• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Game of Thrones *NO BOOK DISCUSSION* |OT2| Season 7 - [Read the OP]

T

The Artisan

Member
there was one thing about what Tormund said that confused me "how many of Mance's people died because he didn't kneel" - first off it seems quite out of character for Tormund to say that, because Mance didn't do so because of the opinions of the wildlings

secondly, if I recall correctly, none of the wildlings were executed because Mance didn't kneel. They were all already prisoners at Castle Black. They only died at battle. After Mance was killed they remained prisoners...they were never executed because of Mance's pride
 
I

-ImaginaryInsider

Member
The Artisan said:
secondly, if I recall correctly, none of the wildlings were executed because Mance didn't kneel. They were all already prisoners at Castle Black. They only died at battle. After Mance was killed they remained prisoners...they were never executed because of Mance's pride
Click to expand...

I took it to mean had Mance bent the knee, the Wildings would have been let through the wall right then to fight for Stannis, sure some would have died, but it would have likely saved more lives and would have been better deaths than what eventually happened at Hardhome.
 
E

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
aBarreras said:
im saying more rolling the dice about jon or his allies surviving the battle.

also little finger is the smartest and i dont think he believes in White walkers, so believing in them or not, has nothing to be with being dumb or smart
Click to expand...

It does in this context, though. Sansa would have to be a dribbling moron to not think the White Walkers are real after seeing everything that has happened up until this point. Jon, the Night's Watch and the Wildlings all saw it, they also all know Jon was resurrected and now he went North of the Wall to bring one back South, and you're saying she doesn't think they're real? Like, you make it sound like I'm the one who doesn't give Sansa any credit but you're implying she might just be the dumbest person in the show.
 
H

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
SurrenderDorothy said:
3rd time won't be a fakeout, eh? :/
I miss the "attack on Castle Black" Jon, rezzed Jon's not taking care of himself to the detriment of himself and others.
Click to expand...

He's already at 4 in a row (saved by his horsemen, saved by the Knight's of the Vale, saved by Dany and her dragons, saved by Uncle Benjen).

Northern Cavalry save Jon:

1ujv6o.gif


Sansa and the Vale save Jon:

1ujvi8.gif


Dany and her dragons save Jon:

1ujuyp.gif


Uncle Benjen saves Jon:

1ujur5.gif


And if we include this,

GOT3-4.gif


All I have to say is, buddy has a lot to pay back for. I think a sacrifice is highly likely.
 
H

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
The Artisan said:
there was one thing about what Tormund said that confused me "how many of Mance's people died because he didn't kneel" - first off it seems quite out of character for Tormund to say that, because Mance didn't do so because of the opinions of the wildlings

secondly, if I recall correctly, none of the wildlings were executed because Mance didn't kneel. They were all already prisoners at Castle Black. They only died at battle. After Mance was killed they remained prisoners...they were never executed because of Mance's pride
Click to expand...

Hardhome bro. Mance led a force of over 100,000 Wilding, and yet not even 10% of them made it south of the wall. Had Mance knelt to Stannis, the Usurper's brother would have let them come south, and the Wilding would have followed Mance (or at the very least many more than the ones Jon was able to save).
 
A

aBarreras

Member
Einchy said:
It does in this context, though. Sansa would have to be a dribbling moron to not think the White Walkers are real after seeing everything that has happened up until this point. Jon, the Night's Watch and the Wildlings all saw it, they also all know Jon was resurrected and now he went North of the Wall to bring one back South, and you're saying she doesn't think they're real? Like, you make it sound like I'm the one who doesn't give Sansa any credit but you're implying she might just be the dumbest person in the show.
Click to expand...

what does have jon going north of the wall this season anything to do with sansa not believing in white walkers last season?????
 
E

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
aBarreras said:
i mean everyone else know those things and still have their reservations, why sansa having them makes her the dumbest person?
Click to expand...

Literally no one who joined Jon has those reservations, that's why they joined Jon.

[edit]

My point is that Sansa isn't dumb, so of course she believes they're real. Who wouldn't at that point? You're saying that she doesn't, which would make her pretty dumb.
 
T

The Artisan

Member
MoonsaultSlayer said:
Your images never seem to work for me.
Click to expand...
something strange is happening in this thread...

edit: that was just an avatar quote, by the way
Heshinsi said:
Hardhome bro. Mance led a force of over 100,000 Wilding, and yet not even 10% of them made it south of the wall. Had Mance knelt to Stannis, the Usurper's brother would have let them come south, and the Wilding would have followed Mance (or at the very least many more than the ones Jon was able to save).
Click to expand...
first, before I respond, did you put a link where you said "led"? because it redirects me to a spam link...maybe it's a virus?

secondly, you're right, i forgot about that. i was only accounting for the wildling prisoners, but not the 90,00 poor souls who are fuckin zombies now.
 
