-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
They're not allowed to respond.
Unrivaled18
Neo Member
I started playing it today and played around the first 6 hours.
So far I give the game a 9.5 out of 10. It's everything I wanted out of a Harry Potter game and really I haven't gotten into the meat of the game as I have been doing a lot of side quests.
I'll deduct it .5 because it had a glitch once where everyone of the characters got demon eyes where I had to save and reboot the app. But just a minor issue that was fixed fast.
I love exploring Hogwarts and I will say it does cater to the LBGT and transgender community with some of the characters. It made sure to be very inclusive. Too bad some of those people will never give it a chance.
So far I give the game a 9.5 out of 10. It's everything I wanted out of a Harry Potter game and really I haven't gotten into the meat of the game as I have been doing a lot of side quests.
I'll deduct it .5 because it had a glitch once where everyone of the characters got demon eyes where I had to save and reboot the app. But just a minor issue that was fixed fast.
I love exploring Hogwarts and I will say it does cater to the LBGT and transgender community with some of the characters. It made sure to be very inclusive. Too bad some of those people will never give it a chance.
rofif
Can’t Git Gud
It's strange. I bet they cover tons of games they didn't get code for... and before release often.
Here, the game released on wednesday. Not friday. If they wanted, they would've analysis done already
Grizzled Ghost
Member
If you didn't know, that line (and many others) are a nod to Brad Neely's hilarious "Wizard People, Dear Readers", a dubbed over narration of the first movie. It's all up on YouTube if you're interested.
Haha, yeah. A Scottish boarding school in the 1800's has on staff a Korean, an Indian, a Japanese, a Chinese, a middle easterner, and a Ugandan. Funny because a 100 years later, it's just a bunch of white British people.
Bartski
Gold Member
15 Hours With Hogwarts Legacy: Magical Surface, Rotten Core
The discourse around the Harry Potter game has encompassed J.K. Rowling’s rancid politics and the role of criticism itself
kotaku.com
Yoboman
Member
Honestly a billionaire throwing legal threats around because of twitter words is weak as fuck. Why are we all overlooking shitty behaviour because of politics?
ShadowNate
Member
Sorry, can you clarify what you think the shitty behavior is in this situation.
Because if you can, I want to read how that sentence will turn out for you.
Because if you can, I want to read how that sentence will turn out for you.
Unknown Soldier
Member
One of the biggest failures of political discourse today is the implication that the richer you are, the fewer rights you should have. AKA "Eat the Rich". None of the people currently preaching this philosophy know any history. Class warfare usually works out the worst for the lower classes in all of recorded history.
winjer
Gold Member
She didn't threaten to sue him over nothing. He's has been defaming her with baseless accusations.
If it takes legal action to make him behave like a grown up, then so be it.
Goalus
Member
Not_sure_if_serious.gif
If you're a HP fan you've no choice but to play. For everyone else. . . it's ok. Stories and vice direction are far better than they have any right to be and the world is incredible.
. . . that said it is a big standard open world. Hopefully with the games success they try to do something more imaginative next game (there's a ton of game systems that are just absent here they would have made the game far more immersive).
Bonsaibäumchen
Member
Which language are you playing this game in? Because the german voice acting seems really underwhelming?
I beg to differ about the stories. Aside from the combat which is kinda better then expected. (Once you have enough spells and know how to use and combine them)
The game doesn't offer much Lore, the lore thats in there is neglectable, the dialogues and side missions are completly underwhelming and lame.
And those that invented/wrote and scripted the "puzzle quests" (including the merlin ones) should go back to kindergarden because these they are so fucking obvious and easy its pure cringe seeing them referred to as Riddles by the npcs/lore of the game.
Sure exploring hogwarts is nice. But aside from that the game seriously lacks in many areas.
And before you ask, I've read all the books and watched the movies and liked the lore of HP. But this game isna huge letdown.
Last edited:
Yoboman
Member
She has way more rights than random twitter user wdym? As shown by her being able to wave around the legal threats against his free speech, no matter how much you disagree with it
And let's say George Soros decided to start legal proceedings against every baseless conspiracy he is accused of?
