Fantastapotamus
Wrong about commas, wrong about everything
I agree so much with this I want to hug youSee I was worried it was going to go the other way and be a RBG choice like Mass Effect 3.
And yeah Eredin really isn't an important character, but the core of that game is the Geralt/Ciri relationship. Having the entire ending pivot on the small moments and ways Geralt treated her over the course of the game was exactly the right way to handle that in my opinion.
Having Geralt be either a broken shell or a proud father by the game's end felt more impactful than other RPGs where I'm fundamentally altering world states.