H

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
The Artisan said:
something strange is happening in this thread...

edit: that was just an avatar quote, by the way
first, before I respond, did you put a link where you said "led"? because it redirects me to a spam link...maybe it's a virus?

secondly, you're right, i forgot about that. i was only accounting for the wildling prisoners, but not the 90,00 poor souls who are fuckin zombies now.
Click to expand...

No, there's no link. Strange.
 
V

Volimar

Member
Artisan, you might want to run a malwarebytes scan.

The Artisan said:
Sansa has proven herself to be loyal and loving and concerned sister to Jon this season as far as I can see as a viewer
Click to expand...

I agree, though I also think that Sansa feels she is owed something for everything she has suffered. And now that it comes out that she credits herself for saving Jon in the BoB she definitely feels like she has it within her to rule.
 
M

Megalosaro

Banned
Has Jon ever done anything? Seems to me he has always failed, only to gave his ass saved by someone else who succeeded in what he wanted to do
 
H

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
LegendofDragoonLives said:
that's Jon dude. Not Danny lol. He is the Dragon and The Wolf. Accept it Targ stans

game-of-thrones-littlefinger-shadows.gif
Click to expand...

There's nothing about him save blood that's a dragon. He's a Wolf through and through.

Volimar said:
Being a good leader doesn't mean having to get it done by yourself.
Click to expand...

Sure, but I think the question is if Jon has won a single battle. He defeated the initial strike force sent against the wall, but even he knew that if Mance throw his full force at him he'd lose. Hence why he went to parley with him. It was Stannis that actually ended the Wilding threat. He also didn't win the battle of the bastard, and would have assuredly died on the lake had Dany not shown up when she did. How is he even considered a good commander, if he is always at the brink of defeat, only to get bailed out by someone else?
 
T

The Artisan

Member
Valar Morghulis said:
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1422490
Click to expand...
FUCK FUCK FUCK! I clicked on the link, now I gotta bring this to the apple store?
Volimar said:
Artisan, you might want to run a malwarebytes scan.
Click to expand...
I have AVG antivirus, will that do the trick?
Volimar said:
I agree, though I also think that Sansa feels she is owed something for everything she has suffered. And now that it comes out that she credits herself for saving Jon in the BoB she definitely feels like she has it within her to rule.
Click to expand...
She does deserve something, though. She's been mentally traumatized at King's Landing, then at the Vale castle idk remember what it's called, and then she was raped. Just like Theon, she technically never had counseling for everything she's been through.
Megalosaro said:
Has Jon ever done anything? Seems to me he has always failed, only to gave his ass saved by someone else who succeeded in what he wanted to do
Click to expand...
"he was the first to make allies of wildlings and northmen."

"he died for us. if we don't offer to do the same, we're cowards."
 
W

water_wendi

Water is not wet!
Heshinsi said:
He's already at 4 in a row (saved by his horsemen, saved by the Knight's of the Vale, saved by Dany and her dragons, saved by Uncle Benjen).

Northern Cavalry save Jon:

https://i.imgflip.com/1ujv6o.gif[IMG]

[U]Sansa and the Vale save Jon:[/U]

[IMG]https://i.imgflip.com/1ujvi8.gif[IMG]

[U]Dany and her dragons save Jon:[/U]

[IMG]https://i.imgflip.com/1ujuyp.gif[IMG]
[U]
Uncle Benjen saves Jon:[/U]

[IMG]https://i.imgflip.com/1ujur5.gif[IMG]

And if we include this,

[IMG]http://cdn.fansided.com/gif/GOT3-4.gif?w=650[IMG]

All I have to say is, buddy has a lot to pay back for. I think a sacrifice is highly likely.[/QUOTE]

i think this counts

[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/kExEPOw.gif
Click to expand...
 
H

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
water_wendi said:
k1OUarq.gif
Click to expand...

To be fair, we do have to remind everyone that Jon did save that farmer. We can not gloss over his moments of...wait a minute, didn't Summer save him there too?! Just checked, and yes he gets bailed out by Summer! Hahaha! Add Summer to the list of names of characters who have bailed our boy out.
 
S

Son Of Sparda

Member
Just a few quick and possibly stupid questions about episode 6.

Didn't they need Dragonglass to kill White Walkers? Then how did Jon kill one of them in this episode?

Do they also need Dragonglass to kill the normal dead (wights?) or are can those be killed with any weapon?
 
W

water_wendi

Water is not wet!
Heshinsi said:
To be fair, we do have to remind everyone that Jon did save that farmer. We can not gloss over his moments of...wait a minute, didn't Summer save him there too?! Just checked, and yes he gets bailed out by Summer! Hahaha!
Click to expand...

New dumb theory time: Bran is time travel warging into everyone thats saving him. Bran is going to be like that whatshername from Doctor Who.
 
B

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
Son Of Sparda said:
Just a few quick and possibly stupid questions about episode 6.

Didn't they need Dragonglass to kill White Walkers? Then how did Jon kill one of them in this episode?

Do they also need Dragonglass to kill the normal dead (wights?) or are can those be killed with any weapon?
Click to expand...

