That's also unfair i think. The compilation itself is fairly nuanced with his character. In FFAC he is in clinical depression and suffering from a life threatening disease, hence why he is despondent. In FFCC he is actually quite open as a character and not closed off at all.
It is only in outside materials like KH and dissidia does he become overwrought, but even in those scenarios, it makes sense in context(in KH, he is actively struggling with his darkness, hence why Nomura decided to give him Vincents outfit, and in KH2, this is even more so true, until Tifa came) In dissidia 012 he has suffered a groundhog day effect for 12 cycles and has become numb to the process outside of his feelings for Tifa.
You have no idea how successful you just were in making me appreciate the Cloud we see outside the original game, lol. And yeah, I forgot about Crisis Core. He is cool there. I probably just forgot because I kind of like CC.I do not like the rest of Compilation, haha.
Agreed. Certainly in my top 3 FF protagonists, maybe even my absolute favorite, time will tell.
By the way, I disagree with people saying we needed more scenes between adult Noctis and Luna. I love the idea that in the end, he never managed to reach her. This's what made their reunion in death very emotional for me.
What the game needed, though, is more letters between them. Umbra was very underutilized in the game. The messages Luna and Noctis wrote to each other were a huge opportunity to flesh out their relationship. More frequent and longer letters would've done miracles improving the presentation of their relationship.
Amen all around.