I've never felt bothered by any of the guys going in on things - including stuff I really like. Even Jeff is quite mild (by internet standards) and funny with it. I guess it's one of those things that some people are more sensitive to than others - like when a comedian starts spouting offensive things you know they don't really think. If it's entertaining, anything goes IMO.
Than again, I think Witcher 1 is better than Witcher 2 and Bioshock Infinity was a fantastic game that improve upon the underwhelming Bioshock. Opinions, hey?