from the F4W
The Chikara wrestling promotion, at least in name, appears to be finished, at least for the time being, following Sunday's Never Compromise iPPV event in Philadelphia.
That rather convoluted opening sentence is the result of three days' worth of digging into what the situation actually is with the 11-year-old promotion. Rumors flew online in the days prior to the event, and the most Chikara said publicly (outside an interview with promoter Mike Quackenbush on the front page of our site which was largely in character) was a two-sentence statement issued to our website last Thursday: "There is no issue regarding ownership of the CHIKARA name, brand, its assets or intellectual properties. Any speculation to the contrary is 100% false."
Quackenbush, who co-founded Chikara in 2002, has been notoriously secretive about the promotion in the past to the point where he often requested of me, when interviewing him, to ask him questions as if he was a performer with the organization and not the promoter. I knew there was zero chance of him giving me any sort of information about what was going on after the iPPV, but figured it never hurt to ask. When I e-mailed, all I received was this response:
"Hello, I am unavailable to read your message at this time."
Quackenbush appeared to have turned on an e-mail autoresponder sometime after the iPPV, likely expecting the flood of e-mails from individuals wondering about the future of the promotion. I talked to a number of people who have worked for or are working with the company and many of them would not talk about it (it was said Quackenbush made at least some of the performers sign non-disclosure agreements at the show), and those who would talk without attribution either weren't there for that particular show or had absolutely no idea what was going on.
The show-closing angle was, obviously, just an angle. During the Eddie Kingston vs. Icaraus main event for the Chikara Grand Championship, just as Icarus was about to get the submission victory and the title, Director of Fun Wink Vavasseur commanded twenty-some members of Condor Security to hit the ring, remove all the participants, tear down the set and kick all the fans out of the building. That's exactly what happened. Some fans thought being part of the show was awesome while others were very upset, some in tears, and one fan even did a diving bodypress into the door of the building and cracked the glass. He was apparently thrown back inside by the fake security and the real security proceeded to inform him that he was going to have to pay $500 for the damage. The iPPV stream abruptly ended and that was the end of that.
If you are not a Chikara fan you probably have no idea from reading that what is going on. Wait until you hear about the time travel storyline a little later. Regardless, what happened happened, and it came across as your usual wrestling storyline, just a little more in-your-face and certainly significantly more serious than any other storyline in Chikara history (Chikara as a promotion is built on fun, hence a Director of Fun commissioner role). It was a very dark angle, but some longtime Chikara followers figured, well, Chikara is heavily comic book based, and this is every comic book story climax you've ever read, where the heels do some dastardly deed and a hero must rise from the ashes to unite the babyfaces and save humanity. In fact, the titles for all the shows in the most recent season were based on the Watchmen comic book series, which is built on the same theme.
Most likely this is exactly what is going to happen, but it appears far more likely the storyline will play out on future "Wrestling Is" events, something of a Chikara offshoot that Quackenbush has his hand in. It doesn't really make much sense to play out inside Chikara anyway since Chikara has been shut down by the storyline guy in charge. The big question is whether, at the end of the day, Chikara is reborn under that name down the road, or if the various Wrestling Is groups (all of which, if you take the first letter of their theme -- Wrestling is COOL, Wrestling is HEART, Wrestling IS, Wrestling is ART, Wrestling is RESPECT, Wrestling is AWESOME -- spell the word "CHIKARA" with the exception of the "K", which most assume is a reference to Kaiju Big Battel) merge into one supergroup which eventually becomes the new Chikara. Whatever happens, there is a storyline, and it is ongoing.
It appears, however, that at this particular moment the promotion known as Chikara is dead in storyline and in real life. They canceled all of their future events Monday. Interestingly enough, most of those events were never actually booked by Chikara in the first place, although apparently people involved with Chikara had talked to at least some of the venues about future dates. This led to some fans, at least one of which is a subscriber, being pretty upset since they'd booked plane flights to attend events during work vacations this summer only to discover that, in fact, those shows will not be taking place. As noted, at least a few of the Chikara workers don't seem to know what's going on, or if they do know what's going on and aren't saying anything due to the non-disclosure, and are preparing as if there are no Chikara events booked anywhere in the near future. Some are advertising strongly for bookings via Twitter. That could be storyline, but we also heard from promoters Monday who, not as part of any storyline, were asked if there were any openings over the summer since dates they'd had planned for Chikara were no longer taking place. There were also people on the business side of things that work with the company who were caught off guard by the cancellations, meaning at least at some point they were under the impression that the shows scheduled for the rest of the year really were going to be taking place.
Interestingly, and I don't know what to make of this except that this storyline is continuing at some point somewhere, I was contacted with a statement Monday claiming that Chikara was liquidating and selling all assets, from old merchandise to the entrance ramp to audio equipment and parts of the set, and that if anyone was interested in buying they could contact, seriously, an "A. Frady" at Titor Conglomerate. Keep that name in mind.