His Valareian Steel sword can also do the job.

Wrights can be killed with dragonglass, Valareian Steel, or fire.
 
V

Vashetti

Banned
Son Of Sparda said:
Just a few quick and possibly stupid questions about episode 6.

Didn't they need Dragonglass to kill White Walkers? Then how did Jon kill one of them in this episode?

Do they also need Dragonglass to kill the normal dead (wights?) or are can those be killed with any weapon?
Click to expand...

Valyrian Steel also kills White Walkers. How can you forget Hardhome?
 
O

Oberon

Banned
Son Of Sparda said:
Just a few quick and possibly stupid questions about episode 6.

Didn't they need Dragonglass to kill White Walkers? Then how did Jon kill one of them in this episode?

Do they also need Dragonglass to kill the normal dead (wights?) or are can those be killed with any weapon?
Click to expand...

Valyrian weapon do the same. And I think any weapons for the zombies
 
S

SurrenderDorothy

Banned
Son Of Sparda said:
Just a few quick and possibly stupid questions about episode 6.

Didn't they need Dragonglass to kill White Walkers? Then how did Jon kill one of them in this episode?

Do they also need Dragonglass to kill the normal dead (wights?) or are can those be killed with any weapon?
Click to expand...

Jon's Valyrian Steel sword kills WWs, it was a big moment in Season 5 when he managed to block an attack that would've shattered ordinary steel.

The others had Dragonglass, it was stupid of them not to give us a line or two indicating that they've had it.
Same with provisions, they left the Wall with bags that must have food or something.
A couple of lines could have mitigated some of the weirdness of this episode.
 
H

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
water_wendi said:
New dumb theory time: Bran is time travel warging into everyone thats saving him. Bran is going to be like that whatshername from Doctor Who.
Click to expand...

Sorry I misspoke, both Summer and Shaggydog saved him lol.

1ujzkl.gif


I can't stop laughing in how all these timely saves are the reason buddy is still with us. Just in this gif you see a guy ready to strike him with a sword...SAVED! Another is about to let loose an arrow...SAVED!
 
S

Son Of Sparda

Member
Thank you everyone.

It's been a while since I last saw the show so I'd completely forgotten about his sword. (now I wanna go back and re-watch Hardhome)

Last question, I don't remember Uncle Benjen at all, so..... what was he doing there?
 
W

water_wendi

Water is not wet!
Heshinsi said:
Sorry I misspoke, both Summer and Shaggydog saved him lol.

1ujzkl.gif


I can't stop laughing in how all these timely saves are the reason buddy is still with us. Just in this gif you see a guy ready to strike him with a sword...SAVED! Another is about to let loose and arrow...SAVED!
Click to expand...

DztgcTo.gif
 
E

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
Son Of Sparda said:
Thank you everyone.

It's been a while since I last saw the show so I'd completely forgotten about his sword. (now I wanna go back and re-watch Hardhome)

Last question, I don't remember Uncle Benjen at all, so..... what was he doing there?
Click to expand...

This should remind ya of Benjen.

Season 1

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=69mO9reqUPI

Couldn't find a video for the next Benjen related scene, but Ghost comes back with a hand, which makes them realize Benjen and his group are in trouble so they make an expedition to go find them, which is how Jon gets mixed up with the Wildings.

Then we don't see him until he saved Bran in season 6 and then he tells Bran this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ecps6L5M0Gs
 
E

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
Speaking of the Lord of Light, ya'll think we'll ever know if he's, like, a real living thing or something? With how powerful Night King is, and since he is yet another part of a Song of Ice and Fire, and the Lord of Light is the other side, it makes it seem like the Lord of Light has to be real and somewhere out there.
 
B

broncobuster

Banned
Einchy said:
Speaking of the Lord of Light, ya'll think we'll ever know if he's, like, a real living thing or something? With how powerful Night King is, and since he is yet another part of a Song of Ice and Fire, and the Lord of Light is the other side, it makes it seem like the Lord of Light has to be real and somewhere out there.
Click to expand...

Given the crazy Bran theories some run with, I propose the equally stupid theory that the Lord of Light will be Dany and Jon's future child somehow guiding everyone to his birth.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

House of the Dragon S2 |OT| Blood for Blood, Fire to Fire (no book discussion)
6 7 8 9 10
457
18K
SlimySnake replied
‘The Last of Us’ Season 1 Finale Scores 8.2 Million Viewers, Reaching Series High
News 2 3
141
8K
Zephyrus0 replied
HBO Original | The Last of Us | Part 1 OT | Endure & Survive
79 80 81 82 83
4K
199K
VulcanRaven replied
The "I survived development hell" club (7 years+) of games (2024 edition)
36
2K
Holammer replied
George R.R. Martin flew to New York to 'beg' an HBO executive to make 'Game of Thrones' 10 seasons long, according to his agent
2 3
105
8K
Kenpachii replied
Top Bottom