• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Gafia 3 [Mafia] | Welcome to Lynchwood Acres

franconp

Member
I don't like this weird code thing. I'll keep my Sorian vote unless Fran or Splinter really vouch for you.

My message said that if he needed to make me know him he would quote and ask how was my day.

It could be any aligment. I still town read Sorian.
 

Faddy

Banned
I told you it was lazy, the night before I had drivin for a few hours and that day I had to catch a flight. Don't worry, all Splinter got was me harping on Blarg, Swamped and Sorian (lol) being scum.

Why give Splinter incorrect reads? It seems like you were sending out disinformation which along with your other play tendencies makes me think you might be a neutral with a survival condition.
 

Sorian

Banned
For anyone who cares about the full claim, I'm Flux, a ham radio enthusiast ( I don't get the joke if there is one), all I can do is send 500 character or less messages and the only other stipulation is I can't break any thread rules?, so no quoting my role pm for example.
 

Sorian

Banned
Why give Splinter incorrect reads? It seems like you were sending out disinformation which along with your other play tendencies makes me think you might be a neutral with a survival condition.

What disinformation? Those were my top scum reads. Throwing myself in so Splinter wouldn't guess me but I also gave two ways to identify myself to him if he started walking down only that track.
 

Swamped

Banned
You still didn't explain the swerve on your read.

I did, but here it is again. Your weak as heck read of me from that recent post. You don't even remember why you scum read me in the first place, yet you have consistently scum read me for four days now. So you have had four whole days to make a case, but haven't. Also i feel like you're trying to get more out of my claim by calling it "garbage". Sorry but that's not going to work friend.
 

Faddy

Banned
What disinformation? Those were my top scum reads. Throwing myself in so Splinter wouldn't guess me but I also gave two ways to identify myself to him if he started walking down only that track.

But if you are town why would it matter if he identified you?

Obviously he is going to want to now who sent the letter. What other outcome did you see?
 
Hm...so here are my reads


*Splinter: still don't know EXACTLY what he is but mostly sure he's town.

Burbeting: find him slightly scummy due to reasons I posted yesterday in game.

Sorian: claims Flux. Message giver. Lean town.

Swamped: claims carrier. Don't know if I buy it. Lean scum...

Faddy: lean scum...?

WhereAreMahDragonz: honestly thought she was town but I'm not incredibly sure anymore.

Bronx-Man: claims poison doctor, no one was poisoned today(?). Lean town but who knows.

Acohrs: lean scum.

StanleyPalmtree: claimed he was poisoned. Lean town?

Everyone I left off I honestly don't know. Even the people I have as scum I'm unsure of. Awful at reading people because I'm usually always scum so I never have to. Awful excuse for awful reads. Fuq. Sorian's claim takes me back to square one.
 

Ourobolus

Banned
acohrs (5)
flatearthpandas 2750
stanleypalmtree 2793
franconp 3018
wherearemahdragonz 3032
kawl_usc 3100

sorian (4)
faddy 2903
theworthyedge 3130
acohrs 3134
swamped 3139

wherearemahdragonz (2)
gorlak 2913
swamped 3083 (3139)
ccs 3095

theworthyedge (1)
sorian 2910 (2994)
swamped 3076 (3083)
sorian 3116

swamped (1)
theworthyedge 2791 (3123)
*splinter 2898

faddy (0)
ccs 2816 (3095)
sorian 2994 (3116)
acohrs 3023 (3121)

gorlak (0)
kawl_usc 2835 (3100)

bronx-man (0)
kyanrute 2911 (2977)

*splinter (0)
swamped 2783 (3073)

Day 4 Ends:
red_1489784400.png


Majority is 9
 

Swamped

Banned
My main reason for leaving town on Sorian was because of his early vote on Blarg on D3. But thinking about it town or scum Sorian could have done that.

Also, scum sending a message to their scum mate on N1 is not out of the realm of possibility, to check flavor etc.

I'm more convinced than ever that this is the right move.
 

franconp

Member
Hm...so here are my reads


*Splinter: still don't know EXACTLY what he is but mostly sure he's town.

