nose. But Sdburton if you want I can PM you whats on the other side
http://imgur.com/a/b434Y
You can see her crying. Poor thing. Fucking criminal.
This is how Geneon treated a mediocre Kannazuki no Miko show.
Observe the artbox, beautiful artwork, double sides covers, insert artwork, pencil boards, and I hid the OTHER side of the inserts and pencil boards because 1. It is NSFW and 2. I dont want SDBurtons blood to explode through his nose. But Sdburton if you want I can PM you whats on the other side
http://imgur.com/a/b434Y
PoeticProse22
Member
Tonari no Kabiutsu-kun 9
This episode was the most enjoyable since the fourth, but, unfortunately, it was disappointingly inconsistent and flawed as well, faltering into a repetition of predictable, unnecessary contrivances in the latter half of the episode. There's this rather noticeable dichotomy between the numerous elements of the show that work extremely well and those that don't, as the latter have been increasingly filtered into each subsequent episode, consistently failing to impress, illustrating a middling execution of the narrative.
The opening was great and, though largely comedic, quite insightful, as the conversation between
illuminated an interesting complexity within
, only ever touched upon for a momentary instance in the subtle exploration of Shizuku's diligent, but partially naive aspirations to strictly follow the same path as
, which was mentioned once again in this episode, still appearing to be a singularly narrow-minded, but sympathetic, approach to dealing with life's unexpected complications.
Haru and Shizuku's interactions are extremely enjoyable, as the gradual development of their relationship illuminates their considerable chemistry and how significantly worse each episode is that doesn't heavily focus on this particular aspect of the story. As such, their relationship consistently provides the best moments in each episode, so it's quite unfortunate that it hasn't been as prevalent in the past several episodes, instead relying on a partial focus of dynamics that are far less compelling.
However, the slow, methodical development of their relationship is usually understandable, but it's become a bit tiresome as of late, due entirely to the knowledge that
are inevitably set to interfere even further with their hopes for a wholly romantic relationship to form. At this point, I'm even wondering if their relationship can, in fact, have a greatly satisfying conclusion, since there are a plethora of potential interruptions that can sabotage the growth that seems to solely be stalled in an increasingly tedious manner. Though Shizuku's
, it seems rather unrealistic that she wouldn't even remember to consider the
throughout an entire month, so this is yet another isolated moment that feels artificial in it's construction.
Natsume really is a fantastic character, as she, along with Haru, have, so far, elevated the show above purely unenjoyable mediocrity whenever a particular episode, such as this one, and the last few, for that matter, waste considerable time focusing on poor secondary characters and uninteresting narrative developments, such as
. As such, I liked the slight elaboration on
, since more development of her character is terrific, but it was accompanied with a moment that reinforced the possibility that she
, which, though
, is somewhat disappointing, since a relationship with
seems thoroughly foreshadowed and quite inevitable, but it's unlikely to be properly concluded by the end of the show, so it feels like a relatively unnecessary addition to her characterization and potential development, except, of course, for the possibility that it compels
to act on
.
Yamaken is a thoroughly unlikable character, devoid of an interesting personality or intriguing characterization. He'd likely be much better if his character development wasn't isolated into the one-dimensional role of a
. His highly contrived interactions with Shizuku aren't engaging at all, since he's far too closely similar to Shizuku, without any of the good aspects that preside within her characterization. As such, I couldn't care less about the development of
, so concluding the episode with an element of this situation only serves to illuminate numerous concerns about the future episodes.
The production values remain one of the strongest aspects of the show, as the beautifully colorful aesthetic complements the nature of the show really well, particularly during the scene in which Haru and Shizuku converse as they
. Musically, this episode was excellent, especially highlighted by the selection used throughout
. The quality of the narrative has noticeably diminished throughout the last last few episodes, as it has increasingly slipped into the highly predictable conventionality of a typically cliche shoujo, and, save for the excellent characters, it has too often lacked the brilliantly unique atmosphere and immense versatility that permeated the first few episodes. This, in large part, is due to the unfortunate introduction of two dull, completely ancillary characters and the terrible, worthless
that accompany them.
All in all, Tonari is quite good, but it's consistently failing to reach the considerably high level of brilliance it once possessed, instead resolving itself to transitioning into an underwhelming near-mediocrity. I'm not particularly confident that the direction the narrative is taking will improve, since the insufferable, monotonous
appear likely to receive a heightened focus throughout the following episodes. Hopefully I'm mistaken and all of this predictability is mere misdirection, but it's inevitability certainly seems to be irrevocably foreshadowed. I simply desire a satisfying conclusion, so, hopefully, this mess of trite complications and an increased level of interference will be resolved by then, since, so far, these developments only detract from each episode. Fortunately, the next episode will be centered around
, so I'd like to think that
won't be involved.
