You do realize if they gave us Halo 2, there'd be something wrong with it according to everyone (even if it was a perfect recreation) and somehow we'd have an entire Halo 2 CE bitching thread right?
I mean, if 343 touches it someone is bound to have a mild heart attack.
Let's not go toward exaggerated hyperbole about hypothetical situations. Why would there be anything wrong it "according to someone"? Especially if it's a perfect recreation.
Of course people will be wary of 343 Industries now. They gave them the benefit of the doubt that Halo would be in good hands before. With Halo 4, we know it and now 'they' know it, that it didn't pan out. Let's not kid ourselves, they did a hell of a job with the aging hardware, but the story is god-awful and confusing and makes little sense. The writing it very poor, the characters are badly written. Even sound direction is bad. Sure listening to a lossless soundtrack is good, except when it's in game, at parts its too loud, others too quiet. Doesn't match what's happening etc. You have a campaign that is far too linear, A.I. that is ridiculously poor, it's utterly forgettable. I hated Halo 2's campaign, but by God do I still remember it like the back of my hand.
The way you wrote your response has me curious. You make it seem like halo fans are unreasonable and as if we're throwing 343 under the proverbial 'bus', as if our complaints aren't valid. I'm just junior, but I can remember who posted what. People said from the start this infinity halo would be a clusterfuck, it is. You have perhaps the least played halo game ever. Especially when it's barely 3 months post launch. When guys like Ghaleon leave and decide to never make an OT for Halo again, you knows you've fucked up.
One post of yours I remember is when you said Reach UI was tired and bland and you were glad 343 were taking a new direction, that it looked fresh etc. How did that work out?
http://m.neogaf.com/showpost.php?p=39616244
The post above yours by Seance and others clearly talked about the UI was crap, that it's vertical baseball card style UI is confusing, doesn't tell you about party details and then you say you don't understand the hatred.