ah yes... that evidence. Still doesn't make sense for that character to do it.
mercy doesn't really seem to be where he aims.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Game of Thrones *Tagged Book Spoilers, Please Read OP* |OT| Season 3 - Sundays on HBO
- Thread starter Steelyuhas
- Start date
- Status
ah yes... that evidence. Still doesn't make sense for that character to do it.
Trojita
Rapid Response Threadmaker
It's kind of weird to see a group on a forum like this kept in a bubble, to the point that there are two threads and any discussion of the source in the other is bannabe. I see why it needs to be done, it just still seems weird. Like allowing people to revel in their ignorance.
Have we had anything of this scale before? Years and years of viewers of a different medium not going on while other people do from the original medium. I mean at most I could think of the LOTR movies.
It makes it worse when show only watchers try and portray book readers as book nerds.
It's cos they pay no attention to what's happened before and/or where it happened. So when that one guy brought up what Jorah was up to in S1, there were people thinking it was book info :|
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=ItUyT9FpLXw
At 0:26, is that
At 0:26, is that
Jojen Reed being restricted? What the heck?
Done. Sorry.
Trojita
Rapid Response Threadmaker
ASOS: I thought
Joffrey got the dagger from the collective armory of the caraven.
Maybe I'm wrong.
You're probably right. I can't remember. I'll have to go look it up.
Also, Morrigan, fix your quote of Mission's post so that it's spoilered.
Nah, you're right.
ASOS:
Wasn't Robert fond of Valryian steel so he brought a bunch with him North to Winterfell? Either way, they had a portable armoury of Valryian steel daggers.
ASOS:
It's certainly possible, but don't you think we would know about that from the books?
ASOS:
I'm curious how they'll do the reveal on the show, should be good to watch hopefully. Although it's a year away 
timetokill
Banned
Remove the quote attribution or else that poster will see his post quoted in this thread.
Morrigan Stark
Arrogant Smirk
ASOSRW is gonna be brutal enough without watching Dacey take the fucking axe to the stomach.
[ASoS]
Oops, I actually meant Maege, she's the one who's carrying Robb's letter. But yeah poor Dacey, that was sad too.
[ASoS]
Fine, I edited the "lol" but come on, isn't this going too far in spoiler paranoia now? "lol" could mean anything, from "comically incorrect" to "funny how he got that so right".
I guess I'll just post every single thing in tags from now on... I only wish there were a feature that automatically showed all spoiler tags (like on the Winteriscoming blog, you click a button and it makes all the tags auto-readable). I find this thread interesting to discuss but the tag frenzy is getting an eyesore, especially since almost everyone in this thread has read all the books. :\
I guess I'll just post every single thing in tags from now on... I only wish there were a feature that automatically showed all spoiler tags (like on the Winteriscoming blog, you click a button and it makes all the tags auto-readable). I find this thread interesting to discuss but the tag frenzy is getting an eyesore, especially since almost everyone in this thread has read all the books. :\
[ASoS]Oops, I actually meant Maege, she's the one who's carrying Robb's letter. But yeah poor Dacey, that was sad too.
[ASoS]Fine, I edited the "lol" but come on, isn't this going too far in spoiler paranoia now? "lol" could mean anything, from "comically incorrect" to "funny how he got that so right".
I guess I'll just post every single thing in tags from now on... I only wish there were a feature that automatically showed all spoiler tags (like on the Winteriscoming blog, you click a button and it makes all the tags auto-readable). I find this thread interesting to discuss but the tag frenzy is getting an eyesore, especially since almost everyone in this thread has read all the books. :\
Fix your post in #5276!
There's always the all books read no spoiler tag thread if you want to not worry about it at all: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=433233
Of course this requires you to have read them all.
Of course this requires you to have read them all.
I already know about the events you guys are discussing, but I think it's a bit rude to pull out peoples' posts from the other thread to ridicule them.
They're just watching a TV show and trying to speculate on it. Once certain things are over and done with, I'm sure the showrunners are going to reimagine the rest of it in ways you aren't expecting either.
They're just watching a TV show and trying to speculate on it. Once certain things are over and done with, I'm sure the showrunners are going to reimagine the rest of it in ways you aren't expecting either.
Pai Pai Master
Banned
That thread taunts me every day. Like a posting nirvana entirely free of spoilers. One of these days I will have the time to sit down and marathon the last two books. I'm like halfway through AFFC.
Yeah fuck non book readers right
I've read it all but that thread doesn't follow the show as closely and the tangents make ones like this afternoons discussion seem really short.
