stupei said:As far as I could tell, it wasn't really between Goodsprings and the Powder Gangers, though. It was between a member of the Crimson Caravan and the Powder Gangers, but happened to take place near Goodsprings.
The people in Goodsprings pretty much say they don't like the guy taking shots at the local gang and riling them up, and a few of them direcrtly say they have no problem with you handing him over. I never went down that route so maybe doing so will result in the Powder Gangers turning on the towns people, but what is actually presented isn't "murder all these civilians or don't," it was one guy who doesn't even live there pissing off the local gang and then drawing a bunch of innocent civilians into his fight. You have to decide if you want to save him or not. I never got the impression that handing him over would immediately result in Powder Gangers overtaking the town, but maybe that's the case?
Yeah, there's not much middle ground at all. You just kill him for the Gangers and then proceed to help them murder the entire town.