I dunno? They're worried that, assuming lynch Sophia, my call for an instakill at the stat of the next day will then let mafia hammer Kawl to win the game. It is a legitimate problem.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Gafia 2.5: The Bachelor Party |Mafia OT| One Last Override
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
I dunno? They're worried that, assuming lynch Sophia, my call for an instakill at the stat of the next day will then let mafia hammer Kawl to win the game. It is a legitimate problem.
flatearthpandas
Member
You seemed sarcastic. Obviously that is the concern
Oh. It's a problem that I don't like the solution to, but it is a solution. Kawl's death will be an unfortunate side-effect of our scheme.
I know why he claimed it when he did, especially since he claimed it based on my actions, but it'd too bad it wasn't kept a secret.
flatearthpandas
Member
Still not following. You said to shoot Gorlak immediately. Allowing scum to gang up on kawl. And that is a solution how?
I said to shoot Gorlak immediately, not remembering the Kawl problem. The solution right now is to stack all of our votes on whoever we want lynched, then shoot someone else. That'd allow us to not have to waste a kill on Kawl, right? Or am I messing something up?
That's what we discussed last night yea.
flatearthpandas
Member
Anyway, despite Flame begging for it, my vote stands. Still a lot of votes to go and not much time.
flatearthpandas
Member
Just don't tie it. I swear to god if we get a tie...
And your response to my scenarios are what make me think you probably aren't scum, the smart play is to just let the day cruise to its end. But of course, as has been said before, if both of us are town then we have a problem.
flatearthpandas
Member
You're both getting lynched eventually. Quit posturing and vote.
Only voting if we're going for someone else other than me. I don't want to tie it up and cause a no lynch.
flatearthpandas
Member
Sophia, if you're so town vote for yourself and avoid the tie we're in danger of. If anyone ties it, you're dead tomorrow. If you're town, gg on losing the game.
Royal_Flush
Member
Fuck this, I want to know if it was my banana. We have enough room for error. Sorry, I'm at a home party right now so I won't reply to the theories right now.
Vote: Sophia
Stanley, don't shoot anyone tomorrow until we discussed who the right target is.
Vote: Sophia
Stanley, don't shoot anyone tomorrow until we discussed who the right target is.
I think we should probably just stay the course and avoid vote shenanigans with five minutes left.
Seeing as we're all here, why AREN'T we considering Gorlak today?
flatearthpandas
Member
The only vote shenanigans are you fucking clowns tying it.
The partiers are at a David Copperfield show (performing nightly at the MGM Grand at 7:00pm and 9:30pm with a bonus Saturday afternoon show, tickets starting at only $121). The enthralling magic is a welcome departure from a bachelor party that has been anything but normal.
RobotNinjaHornets is trying to stay awake after spending a long night at the strip club. Slumped in his seat, he barely notices a bright light illuminating him from above. Is it an alien abduction? Are they taking me to Mars? Should I tell Missy? Come to think of it, did I even get Missy’s number last night? Aww man, I’ll have to go back…
“RNH, go up there.”
“Huh?”
“They picked you for the next act.”
RNH stands as the audience applauds. He follows a smiling assistant up onto the stage, where Copperfield (holder of 11 Guinness World Records) awaits.
“Hello, and what’s your name?”
“Uh, RobotNinjaHornets.”
Forbes’ most commercially successful magician of all time blinks. “That is an interesting name. Mr. RobotNinjaHornets, please put on this vest. It’s bulletproof.”
In the audience, the party members whimper and lean back in their seats, looking around fearfully.
The 21-time Emmy winner chuckles. “Oh don’t worry, he isn’t getting shot. Not here, anyway. I’m going to make him disappear, and reappear in a politically unstable climate in the Middle East. I’ll bring him back if he’s in any danger.”
The man knighted by the French government waves his hands, and RNH vanishes in a puff of smoke. The audience cheers wildly.
After the applause dies down, the Library of Congress Living Legend waves his hands again. But nothing happens.
“Hmm technical difficulties. I’ll have to end the show for tonight. Don’t worry, I’ll bring him back. I swear it on my Hollywood Walk of Fame star!”
The curtains close and the orchestra plays. The audience is too perplexed to cheer or boo.
“What just happened?”
“The 2-time Magician of the Year as voted by the Academy of Magical Arts made RNH disappear permanently?”
“Hope he’s okay, but we’ll have to go on without him.”
Sophia has been removed from the party.
Day 4 has ended
Day 5 will begin in:
RobotNinjaHornets is trying to stay awake after spending a long night at the strip club. Slumped in his seat, he barely notices a bright light illuminating him from above. Is it an alien abduction? Are they taking me to Mars? Should I tell Missy? Come to think of it, did I even get Missy’s number last night? Aww man, I’ll have to go back…
“RNH, go up there.”
“Huh?”
“They picked you for the next act.”
RNH stands as the audience applauds. He follows a smiling assistant up onto the stage, where Copperfield (holder of 11 Guinness World Records) awaits.
“Hello, and what’s your name?”
“Uh, RobotNinjaHornets.”
Forbes’ most commercially successful magician of all time blinks. “That is an interesting name. Mr. RobotNinjaHornets, please put on this vest. It’s bulletproof.”
