Night Angel
Member
I never liked In N Out. Too little meat, too much lettuce, and their fries are fucking gross. Your options are soggy or burnt to a crisp. And don't get me started on Animal Style (who wants mustard cooked onto their meat, bleh).
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
In-N-Out Burgers not coming east. Steak N Shake still secretly the best.
- Thread starter norm9
- Start date
schwabdizzle
Banned
St. Louis has Steak and Shake, Freddy's Steak Burgers, 5 Guys, and we are getting 2 Shake Shacks (1 opening next month).
finalflame
Banned
Then don't get lettuce or ask for light lettuce. I agree on the fries, I've never liked 'em. Animal Style (or just asking for mustard fried patties) is delicious, tho.
Chezzymann
Member
Steak n shake never fills me up. I could eat 3 of those burgers and still be hungry. It's like they're made of air.
perfectchaos007
Member
The thing about In-N-Out for me has always been price, consistency, and the fact it has a very particular taste that you can only get at In-N-Out. It's very good, but it'll always lose out to more expensive places like Five Guys in terms of pure taste, IMO. I've missed it dearly since leaving California. For the record, Dick's in Seattle is not a suitable substitute -- it's just shittier for the same price.
Look at this:
It's a < $4 burger. Come on now.
With that said, I've never liked In-N-Out's fries, well done or not.
Ketchup instead of in-n-outs signiture spread? Gross dude
finalflame
Banned
Not mine, it's a buddy's snap
My orders are always:4x4
mustard grilled patties
spread sauce
chopped grilled onions
whole grilled onions
chopped chillies
ONLY
Boom.
Uno Venova
Banned
I wish they were here on price alone.
But I mean, they're so many great burger joints in NYC, not having one chain isn't really hurting much.
But I mean, they're so many great burger joints in NYC, not having one chain isn't really hurting much.
PlayALLtheGames
Banned
This place only one has location a couple of blocks from where I live. If you ate here, you would forget In-N-Out fucking exists:
http://www.eatbigbuns.com/menu.html
There are places like this all over the East Coast. We don't need no fucking In-N-Out.
Plus Shake Shack, Ray's Hell Burger, etc. though I find those overrated as well.
Big Buns, bitches.
http://www.eatbigbuns.com/menu.html
There are places like this all over the East Coast. We don't need no fucking In-N-Out.
Plus Shake Shack, Ray's Hell Burger, etc. though I find those overrated as well.
Big Buns, bitches.
Googling the name, Big Buns is like twice as expensive as In-N-Out. Obviously it should be better at that price.
Days like these...
Have a Blessed Day
I honestly find their burgers bland. Probably McDonald's is the only chain whose burgers are more bland. Like you said to each their own
finalflame
Banned
No way any of these burgers are less than $10. Stop comparing accessible fast food burgers to gourmet burgers that are 3x the price.
This is why I just get the fries animal style too.
Shit's delicious.
Also everything should be prefaced by the price of In n Out.
If I'm buying a $8 burger from The Habit, it better fucking well be better than most any other burger. That's an entire meal at In n Out otherwise.
oh hell yes
finalflame
Banned
Smothering them in spread sauce and cheese makes it ok. When I do get the fries it's definitely animal style, and when I get a shake it's always Neapolitan.
Thanks! Will do!
Mister Wolf
Gold Member
The fries have always been In-N-Outs weak link but that doesn't bother me because I always swap them out for a Flying Dutchman. I could eat three of those by themselves as a meal.
Fenderputty
Banned
Any time I see someone criticize in n out fries I think of how our society is probably conditioned to like processed garbage.
Night Angel
Member
That's one way to justify liking bad fries, I guess.
J_ToSaveTheDay
Member
I don't live in a state that has In-N-Out, but when I traveled and tried it, I was amazed at the price-vs-quality of it. It's ridiculously cheap and reasonably great. Tried the animal style on my first visit, btw, which is pretty unique compared to the options I typically have available.
That comment about Five Guys vs In-N-Out for price is ridiculously off base. I just had Five Guys yesterday and it took weeks to psych myself up to pay that much -- they make my favorite burgers out of the range that I have available locally, but I could probably order my In-N-Out order 3 times for a single meal at Five Guys... C'mon.
That comment about Five Guys vs In-N-Out for price is ridiculously off base. I just had Five Guys yesterday and it took weeks to psych myself up to pay that much -- they make my favorite burgers out of the range that I have available locally, but I could probably order my In-N-Out order 3 times for a single meal at Five Guys... C'mon.