Burbeting: find him slightly scummy due to reasons I posted yesterday in game.

Sorian: claims Flux. Message giver. Lean town.

Swamped: claims carrier. Don't know if I buy it. Lean scum...

Faddy: lean scum...?

WhereAreMahDragonz: honestly thought she was town but I'm not incredibly sure anymore.

Bronx-Man: claims poison doctor, no one was poisoned today(?). Lean town but who knows.

Acohrs: lean scum.

StanleyPalmtree: claimed he was poisoned. Lean town?

Everyone I left off I honestly don't know. Even the people I have as scum I'm unsure of. Awful at reading people because I'm usually always scum so I never have to. Awful excuse for awful reads. Fuq. Sorian's claim takes me back to square one.

You are town reading Splinter but not Faddy? How that even works?
 

Sorian

Banned
If anything, I'm surprised scum hasn't NK'd Sorian by now. Dude is always in their sights at the start of each game.

This is old meta garbage. I haven't been high impact at all this game and have not shaped a single lynch, why would imthey bother.

I did, but here it is again. Your weak as heck read of me from that recent post. You don't even remember why you scum read me in the first place, yet you have consistently scum read me for four days now. So you have had four whole days to make a case, but haven't. Also i feel like you're trying to get more out of my claim by calling it "garbage". Sorry but that's not going to work friend.

Faddy wanted me to talk about where I stand on you and I did. Your claim is bullshit, you aren't an x-shot commuter that acted N1 as a townie, it makes 0 sense. It also isn't new that I've been scum reading you. It's been the same for days now and through it all you've town read me because of Blarg stuff, suddenly out of that read you come full force when there is an actual wagon on me though.

But if you are town why would it matter if he identified you?

Obviously he is going to want to now who sent the letter. What other outcome did you see?

Because I don't know that he is town? Why would I want scum to know who I am when town doesn't? Both Splinter and Blarg got the same hint as to who I was. The first letter of each sentence spelled out my name in their messages. If Blarg figured that out then scum has known me since day 2, something to keep in mind.

-----

For bonus points, you lean town on me now Worthy?
 

franconp

Member
Let's not even get into that. Here is a fact, he is happy to join a lynch on Sorian with 3 people he is scum reading.

Why would we get into that? If there is something I find strange I will ask and Made read. That is what this game is about.

If he trust Splinter he must trust his claim. So you should be town. Not following that logic is scummy.
 

*Splinter

Member
Looks like gorlak isn't going to get any traction.

Yalls loss.

Vote: Acohrs

Inconsistent logic, bad reads lists, same reasons as before.

Will read over wamd after work is over though, need to see if there is a case there beyond meta game stuff. Don't have a good read on swamped either, some bad mojo but I'm almost certain that's just residual omgus. Will look at her too if possible to form a meaningful read.

Acohrs and sorian need to move their votes or else make a case for why splinter is lying/wrong.
How?
 
Where is Gorlak, flatearthpandas, Burb, and stanley?

Also. Sorian...i really don't know. But Swamped brings up a good point regarding your role and how it aligned with Mafia in SW. But I don't want to bring in past games...

I lean scum on you because of that but if there was no SW game I'd lean town...so I think I'm leaning more town than Scum?

Idk...
 

franconp

Member
Why would we get into that? If there is something I find strange I will ask and Made read. That is what this game is about.

If he trust Splinter he must trust his claim. So you should be town. Not following that logic is scummy.

*Why wouldn't we get into that?

*Will ask and make reads.
 

Faddy

Banned
Why would we get into that? If there is something I find strange I will ask and Made read. That is what this game is about.

If he trust Splinter he must trust his claim. So you should be town. Not following that logic is scummy.

Sorry I should have been clearer. There are definitely ways I could be scum (e.g. re-directs) so his read of me being scum isn't as troubling to me as him joining up with 3 of his scum reads on a lynch.
 

Sorian

Banned
Where is Gorlak, flatearthpandas, Burb, and stanley?

