Horizon Zero Dawn - Preview Thread [Up: All Previews Live]

Game came out 6 years ago dude. standards have changed

crazy enough - this vo is much better and even the 2011* engine being used looks on par with animations compared to what we seen today with Horizon. thanks for sharing.

You're both missing the point. Having a poor bit of dialogue and voice acting in a game (assuming it's an outlier) is pretty inconsequential in the grand scheme of things — especially if it's a side-quest.
 
How can we dance when our earth is turning?
PerkySpitefulHoverfly.gif


How do we sleep while our beds are burning?
RepentantJoyousCobra.gif

When ya song come on at the club and the molly just hit you.
 
Point to me an example with as attrocius dialogue. I don't even care about the animation. Just point out one witcher 3 cutscene that has dialogue that is as horrible as what is being discussed. I still hold out hope for this game and hope people like it, but that dialogue was pure garbage.

I thought Triss's voice acting in general was questionable. Same for Geralt, really. If it weren't for the conceit that he was supposed to be an "emotionless witcher", I would even go as far as to label it unacceptable.

That dialogue wasn't as bad as you're giving it credit for. On top of that, you're viewing it entirely outside of its context, and AFTER you're basically being primed to think it's shit by everyone else saying it's shit.
 
No, but the majority of it was good. Even if the acting was a bit hammy, the content of the conversations and emotions expressed were believeable in the context of what was going on.

The writing in the cutscene everyone is talking about seems like fanfic stuff and the VA seems like people were just given the script without any context as to what was being discussed.

So now we comparing a couple scenes from a preview event to a whole game? Can we see me before writing it off or nah?
 
Looks like a your standard RPG. The only thing that stood out was that awful Brom cutscene. Everything else was just what you would expect only prettier.
 
Nah, you just making up shit to justify your bias. You don't know what the game entails, so your extrapolation means nothing.

What bias? I already said that I'm buying the game in this very thread xD Also I would have you take down the attitude down a notch, if at all possible.

My extrapolation means a lot to me. I look at a game and make an assessment based on everything they've shown so far of it's gameplay mechanics (not the story etc, but gameplay mechanics). If they're purposefully hiding some huge game changing gameplay mechanics (on a moment-to-moment level) then yes I will have been wrong but it would also be a pretty strange marketing strategy.
 
So now we comparing a couple scenes from a preview event to a whole game? Can we see me before writing it off or nah?
I wonder what he actually typed.
The writing in the cutscene everyone is talking about seems like fanfic stuff and the VA seems like people were just given the script without any context as to what was being discussed.
Point to me an example with as attrocius dialogue. I don't even care about the animation. Just point out one witcher 3 cutscene that has dialogue that is as horrible as what is being discussed. I still hold out hope for this game and hope people like it, but that dialogue was pure garbage.
Just point out one witcher 3 cutscene that has dialogue that is as horrible as what is being discussed.
to one witcher 3 cutscene
So now we comparing ... to a whole game?
hrm
 
Im loving Aloy. Her voice actress is fantastic. In fact all the voice acting is great apart from Brom. But he's playing a schizophrenic having a pretty serious episode so I can't blame the voice actor for hamming it up a bit.
 
Combat against human enemies looks disappointing due to a lack of visceral hit reactions, granted the dude in that video was literally constantly jumping in space before each arrow fired.
 
I thought Triss's voice acting in general was questionable. Same for Geralt, really. If it weren't for the conceit that he was supposed to be an "emotionless witcher", I would even go as far as to label it unacceptable.

That dialogue wasn't as bad as you're giving it credit for. On top of that, you're viewing it entirely outside of its context, and AFTER you're basically being primed to think it's shit by everyone else saying it's shit.

You're being too generous. There's zero context needed for that to see it's plain badly animated and voiced.

I'll give you Triss. Worst voice acting in the game by a wide margin. Geralt's fit the character of someone stripped of emotion. I never heard a line uttered that wasn't in line with that, and instead sounded flat bad. It was always decent at worst.
 
I think this voice acting and dialogue is better than Horizon's, and while the animation is also bad, it looks more consistent than Horizon's does.
It's not that it looks more consistent, it's that the fidelity of Deus Ex MD isn't so high that it's genuinely producing an uncanny valley effect.
 
The voice acting is fine.

The animation and facework is bad though. And it's been bad since the beginning. What's going on there....
 
So now we comparing a couple scenes from a preview event to a whole game? Can we see me before writing it off or nah?

Do you really thin the side quest animation and VA will change this close to release in the game?

Also, I do not think it was just the one cutscene people are referencing. I don't remember the name of the character since the video was taken down, but I think it was the one with Kral or something similar. The voice acting was just as terrible in that scene.

Again, I hope the gameplay is good. I hope the game is good. But just because you like something doesn't mean that it is without faults.
 
What's the point? You want me to be optimistic about this game because we haven't seen everything yet?

Why are you so confident in the game's quality when you haven't seen everything yet?

So you're pessimistic about anything you don't fully know of? Man, must be tough living your life expecting every day to be shit
 
If the main complaint is that it takes cues from other popular games, i think the criticism is kinda overblown

The main criticism is that it doesn't just look like it's taking cues, but rehash what I've seen a dozen times over. I enjoyed FC3, but pretty much ever since similar games just can't keep me invested. All I can see is the mechanics and UI hand-holding designed to cater to the lowest common denominator. Even if some of it can be disabled, the game is probably designed relying on them to take out frustration that will otherwise ensue. So I'm stuck with following markers to gather shit to upgrade my shit to progress. It's a pointless time sink.

Essentially I feel like this game is more like this altered image of BB, when I would prefer it to be what BB actually is like.


Witcher 3 does follow some of the same boring open world mechanics, but its saving grace is the world and its lore in addition to the quests and characters. This is something I highly doubt Horizon will be able to replicate. I'm still hoping that it'll be a step above Far Cry Primal, but I'm certainly not pre-ordering this. The core gameplay has to have a lot more going for it than all the standard open world time waster mechanics and map fillers we've seen before. And this is coming from someone who actually likes DA: Inquisition.
 
I think this voice acting and dialogue is better than Horizon's, and while the animation is also bad, it looks more consistent than Horizon's does.

I agree about the voice acting and dialogue but completely disagree with the animations. It's just outright much worse than Horizon's. That's not to say Horizon's is great, and all of these types of games are going to be pretty inconsistent with them, but I still find Horizon's a pretty big step up overall.
 
Looks spectacular. I'm always amazed how Sony's 1st Party studios constantly put out the best visuals on any system this gen. Horizon seems no different.
 
So you're pessimistic about anything you don't fully know of? Man, must be tough living your life expecting every day to be shit

It's a video game dude. I'm seeing this, thinking about a possible purchase. Waiting for more preview coverage and actual reviews.
 
Top Bottom