In the audience, the party members whimper and lean back in their seats, looking around fearfully.
The 21-time Emmy winner chuckles. “Oh don’t worry, he isn’t getting shot. Not here, anyway. I’m going to make him disappear, and reappear in a politically unstable climate in the Middle East. I’ll bring him back if he’s in any danger.”
The man knighted by the French government waves his hands, and RNH vanishes in a puff of smoke. The audience cheers wildly.
After the applause dies down, the Library of Congress Living Legend waves his hands again. But nothing happens.
“Hmm technical difficulties. I’ll have to end the show for tonight. Don’t worry, I’ll bring him back. I swear it on my Hollywood Walk of Fame star!”
The curtains close and the orchestra plays. The audience is too perplexed to cheer or boo.
“What just happened?”
“The 2-time Magician of the Year as voted by the Academy of Magical Arts made RNH disappear permanently?”
“Hope he’s okay, but we’ll have to go on without him.”
Sophia has been removed from the party.
Day 4 has ended
Day 5 will begin in:
After leaving the MGM Grand (and getting their money back for the abbreviated show from some hack magician), the group returns to their hotel.
Can you believe that fraud owns 11 islands in the Bahamas?
Poor RNH.
Elevators here.
Somehow they all pile into one elevator. At the 12th floor, they squeeze their way out.
Everyone here? Nice. See you tomorrow.
No one has been removed from the party
4 votes are needed for majority
Day 5 ends in:
Can you believe that fraud owns 11 islands in the Bahamas?
Poor RNH.
Elevators here.
Somehow they all pile into one elevator. At the 12th floor, they squeeze their way out.
Everyone here? Nice. See you tomorrow.
No one has been removed from the party
4 votes are needed for majority
Day 5 ends in:
flatearthpandas
Member
I vote we stack votes on Gorlak and then shoot Flame.
Rest easy big guy, Stanley is a day vig.
Did FEP watch you?
You expect me to know this...how?
I'm spitballing ideas at this point.
What if Gorlak/FEP are the two remaining scum. Is there anything we know that confirms FEP other than him and Gorlak's matching actions?
Because right now, FEP can come in and say that he saw Kawl visit Stanley, because that's what Kawl said he did, not really a test of his claim.
What if Gorlak/FEP are the two remaining scum. Is there anything we know that confirms FEP other than him and Gorlak's matching actions?
Because right now, FEP can come in and say that he saw Kawl visit Stanley, because that's what Kawl said he did, not really a test of his claim.
Gorlak has in no way been the one to verify FEP. That's all me. FEP saw me visit Gorlak N2.
Okay, thanks for clearing that up.
Answer this: Who are the last two scum?
And for the sake of argument, assume I am not one of them (which I'm not).
Roles in game:
Droplet - Ordinary Town
Nukedeggs - Ordinary Town
Zipped - Mafia 2 shot tracker
Squidyj - Ordinary Town
Gryvan - Ordinary Town
CrimsonFist - Town Beloved Virgin
Sophia - Ordinary Town
Remaining:
Kawl - Town Hated Role Cop
FEP - ??? X-Shot Watcher (soft confirmed by seeing me visit Gorlak)
Royal Flush - ??? Fruit Vendor (and I'll be having words with game designers after this if this roles items actually do something)
Gorlak - ??? Ordinary
Flame_AC - ??? Ordinary
Stanley - ??? Day Vig (almost certainly town)
Only one I haven't personally seen as a result is FEP. Could a JOAT be possible and he decided to leverage that into posing as a town watcher. Possible.
We've been working on the assumption of 3 scum in a 14 player game probably with one goon, I think thats a decent assumption looking at numbers and especially seeing how weak town is.(Role cop worst cop, virgin can have negative utility, though pairing it with beloved modifier makes it a bit better as he can have that confirmed and be trusted when he says something bad will happen if he's lynched, day vig is hit or miss, etc).
I find it a bit hard to swallow scum would only have a 2 shot tracker for a PR though. I really thought Sophia would flip as scum PR and make this situation make more sense.
Is it likely to be RF? Probably not I guess, the real fruit vendor would have counterclaimed by now. We don't actually know however, that the vendor is a town role. It could very well be scum, given that they didn't know what it would do, it's certainly plausible what happened with Zipped.
If Stanley performs his day shot as expected, following the will of town, he's probably town as well. There is no logical reason for him to have played the way he has otherwise.
Kawl? His checks have so far been correct, but they could have been faked. His statement on me came after I claimed. Gorlak had his claim as well and so, if Kawl was scum, could infer that RF woud be the fruit vendor.
Gorlak - Probably scum.
Kawl? His checks have so far been correct, but they could have been faked. His statement on me came after I claimed. Gorlak had his claim as well and so, if Kawl was scum, could infer that RF woud be the fruit vendor.
Gorlak - Probably scum.
Actually Gorlak simply stated that he hadn't taken an action N2, not that he was ordinary.
Since you're here. You still haven't answered the question.
On that point, one might be able to infer he was ordinary. Most roles are active every night.
The point is that he was going out of his way to not state whether or not he was an ordinary. Let's try to not be coy, yes?
And frankly I'm not really interested in going around and around with you. I'll wait for some others to actually check in.