Indeed, I've watched the EE of FOTR, and quite honestly I'd take the theatrical version. FOTR didn't need anything, I only *liked* a couple of the added scenes, most of them were just useless. It was perfect as it was originally cut.
TTT on the other hand has severe pacing and editing problems...that and the fact that Peter Jackson can't direct massive battles scenes worth shit. Helm's deep was just boring. It was a mistake to give so much importance to it, the whole movie leads up this huge, uninteresting event. I would rather have more character development. Anything, really, but that.
ROTK suffers from the same problems.