One thing that is clear is that whatever happened Sunday, it was not something done at the last minute. Based on a number of pieces of information, including promoters who had been approached for the first time by Chikara workers in recent weeks, the specific names of all the events this season, the formation of the Wrestling Is satellite groups, and even websites devoted to the storyline Titor Conglomerate that sprung up literally in the mid-'00s, it's clear that the angle on Sunday was a long, long time in the making. I talked to people close to Quackenbush who don't have any idea where this is going, but feel that he is trying to do something big, something never done before in wrestling. I suspect there really will be no more Chikara events this year, some of the wrestlers will start working for Wrestling Is, some will go to other promotions, and the storyline will continue to evolve in some fashion. My guess is, barring a situation where Quackenbush has decided to shut down the promotion for good, perhaps a year or so down the road (maybe sooner, maybe later) the storyline will lead to a company rebirth.
Quackenbush had stated publicly in the past that the company was never a huge money-maker, and often things were tenuous, and other sources close to the group confirmed this to be the case. One person said they would have times where it was, at best, break-even, other times when they'd run a very successful event and do great DVD sales and come away with a big single-day haul, and then other days where for whatever reason, perhaps expensive fly-in foreign talent, perhaps wrong place wrong time, whatever the case, they'd come away with a big one-day loss. Their DVDs always sold well on Smart Mark Video (best-selling of any videos, in fact) and they'd had some decent numbers for the few iPPVs they ran (Sunday's show drew a sellout 600 to the Troc and the belief is they did the best iPPV numbers of any of their events to date). But we have also been told that for various reasons, not the least of which were the JoshiMania mini-tour in 2011 and National Pro Wrestling Day earlier this year being big money-losers for the company, things had been rough for awhile. There were definitely people who thought the promotion wouldn't last through 2013, and others who felt that if they could get the iPPV numbers up they'd be able to sustain. One person not affiliated with the company at all noted that the promotion was pretty niche to begin with, and while they had a very loyal following it wasn't the kind of promotion that was going to play well in terms of drawing new fans and iPPV buyers, particularly since you had to be a very hardcore fan to follow some of the longer-term storylines, particularly the time-travel odyssey that played out on the iPPV Sunday.
Basically, in storyline, Chikara was sold a few years ago to Worldwide Media Development Corporation, a subsidiary of a group called Titor Conglomerate. Titor is a reference to a guy by the name of John Titor, a message board poster (on, among things, an Art Bell BBS) from the early '00s who claimed that he was a time traveler from the year 2036. Titor told all sorts of crazy stories and made various wild predictions, none of which came true. His out was the claim that the Many Worlds theory of quantum physics was true, meaning that his going back in time had altered timelines so that his predictions took place, but on a different timeline than the one you and I and everyone else is living in.
Got all that?
So anyway, Chikara created an imaginary conglomerate based on this real-life (well, you know) time traveler, and started a storyline where, among things, Archibald Peck was sent backwards and forwards in time after being hit by Eddie Kingston's Backfist to the Future finish, which eventually led to him existing in two different timelines as, among things, a mixed martial artist and a cowboy. It only got more complicated from there. The amount of work that went into creating his angle, from the years of preparation including a No Private Armies blog that plays into the storyline that was set up in, no joke, 2007, to setting up fake webpages for Worldwide Media Development and the Titor Conglomerate (which includes a listing for W. Conrad Vavasseur, Chikara's current Director of Fun and Titor's "Executive Vice President of Acquisitions"), is almost mind-boggling. Titor also "owned" Condor Security, the group that kicked all the fans out of the building at the PPV. Vavasseur's role in the company began shortly after they did the storyline where Worldwide Media had purchased the company in January of 2011. So this was no short-term deal. As part of it, Quackenbush was in storyline kicked out of his own company after being handed an envelope by a man in an "NPA" (No Private Armies) hat, leading one to speculate that, at the end of the day, he'll be the one to return as savior in whatever form the angle takes.
So what form will it take? Perhaps, in the end, the company wasn't making enough money and Quackenbush decided to put everything on hold, an indefinite hiatus. Perhaps he pulled the trigger on an angle that had been slowly building for years, and at some point when he regroups he'll pull the trigger on the next stage of the angle and write the storyline to bring about the triumphant return of the company. If he never regroups, such is life, and the end of Chikara was at least booked as part of a long-term storyline. Or perhaps what happened was a wrestling angle that took place in an imaginary world, and because there are people aware of what is going on in the real world, two different timelines, in a great irony, got mixed up, and all the controversy and speculation is much ado about nothing.
It would be sad to think, if this really is the end, that Chikara, the promotion built on fun, promoted as family fun and overseen by a Director of Fun, did not go out with an angle where everyone was celebrating and partying and clapping and laughing and having fun, but rather with an angle that was not, in their own universe, any fun at all. Or maybe, like in all the comic books and fantasy films and really any good fiction ever written, things look bleak right now but this isn't the end, and down the road everyone will live happily ever after.