This episode was the most enjoyable since the fourth, but, unfortunately, it was disappointingly inconsistent and flawed as well, faltering into a repetition of predictable, unnecessary contrivances in the latter half of the episode. There's this rather noticeable dichotomy between the numerous elements of the show that work extremely well and those that don't, as the latter have been increasingly filtered into each subsequent episode, consistently failing to impress, illustrating a middling execution of the narrative.
The opening was great and, though largely comedic, quite insightful, as the conversation between
Haru and Shizuku's father
Shizuku's family
her mother
Haru and Shizuku's interactions are extremely enjoyable, as the gradual development of their relationship illuminates their considerable chemistry and how significantly worse each episode is that doesn't heavily focus on this particular aspect of the story. As such, their relationship consistently provides the best moments in each episode, so it's quite unfortunate that it hasn't been as prevalent in the past several episodes, instead relying on a partial focus of dynamics that are far less compelling.
However, the slow, methodical development of their relationship is usually understandable, but it's become a bit tiresome as of late, due entirely to the knowledge that
triangles
stubbornly distracted by schoolwork
full meaning of her love for Haru
Natsume really is a fantastic character, as she, along with Haru, have, so far, elevated the show above purely unenjoyable mediocrity whenever a particular episode, such as this one, and the last few, for that matter, waste considerable time focusing on poor secondary characters and uninteresting narrative developments, such as
the imminent love triangles
her difficult past
has feelings for Mitsuyoshi
he's a really likable character
Sasayan
Sasayan
his seemingly evident feelings for her
Yamaken is a thoroughly unlikable character, devoid of an interesting personality or intriguing characterization. He'd likely be much better if his character development wasn't isolated into the one-dimensional role of a
"love rival"
his superficial feelings for Shizuku
The production values remain one of the strongest aspects of the show, as the beautifully colorful aesthetic complements the nature of the show really well, particularly during the scene in which Haru and Shizuku converse as they
walk through the city
Natsume's reminiscence to her troubled past
triangles
All in all, Tonari is quite good, but it's consistently failing to reach the considerably high level of brilliance it once possessed, instead resolving itself to transitioning into an underwhelming near-mediocrity. I'm not particularly confident that the direction the narrative is taking will improve, since the insufferable, monotonous
triangles
Christmas
Yamaken and Chizuru
Jex
Member
Translation: it costs us more upfront to produce BD's and they don't sell well enough to cover manufacturer unless we know the show is going to be a big hit.
Thats sure as fuck not true because I have FRACTALE BLURAYS.
They didnt cheap on it either. the artwork and artbox is high quality and sturdy, the disc covers have double sided art and there are tons of disc extras.
for FRACTALE.
Tell us what the future brings.
dakkumauji
Member
At least in Hyouka, there was more than one character talking to himself.
Jex
Member
Yamauchi. He's going to cut between close ups of stuff really fast so you wont have any idea whats going on, what the geography of the scene is like. or who is interacting with who. The normal character designs will be pushed to one side and the colour scheme will be pretty wacky.
You don't need that stuff anyways.
Extremely recent manga spoilers:
the nose hair event in this episode actually comes back around in a very big way.
That episode was so unrealistic. Who in the hell is that socially inept that they cant approach a girl and tell her she has a noticeable nosehair?
Jex
Member
Paperman it aint.
It can't be as bad as episode 5, can it?
Chet Rippo
Member
There are a lot.
Jex
Member
Time will tell.
I don't understand why, every time the show starts to pick up momentum, boom, Yamauchi episode. He's like the Philip Rivers of anime.
Well here's what we know so far...
From the New World - Episode 10 preview:
http://i.imgur.com/vc4YD.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/AZ6r1.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/tNYvz.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/17S1D.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/bXb6F.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/JsJSF.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/fIbNK.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/6Q3ZH.jpg
Pathetic.
Screenshots can't show us editing and pacing, which was the biggest problem with episode 5.
But his episodes are good.
Oh but it can certainly show us editing. The last 3 screens are from a single animation cut! In fact, I think those are the only 3 frames in that 0.5 second cut.
Cantseeshit.jpg
Yamauchi has learned nothing!
I didnt know who that was, but that's pretty explanatory.
Idolm@ster and Chihayafuru both had pretty good Yamauchi episodes.
That's because SSY isn't a good show.
Yamauchi is good but he's not a miracle doctor.
And MGX!
Regulus Tera
Romanes Eunt Domus
The other Anime of the Year.
Neither of those shows is as narratively-focused as From the New World. It really takes you out of a story when it switches styles in the middle of a linear narrative arc.
Did you even watch the episode?
So how did we wind up with a first season like that?
No, I dropped SSY about halfway into ep1. I can smell a stinker from a mile away.
Right, so you just wanted to troll the conversation despite not knowing what you were talking about.
Chet Rippo
Member
Oniai 1
Ok, I get why the dude doesn't want to have a sexual relation with his sister. That makes sense. But when there's a bunch of girls that, as far as I know, aren't related to him want to sex him up, he still refuses. Stupid typical harem lead.