Sorry but people should be allowed to same dumb shit online without some rich overlord crushing them
Warnen
Don't pass gaas, it is your Destiny!
Free speech does not equal free of consequences
transformer
Member
JK Rowlings response is precisely NOT overlooking shitty behavior and discourse because of politics. You should be pleased with her response.
RafterXL
Member
Wrong.
First off, libel and slander aren't "free speech". Making allegations and lying in order to hurt a reputation or harm their business is illegal. The fact that she has enough money to go after people who do this isn't a problem.
Frankly, more people should sue the fuck out of these idiots when they blatantly lie and distort the truth to try and destroy people online. Maybe the internet would be a better place if these people were actually held accountable for their lies. Isn't that their motto anyway? "Freedom of speech does not mean freedom from accountability"?
And, yes, even George Soros or Donald Trump or any other shithead deserves to be free from people using lies to try and harm them.
Take a guess.
Well this is the internet - that is your right.
As someone coming from nearly zero awareness of "the Wizarding World" I wouldn't say the game "doesn't offer much lore" in the slightest. There is lore all over the place (it is literally a gameplay element). Is all of it high fallutin and impenetrable like a Dark Souls? No. Because of course it isn't. It's lore from a children's book placed into a children's game. This also extends to everything else: this is a kids game. You are not meant to be stymied in this game, you are supposed to succeed. The "Divine Beasts" dungeons are about as puzzling as you're gonna get, but even those are fool proof as the MC constantly reminds you what you should be doing. Anyone honestly critiquing the game knows this and isn't trying to enforce N++ level difficulty as a core piece of the gameplay.
. . .and not for nothing, but you haven't really disagreed with what I said (particularly for someone who isn't a great fan of the IP).
I wasn't.
I'd say then, you're probably the atypical HP fan in regards to response to this game. Not at all improbable, but also doesn't take away from my original comment (in general): "If you're a HP fan you've (probably) no choice but to play."
Foilz
Banned
I absolutely love the game but my god is there so many glitches. Quests not finishing, objects getting stuck in things, npcs turning retarded. I was trying to find rocco co or whatever it's name was and the boxes you need to open the door were floating in the air. It took me like 20 min to get the box new the floor to open the door
Astral Dog
Member
Suddendly cancel culture is wrong when it works against them
Grizzled Ghost
Member
I guess I must just be stupid then because the optional Depulso dungeons took some serious thinking on my part.
Just did that one today, missed it on my first playthrough. It was really cool.
CherryFalls
Banned
Gamespot dropped their video propaganda 'review' - 6/10
Last edited:
Grizzled Ghost
Member
There are at least 2 more that open up after the quest that I found quite a bit trickier. Game doesn't really point them out but they'll be white dots on the Hogwarts map screen.
RafterXL
Member
No one cares what they have to say at this point. They're tainted for how they handled this game and they waited too long to take their shot of knocking the game down a peg or two. There are 84 reviews now, this review is pissing in the wind.
It's hilarious how poorly all of these clowns handled this situation. They were completely unprepared and all they've done is hurt their own reputations and the trans movement in general.
winjer
Gold Member
You have to learn something about the real world, you can't just insult and lie about other people like that, without consequences.
Doesn't matter if it's a billionaire or a poor person. This is not some case of some rich person oppressing freedom of speech.
Insults and lies are not covered within the concept of freedom of speech.
Hugare
Member
Fucking ridiculous
Why even bother at this point? See how many people in the coments are disagreing about the score
It's doing more harm than good to them by releasing their review. Should have stayed quiet.
SegaSnatcher
Member
Cowards couldn't even name the reviewer. Maybe don't review games on a big gaming site if you need to stay anon.
sendit
Member
Agreed.
With that said. I am now rushing through the game (40+ hours of gameplay time so far). The gameplay loop was good for the first 10 hours. However, It's now become an exhaustive effort similar to Assassin's Creed's gameplay loop.
Last edited:
FunkMiller
Member
Because it’s not really about JK Rowling. It’s about other women without her power and influence saying the same things she is, and having their lives ruined. She’s doing this to help protect them. She’s said as much.
Urban
Member
they really tried to hate the game.