Also. Sorian...i really don't know. But Swamped brings up a good point regarding your role and how it aligned with Mafia in SW. But I don't want to bring in past games...

I lean scum on you because of that but if there was no SW game I'd lean town...so I think I'm leaning more town than Scum?

Idk...

The message giver was town in election mafia. And that game was run by......oh look Ouro. Basing it on just past games isn't going to get anywhere.
 
May switch over to Burb...or possibly acorhs because I do scum read him and Burb will most likely not get any traction. Swamped is a possibility as well for my vote today.

Argh..
 

franconp

Member
Where is Gorlak, flatearthpandas, Burb, and stanley?

Also. Sorian...i really don't know. But Swamped brings up a good point regarding your role and how it aligned with Mafia in SW. But I don't want to bring in past games...

I lean scum on you because of that but if there was no SW game I'd lean town...so I think I'm leaning more town than Scum?

Idk...

What? I don't understand this post at all.

Also where is CCS too?
 

*Splinter

Member
Yeah Sorian is the messager.

I had been assuming the message was from scum. The way it's written almost assumes I am town (it points out that it could have been sent from scum, but seems to have no such reservations about my alignment). Sorian has been town reading me, so I'm not totally sure now...

Sorian is probably scum. I'd still rather lynch Swamped first but for some reason that lynch isn't going anywhere (I wonder why).

My main reason for leaving town on Sorian was because of his early vote on Blarg on D3. But thinking about it town or scum Sorian could have done that.

Also, scum sending a message to their scum mate on N1 is not out of the realm of possibility, to check flavor etc.

I'm more convinced than ever that this is the right move.
Yeah we did exactly this in Election.
 

*Splinter

Member
Why are you telling Faddy to claim when you are more likely to die than he is? Also, why aren't you just saying what happened last night as well, you're already 2/3 of the claim?
He was more likely to die since we haven't lost any protective roles yet.

It's probably more 50/50 now that I've pointed it out.
 

Kawl_USC

Member

As I say following that line, I have a lean scum feeling on her, but I'm not certain that's really due to anything beyond her constantly saying something is off about me but never producing anything. I can't remember any major points from her that I feel are shit, like I do with acohrs.
 

*Splinter

Member
VOTE: Sorian

Think that's 6-6

My preferences in order are Swamped -> Sorian -> Acohrs

Any one of those flipping scum would reinforce my reads of the others (although there's less link between Sorian and acohrs directly).

I'm out again for a bit. Probably won't be back in time for day end.

Protect Faddy please. I assume I will be blocked even if I survive.
 

Sorian

Banned
I have nothing else to defend myself with. I've made my case and I do think there is high percentage of scum within Worthy, Swamped, and Acohrs, at least 2 out of 3. Splinter and fran have been my strong town reads which is why they got messages. Splinter did worry me with his partial claim and I'm still not sold on why he thinks he is a likelier target than his green check but that doesn't drain away the rest of the goodwill. Worthy is clearly flopping around on dry land but somehow votes keep coming onto me from literally no where.
 

Kawl_USC

Member
Won't be voting Sorian over Acohrs, I find sorian's logic at the very least consistent which is more than can be said for aco.

also going to be driving for the next hour, should be here for days end though.
 

CCS

Banned
I'm in Poland so my posts today have been minimal, sorry about that.

Scum reading WAMD, TWE, slight scum on Burb and Sorian.

Not wild about either of the lynch targets, but if I have to pick I'll go with the one I do think is slight scum.

VOTE: Sorian
 
Won't be voting Sorian over Acohrs, I find sorian's logic at the very least consistent which is more than can be said for aco.

also going to be driving for the next hour, should be here for days end though.

I agree. I think his claim is reasonable and if it's between him and Acorn, I'm going to go with my stronger scumread
 

Sorian

Banned
Now it would be tied 6-6 btw, Splinter made it 6-5.

I am going to make it 7-6 though, cards should just be on the table.

VOTE: Acohrs
 
Top Bottom