• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

July Wrasslin' |OT| All this G1 talk is making me Climax.

S

Syder

Member
Zach said:
Okada/Cody deserves at least nine starz.
Click to expand...
gedo.gif
 
H

HashtagLapsed

Member
For me, Cody/Okada was 3.5 at best. Everyone has their preferences though and Meltzer usually says he just gives it a rating depending on how it makes him feel at the time. Nothing to get worked up about.
 
T

Tall4Life

Member
It's one dude's ratings for a fake sport good lord what does it matter how close it is to another match

do y'all want "I give this a low to a medium 4.5 stars" instead now?
 
E

excelsiorlef

Member
Heroman said:
What in the world is this?
Click to expand...

Nothing you're right

All matches are basically the same when you consider it. So I shouldn't be upset I mean Okada, Jinder, Hornswoggle, Omega... They're all just not that different from each other.

Nak vs Roode was better than Okada vs Cody though
 
E

excelsiorlef

Member
I mean it's not like I'm mad at him or something I just thing giving it 4.5 is absurd.


And Meltzer can say his ratings don't mean anything to him but he's basically the Roger Ebert of wrestling.
 
H

Heroman

Banned
excelsiorlef said:
Nothing you're right

All matches are basically the same when you consider it. So I shouldn't be upset I mean Okada, Jinder, Hornswoggle, Omega... They're all just not that different from each other.

Nak vs Roode was better than Okada vs Cody though
Click to expand...
Using math or whatever that was to compare matches what is this a review thread?
 
D

DMczaf

Member
Raw64life said:
No Mercy the GOAT, but as the first 3D wrestling game I ever played this game blew me away when I first played it. To go from RAW and Wrestlemania: The Arcade Game to this was just mind blowing.
Click to expand...

I would book my territory through that game

And script my matches
 
S

Syder

Member
HashtagLapsed said:
For me, Cody/Okada was 3.5 at best. Everyone has their preferences though and Meltzer usually says he just gives it a rating depending on how it makes him feel at the time. Nothing to get worked up about.
Click to expand...
I hate that I was right about Okada/Cody being 4+ stars. I think 3.5 is a fair rating based on New Japan and Okada's standards but I was expecting 4 stars from Meltzer because of his bias.

First half of the match was 2 star, second half was worthy of 4 stars.
 
H

HashtagLapsed

Member
Syder said:
I hate that I was right about Okada/Cody being 4+ stars. I think 3.5 is a fair rating based on New Japan and Okada's standards but I was expecting 4 stars from Meltzer because of his bias.

First half of the match was 2 star, second half was worthy of 4 stars.
Click to expand...

Yeah I completely agree. I was going to say in my initial post, it was really only the last 1/2 of the match that was actually good and you could see Okada basically willing it to be good.

OwensIsNow said:
Man
This is such a Heroman post.
4.5 stars.
Click to expand...

Hahaha
 
F

Foggy

Member
excelsiorlef said:
I mean it's not like I'm mad at him or something I just thing giving it 4.5 is absurd.


And Meltzer can say his ratings don't mean anything to him but he's basically the Roger Ebert of wrestling.
Click to expand...

He might be seen as such but he doesn't owe people a greater standard of criticism. He's never positioned himself as a critic, he's just doing this because he's always done it. He'd probably drop them alltogether if not for an inevitable backlash. Star ratings and grades and numbered ratings were a terrible terrible mistake.
 
S

Sweeney Tom

Banned
Fox318 said:
Meltzer's piece about his father's death is a must read.

He is a fantastic writer.
Click to expand...

Agreed 100000000000 percent

That bit about the Bucks was particularly great, that tribute really meant a lot to him and the family when they really needed a reason to smile
 
A

avengers23

Banned
I saw four fluorescent light tubes on the street today.

I was tempted to pick them up and smash them on something.

Nick Gage and light tubes though?

tumblr_oj65kb9Qgw1tx8dnyo1_400.gif


Hope he doesn't die.
 