Dynasty8
Member
Lost all respect. They didn't have the balls to show who reviewed it, instead it just says "Gamespot Staff".
Perfectly fine if someone doesn't like the game, but anyone with half a brain could tell how biased this review is. Gamespot lost all its credibility.
Dr. Claus
Banned
What do you expect from a site who couldn't even properly review a child-focused platformer without failing to do the most basic of challenges? (Spongebob: Battle for Bikini Bottom Rehydrated)
They have been a fucking joke for ages.
Just hope that people start to see reality and stop giving dipshits like these the time and attention they so desperately crave. Same with sites like opencritic and metacritic that openly compile these reviews from mental degenerates.
Fuz
Banned
I mean, is anyone surprised?Uh oh
Last edited:
semiconscious
Member
they were banking on the game being bad, & just blowing it off along with everyone else. when they discovered it wasn't, they became conflicted & confused...
LordCBH
Member
Nah. Her being rich as fuck doesn’t change the rights she’s afforded. It’s even weaker as fuck to call people you disagree with Nazis. Not a single one of these cucks would recognize an actual Nazi today even if it was leading them into the gas chambers.
Dr. Claus
Banned
The only one overlooking behavior here because of politics is *you*. I get you agree with this manchilds shitty behavior, but that says more about *you* than it does her. She is simply following basic libel laws.
Why do I get the feeling that you are so against her doing this because you acted in similar fashion to this pathetic ingrate that is trying desperately to walk back what they said?
DeaDPo0L84
Member
SafeOrAlone
Banned
I am relieved but will continue to make fun of his baby tantrum.
Heimdall_Xtreme
Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
How is it possible that it runs so badly with 16 GB of RAM???
I just want to see what the Switch version is like... It's going to be hilarious.
La versión de Nintendo Switch va a estar de la chiflada.
Strider Highwind
Banned
They released a patch today for it and the game performs terribly now even on a 4090. I tried it on my system with a 4080 too.
Even with Frame Generation on, where I was getting a locked 144fps(143 of course) with everything kicked up to ultra including raytracing, the game now struggles to run at 60 fps consistently lol. They effectively broke the progress they'd made over the first 2 patches
More bugs too with random characters floating disappearing, or lines of dialogue just starting(It literally started playing the dialogue from a story mission...that was located across the map from me and I didnt even start at one point)
Even with Frame Generation on, where I was getting a locked 144fps(143 of course) with everything kicked up to ultra including raytracing, the game now struggles to run at 60 fps consistently lol. They effectively broke the progress they'd made over the first 2 patches
More bugs too with random characters floating disappearing, or lines of dialogue just starting(It literally started playing the dialogue from a story mission...that was located across the map from me and I didnt even start at one point)
rofif
Can’t Git Gud
Stupid but maybe reinstall the driver now to re trigger shader compilation?
Strider Highwind
Banned
Bro it's doing the shader compilation, but it gets stuck at like 10 percent then the bar shoots finished real fast and voila, games weird lol
I'm almost done reinstalling the whole game. Nvidia DID put out a patch centered around redfall today, i hope that garbage game isn't sabotaging all games
ShadowNate
Member
Runs ok for me after the patch. feels smoother and better performing but I'm not using RTX.
I am also not on the latest (May) NVidia driver yet. Probably the one before it. And I did not do any manual workarounds like replacing DLSS files or mess with configuration files.
I am also not on the latest (May) NVidia driver yet. Probably the one before it. And I did not do any manual workarounds like replacing DLSS files or mess with configuration files.
King Dazzar
Member
Apologies to bring this topic back to life. But after some feedback on how the PS5 or XSX (I'd prefer PS5 due to haptics & triggers) version run in the 60fps modes? I know its been getting quite a few patches over time so wondering how it is these days, specifically in 60fps mode? It had quite a lot of frame pacing issues etc reported on launch which put me off... how does it look in its performance mode too?
Cheers.
Cheers.
Heimdall_Xtreme
Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
Where is the Nintendo switch versión???
Warner bros will give us another MEME like MK 1 xD
Warner bros will give us another MEME like MK 1 xD
Big Baller
Al Pachinko, Konami President
Ask DFweekly
Similar threads
- Locked