So without getting banned from here; this special site I go to doesn't seem to have what I want. Is there any other way to watch Game of Thrones for free
note: I didn't ask if it was illegal or legal. So any links to my pm would be appreciated
Go to a friend's house.
So without getting banned from here; this special site I go to doesn't seem to have what I want. Is there any other way to watch Game of Thrones for free
note: I didn't ask if it was illegal or legal. So any links to my pm would be appreciated
Wait until the show enters syndication and airs on TNT.
Or better yet, stop quoting that stupid fucking thread in here. If I wanted to read what illiterates thought of the latest episode, I know where to go.
Or keep quoting them every other post, better that than the millionth reiteration of "what if the show catches up to George?!?!".
No it is, but I didn't know how to go about doing it! XD
No one here is going to help you steal. So fuck off already.
Oh sushhhh you!
Pai Pai Master
Banned
He's telling you that becuase it's a bannable offense to ask people how to steal TV content. Read the FAQ. Take the hint already.
Fidelis Hodie
Infidelis Cras
Yep.
Poor lad doesn't even know what's coming.
For the mods are full and dark of terrors
Morrigan Stark
Arrogant Smirk
Huh?Fix your post in #5276!
Wait, I'm not ridiculing anyone. I'm merely enjoying their speculation, whether it's accurate or not. I'm certainly not mocking anyone for speculating one way or another, I mean most of us who read the books were surprised at many plot twists too and speculated wrong about a lot of things. And sometimes, we guessed right too. It's part of the fun.
pulga
Banned
Or better yet, stop quoting that stupid fucking thread in here. If I wanted to read what illiterates thought of the latest episode, I know where to go.
Or keep quoting them every other post, better that than the millionth reiteration of "what if the show catches up to George?!?!".
But, please, tell us how you really feel
edit: awww you edited out your rant looooool
You quoted Mission's post that contains a spoiler.
Morrigan Stark
Arrogant Smirk
Oh, right. I was looking at what I wrote and ignored what I quoted. Duh. Sorry, fixed.
lol. Sure we can, but some people think that we're "ridiculing" them, for some reason. It's not like anyone said "lol they're such idiots look at how wrong they are", so I have no idea why s/he would say that...
pulga
Banned
Now we can't even discuss non book reader speculation? What a bunch of fucking babies
Fuck that, just look at this exchange going on right now
SeanR1221One confusing thing from last night....so Rob is going to ask the Frays for help? The same family he screwed over by marrying a different woman than he was supposed to? Err....[/QUOTE said:
pulga
Banned
Am I? Im just saying I love the speculation going on, not teasing what the fallout, if any, is gonna be. But sure Ill spoiler it just because people are getting prissy.
I mean, shouldnt this be the free for all show thread for people whom already know whats up?
Honestly didn't think I'd be saying this after after the first couple of episodes this season but the show has really been winning be back over with the latest couple of episodes. I still don't think it will ever be as good as in season 1 just because the narrative is so sprawling now that it's hard to have any focus or momentum, but I have been finding myself thoroughly captivated and entertained which is a lot more than I can say for season 2. The quality isn't as even as I'd like, still usually one or two of scenes an episode which drag it down a bit but there has been a lot of genuinely fantastic stuff of late.
I am feel like they are getting through some of the content much quicker than I expected which has been great for the pace of the show but has me a little concerned for the future. For example if they continue to tell Dany's story at this pace they will finish all of her ASoS material by the end of season 3, and [general]
. Jaime/Brienne also feels way ahead of schedule.
Finally, one minor book confusion. Is Loras not a king's guard in the show or are they just ignoring the fact that they aren't supposed to marry?
I am feel like they are getting through some of the content much quicker than I expected which has been great for the pace of the show but has me a little concerned for the future. For example if they continue to tell Dany's story at this pace they will finish all of her ASoS material by the end of season 3, and [general]
by god her story doesn't need padding any more than it already is
Finally, one minor book confusion. Is Loras not a king's guard in the show or are they just ignoring the fact that they aren't supposed to marry?
He should have thought about sieging Casterly Rock much sooner. Would have given Karstark his vengeance that he wanted in the first place.
Fucking amen. I pay for HBO, if every stealing asshole paid what I pay we could have 13 episode seasons with dragons all over the place. Instead we get 10 episode seasons with dragons spending time in canvas covered wicker boxes. Real shit costs, fuck off.
http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/125549
But if you screw up and post something outside of a spoiler tag that was originally tagged then that will be your fault.
- Status