T

The Ummah

Banned
Sounds good so far 2K...can't fall for the hype yet. I need some screens and gameplay, shawty. Don't boast these new features and don't show us shit until September. I hope they don't...
 
E

excelsiorlef

Member
Foggy said:
He might be seen as such but he doesn't owe people a greater standard of criticism. He's never positioned himself as a critic, he's just doing this because he's always done it. He'd probably drop them alltogether if not for an inevitable backlash. Star ratings and grades and numbered ratings were a terrible terrible mistake.
Click to expand...

That's why I talk about him here and don't go bug him on Twitter or something :p

And bullshit he doesn't present himself as a critic, he runs review podcasts of every PPV, Raw and Smackdown and major NJPW event
 
T

Toki767

Member
excelsiorlef said:
That's why I talk about him here and don't go bug him on Twitter or something :p

And bullshit he doesn't present himself as a critic, he runs review podcasts of every PPV, Raw and Smackdown and major NJPW event
Click to expand...

It's not his fault people want to hear what he thinks of them.

Plus he probably enjoys talking about what he watches.
 
A

Anth0ny

Member
serenewarfare said:
That was already the plan. They are just moving faster on it. The new info is that they want to do a US Tour by March or April.

Meltzer is saying they are talking about doing NOLA for WM weekend.
Click to expand...

Jesus fuck, friends.


Reality is following the #5years timeline to a T.





Also, Meltzer pls. The okada bias is real ;_;
 
F

Foggy

Member
excelsiorlef said:
That's why I talk about him here and don't go bug him on Twitter or something :p

And bullshit he doesn't present himself as a critic, he runs review podcasts of every PPV, Raw and Smackdown and major NJPW event
Click to expand...

There's a crucial, but subtle difference between giving an opinion and presenting yourself as a critic. I talk about action movies on a weekly basis, but I would never present myself as a critic, just someone relating my experience to other people. I can guarantee he would scoff at the idea that he sees himself as some gateway to taste in wrestling. It's not on him that this fake sport has had such a dearth of quality critics.
 
E

excelsiorlef

Member
Toki767 said:
It's not his fault people want to hear what he thinks of them.

Plus he probably enjoys talking about what he watches.
Click to expand...

I'm sure he does.

He's still a critic. A critic is not a bad thing

Foggy said:
There's a crucial, but subtle difference between giving an opinion and presenting yourself as a critic. I talk about action movies on a weekly basis, but I would never present myself as a critic, just someone relating my experience to other people. I can guarantee he would scoff at the idea that he sees himself as some gateway to taste in wrestling. It's not on him that this fake sport has had such a dearth of quality critics.
Click to expand...

He literally reviews and gives ratings...

He's a critic... and again that's not a bad thing.


He's also a journalist
 
R

RecRoulette

Member
SomewhatGroovy

You don't know who I am, but I know where you live, and if you teach that sex-ed class so help me I will make you tap at GWF6: Great Bans of Fire Pay Per View Digital Streaming Event

HeavenlyE said:
When you see Cody/Okada got 4.5 stars and immediately rush to Wrasslegaf

giphy.gif


(Kenny/Ishii deserved 5 stars tho)
Click to expand...

Cody/Okada was as good as Bate/Dunne at NXT according to Da Meltz. I disagree, but it's his ratings, and I don't give him any money so more power to him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

August Wrasslin' |OT| I'M NOT FINISHED WITH YOU-LY
397 398 399 400 401
20K
835K
SomewhatGroovy replied
March Wrasslin' |OT| The March to Wrestlemania XXXIII!
397 398 399 400 401
20K
716K
FlammableD replied
NJPW G1 Climax 27 [OT] It's a Real-Life Tournament Arc!!!!!
47 48 49 50 51
3K
158K
Anth0ny replied
  • Locked
New Japan Pro Wrestling: G1 26 Climax |OT| Both the A and B block are clean
10
6K
oddjobs replied
October Wrasslin' |OT| Dia de los Mil Muertes
340 341 342 343 344
17K
834K
Syder replied
Top Bottom