There should just be an Ubisoft category for Ubisoft Open World Action/Adventure games where all Ubisoft Open World Action/Adventure games can go to be forgotten. Except AC4 Black Flag of course, because, y'know, everyone liked that one.
(For the sake of transparency I will admit that I have never played an Ubisoft Open World Action/Adventure game.)
Is dark souls 2 even on the hook for most disappointing anyway? Vinny and patrick seemed to have liked it, and brad is just waiting for the PC version AKA getting too addicted to DOTA 2.
Being revolutionary (like Dark Souls 1) vs. being evolutionary (as with the sequel), I think, dampened a lot of the evangelical praise for the game. Plus there were definite design problems in the game, even though the core gameplay was maintained. Not to mention the PC delay and downgrade complaints that dampened the excitement around release.
The real shame will be Divinity: Original Sin getting snubbed because none of them except Patrick (I think) finished it.
That is a revolutionary video game of 2014, complete with evangelical praise; most everyone that plays it becomes a fanatical endorser. Though I do recall Brad "Filibuster" Shoemaker enjoying the game, so there
is still hope... (you can do it, rudds!)