The other girls kinda just kinda appeared half way through the episode, I assume they're going to explain how they came to live with them right? So far so good anyways.
Being a brocon is suffering.
At least they know why I'm watching this show.
Ok, I get why the dude doesn't want to have a sexual relation with his sister. That makes sense. But when there's a bunch of girls that, as far as I know, aren't related to him want to sex him up, he still refuses. Stupid typical harem lead.
The other girls kinda just kinda appeared half way through the episode, I assume they're going to explain how they came to live with them right? So far so good anyways.
Talking cleavage.
Looks like she's wearing a red glove.
Uh, you didn't originally specify SSY 5 in this post:
Keep up with yourself before you start trying to accuse others of trolling.
That was a typo, it was supposed to say "the show." Anyway it was obvious in context what show I was talking about.
No it wasn't. It can also be read as everytime shows in general start to pick up momentum, which is how I read it, as if you were trying to troll everything he's directed without knowing what you're talking about. You should be more careful before you hit submit post.
How did we end up with that great season?
I don't think it's a matter of whether or not you're socially inept. It's a matter of whether or not you care enough to tell them
If you'd actually watched episode 5, you'd understand why people would have such a low opinion of him if they haven't experienced his other work. He should be more careful before producing such substandard work.
I don't think it's a matter of whether or not you're socially inept. It's a matter of whether or not you care enough to tell them
If that was the case, the character would have been indifferent but instead he just stared awkwardly going over ridiculous scenarios in his head.
Dedication Through Light
Member
My Little Monster 9
Sasayan and Haru interacting was my favorite part, just so funny and silent exchange and understanding I laughed. They needed more time together over the duration of this anime as it winds down.
Highschool girls are just plain awful
Alright episode I guess, ending scene was my second favorite with the cliffhanger of sorts
Sasayan and Haru interacting was my favorite part, just so funny and silent exchange and understanding I laughed. They needed more time together over the duration of this anime as it winds down.
Highschool girls are just plain awful
what is wrong with having guy friends, and then saying all that stuff, anyone would wanna be Sasayan's friend
Alright episode I guess, ending scene was my second favorite with the cliffhanger of sorts
can never have enough Yamaken around and the wrench he throws into the scheme here
Chooney 05:
fucking hell I had my times tables memorized when I was eight years old and Rikka is, what, fifteen? Though I was a math whiz so this kind of thing always baffles me, I guess.
I've given up raging at everyone enabling Rikka's stupidity. It's clear that this is just very well-made pander and I'll consume it as such from this point out.
Chooney 06:
So I was going to comment on how strange it was that the second half of the episode was being devoted to the overactive imagination of a minor character, but then I came to the realization that
. The cut between
felt rushed and unnatural since there was nothing in between to bridge the two events and so for a few minutes I was under the impression that
.
What a strange thing to devote a large portion of an episode to regardless.
Chooney 07:
oh god the worst thing that they could possibly do is try to justify the characters' behavior with DEEP PSYCHOLOGICAL TRAUMA. Please don't let this infect the rest of the show, stupid just becomes even more stupid when mixed with serious.
Chooney 08:
Looks like
.
Kind of feels like Rikka is regressing mentally even further; outside of the UNSEEN HORIZON shit she pretty much communicates in short sentences and auuuuuuus now. This arc really needs to end.
fucking hell I had my times tables memorized when I was eight years old and Rikka is, what, fifteen? Though I was a math whiz so this kind of thing always baffles me, I guess.
I've given up raging at everyone enabling Rikka's stupidity. It's clear that this is just very well-made pander and I'll consume it as such from this point out.
lots of good stuff on Danbooru was fairly influential in nudging me from rage toward apathy
Chooney 06:
So I was going to comment on how strange it was that the second half of the episode was being devoted to the overactive imagination of a minor character, but then I came to the realization that
it was actually happening
the notebook being lost on the pavement and Nibutani's inquisition
the scene was merely an extension of Minor Character-kun running scenarios in his head to prepare for meeting his crush
What a strange thing to devote a large portion of an episode to regardless.
Chooney 07:
oh god the worst thing that they could possibly do is try to justify the characters' behavior with DEEP PSYCHOLOGICAL TRAUMA. Please don't let this infect the rest of the show, stupid just becomes even more stupid when mixed with serious.
Chooney 08:
Looks like
Rikka wants to fuck Yuuta almost as much as the dog wants to fuck Shinka
Kind of feels like Rikka is regressing mentally even further; outside of the UNSEEN HORIZON shit she pretty much communicates in short sentences and auuuuuuus now. This arc really needs to end.
Chet Rippo
Member
Have you ever met someone like Madarame?
No, how did we end up with a kind of alright show that constantly trips over itself if it's so hard to screw up Chihayafuru? The last half of the series offered dip after dip when it came to quality, and the show is anything but consistent.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked