There's a big difference between being skeptical about everything and not liking anything (ie. Derrick) vs being skeptical when actually called for it.
You know I am skeptical about a lot of stuff but I can get hyped too (and still enjoy a lot of games). Quite a few users on GAF are basically a new tier of Derrick where whenever they post it's like you know something negative is going to come out of their post.
People should look at their posts sometimes and see how many negative posts they have on here (ie. hating on something, complaining about something) vs something positive.
Advertising a kickstarter as if it were a real game announcement at a press conference is grimey ass shit that should be called out.
Lowballing an unrealistic budget (Shenmue 1 cost 70 million) just so your kickstarter can barrel past the goal at a record rate is misleading and should be called out.
Basically telling fans "show us how much you want this game or we won't fund it" is exploitative as hell, and only gets called out when it's Capcom asking for DMC sales.
People going crazy over this shit is troubling,
even if they like Shenmue. At this rate filipino champ will be raffling off a new wipeout game on stage for Sony's E3 2017