Not mine, it's a buddy's snap
4x4
mustard grilled patties
spread sauce
chopped grilled onions
whole grilled onions
chopped chillies
ONLY
Boom.
that sounds like a beautiful disaster
but also the thought of eating a 4x4 is causing me pain
The fries are literally a potato and oil. That's how it's supposed to taste. I stan for McD's, but their fried aren't how regular fries are supposed to taste.
When we first moved here we were suggested Dick's. We went once. We had no idea why people thought it was any good. Even the fries were not so good (I think they were soggy but that was so long ago the only impression I remember was that we didn't like it).
pretty done
Member
If I wanted regular I wouldn't be eating fast food in the first place!
McDonalds fries are some crack
Fenderputty
Banned
That's one way to justify liking processed shit, I guess. I mean ... liking a fry is subjective. You can't argue freshness.
TheOfficeMut
Unconfirmed Member
For real. Like natural fries have to be bad for the sake of being natural. You can season that shit. At the very least some salt and pepper. Just because their fries are fresh does not excuse them for being crap.
finalflame
Banned
Typically got one on the way home to enter into a food coma and watch TV, and it definitely got the job done. Man, all this In-N-Out talk is REALLY making me miss it =(
Dick's is really not that good. I have a Dick's literally underneath my balcony (Broadway/Cap Hill) and the smell of the patties being freshly grilled is actually nice sometimes, and I'll try to run down and grab a fresh burger around that time, when they're a bit better. With that said, the fries ARE soggy and unremarkable and the fact they don't allow any modifications makes the cheeseburger a bit too bland and the Deluxe a bit too ... busy. I'm not a huge fan of the mayo/chopped pickle spread, but for those who like it a lot I can see it being better.
Dick's does become about 5x better when you're drunk at 1am, though. Still not good enough to come even close to In-N-Out any other time.
Coco and Curry House should spread out more I agree. And heck with just burgers, why can't we get some cheap and fast okonomiyaki places in the US? Or some empanadas or salteñas.
And you guys are being some serious fry apologists, they don't taste fresh, they taste starchy and unseasoned. If you have to put animal sauce glop on them to hide their lack of potato flavor, then you know there's something off with the recipe. We can cook better fries at home than what you get at In N Out.
TheBryanJZX90
Member
As someone who grew up in St. Louis and lives in LA, Steak n Shake ain't shit. Not really on the same level as any of the other regional burger chains that always come up. The Patty melt is good though.
half a moon
Banned
I want a fookin burger mates
phoisgood495
Member
In-n-Out is the most overrated burger shop in the nation. My entire family were so excited to go when we went to California, all took one bite then felt betrayed and lied to.
Sure they're cheap, but they're no better than any half decent burger place, and their fries are painfully mediocre. I still prefer Five Guys by far.
Sure they're cheap, but they're no better than any half decent burger place, and their fries are painfully mediocre. I still prefer Five Guys by far.
Basketball
Member
You know who secretly has the best burger
fucking Crazy wings in Georgia
fucking Crazy wings in Georgia
katsubento
Member
I tried a Steak and Shake last year in SC. Wasn't too bad.
Again, we have nothing so we have to envy all the places people say aren't all that.
Again, we have nothing so we have to envy all the places people say aren't all that.
lol. Betrayed and lied to.
TAJ
Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.
We have avocado groves. If you buy direct from the growers then avocados are cheap AF.
Stay losing.
Yes. Plenty of places make their fries with only fresh potatoes, oil, and salt and they're delicious. In-N-Out's fries suck because they suck at making fries, it has nothing to do with the freshness.
#sorrynotsorry
Member
In-n-Out's only real competition in the price range is Whataburger (and even that is more expensive, but definitely better and at least still cheap).
phoisgood495
Member
I'm obviously exaggerating, but In-N-Out is mediocre. The way people talk about it you would think it's the second coming of Jesus.
Jailer of Hope
Member
I had a Steak N Shake burger for the first time a few days ago and thought it was okay. The bun was good but the patty was overcooked.
Teren_Kanan
Member
I will fucking never understand the love for Five Guys.
It's overpriced garbage. It's any burger I could make in a fucking skillet on a stove, cept for like 7 dollars. Absolutely nothing exceptional about their burgers.
To each their own though.
It's overpriced garbage. It's any burger I could make in a fucking skillet on a stove, cept for like 7 dollars. Absolutely nothing exceptional about their burgers.
To each their own though.
Crimson_Echidna
Banned
I just wish Steak N Shake had better fries. Shoe String Fries are an abomination.
GKSilKamina
Member
All I need is Steak n' Shake. Ten bucks goes a long way there.
perfectchaos007
Member
I disagree. thicc fries have too much potato. I like the fried grease/potato ratio of skinny fries better
Similar threads
- Poll