Pixel art never bothered me but maybe that's because I grew up with the nes as my first console. I wonder if people who didn't grow up in the 8-16 bit eras are more or less inclined to accept that style than those who grew up in the 3d polygonal eras. Shovel Knight sat between 8-16 bit era visuals and i'll be damned that was easily one of the best games i played last year.
or maybe i'm just into playing good games and that stuff doesn't matter to me *pushes his glasses up, crosses his arms**
I grew up on the NES, I'm also glad we left it behind. Early 2D graphics are just as ugly as early 3D graphics.